Friday, June 2, 2017

rent apartment helsinki


- [man] my question is what was the or what is the most important year in your life? (gary sighs) (laughter) - i think the most importantyear in my life was the first one because i think-- - [man] i'm talking about in business. - oh, in business. i would say the first one.

i had unbelievable bravado going into my dad's liquor store, right? i'd been working in it since i was 14 so had a lot of experience. i was a completely shit studentand my whole claim was, you know, i'm a shit student buti'm gonna be more successful than all of you when i talked to my friends. and so, like, i really talkeda lot a shit and so that first year i just rememberbeing like obsessed.

this really fun to tell you guys 'cause it's basically around the same age. i don't know if you can imagine,may be you can depending on how you roll, the i ended school i drove from boston to new jersey and worked in theliquor store that night and basically didn't stopfor seven years but let's say didn't stopin at first year. genuinely, again at this youngof an age no jersey shore,

no dating, no hanging out,no wiffleball, no nothing. 7 am, liquor store 11 pm leave every day, seven days a week. sleep on sunday 'causeit was a half a day. right? like just fucking pot committedall-in and what happened was at the end of that year thebusiness went from 3 to 10 million in the first year whichis if any of you come from a family business or it's notsuper hard to understand when you don't come from a whole,whole lot that is such a big

difference that is such a "wait a minute," that is such a "wait a minute i had to buy a car at a garage sale, "aj got a new lexus. what the fuck?" it was such a game changer soit was the first year because i think that a lotof pent-up bravado. but i'm sure i had, i'm tryingto recall, i'm sure i had, no, i definitely had, i definitely had my 1% of doubt. well what if i'mjust full of shit. what if i'm talking too muchshit, like what's gonna happen?

having that first year undermy belt and having such a crazy success it allowed, i mean you know, it's been on since then, right. it has been very difficult tolike believe in myself since. - [man 2] alright,so, would you say-- - how are you guys, howyou guys hearing this? okay? this probably better. you might get someweird chin action.

don't look.go ahead. - [man 2] would you say yourupraising and your relationships to your family as a wholecorrelates to your relationship to your employeesand how you-- - yeah. i absolutely easily with no hesitation will tell you right now that my mom has abigger impact on this culture than anybody besides me. 100%. the way i was parented andobviously the dna that i think

i took from her, yes and very weirdly and, you know, i would tell you that i saw my dad do a lot of things i don't believe in. you know, as asoviet businessman. i was mad at him as a kid, nowi understand it much better. when you grow up and you guysare all about the age my dad was when he came to america soyou've lived your whole life, if you go move now to acommunist country or somewhere

that's very different than america, everything that you've beentaught here comes with you. in russia, it was communism which meant everything was the black market. which meant at every business inrussia people stole, every one. every business in the countrysince it was owned by the country for people to survive, everything was done on the black market. so if you worked at a foodstore, you stole from the back

room and then you sold that shiton the black market and that's just how the whole countryworked so my dad really looked at his employees as his enemies. he didn't trust them at all. and it created avery negative culture. as a 14, 15-year-old kid working my dad's liquor store, they hated my dad whichthey took out on me. i wasn't super tough. it sucked and so

i saw the things i didn't want and then i had my own natural dna and then i had the way i was parented so i would say yes, itis, no question, the foundation. - [woman] hi.- hey. - [woman] so obviously you haveto be pretty ballsy to run a business like this,you're not very risk adverse. how do you evaluate what risksare worth the reward or do you just kind of jumpin with both feet? - i jump in with both feet oncei make a binary decision that

it's worth the risk. and basically my judgment oneverything we do including this fuckin' rent is scary as shit. you know, so evenstuff like that. basically, i think aboutdoomsday. i basically can afford if this company goes to deadzero from $100 million revenue that we're gonna do thisyear to dead zero i can afford personally to pay off the10 year rent of this place. so i basically make everyrisk based on if everything goes

terrible, does it kill me? as long as the answer is no then i'll do it if i think it's interesting. basically, i take it right todeathblow but i will never bet and a lot of peopledo that on deathblow. lot of people make bets that if they don't play out they're dead. i do not do that. that's my immigrant in me likei won't let bad happen but i go

right to the edge of that andas things get bigger they become bigger bets so you're right i'm super, i'm only comfortable in risk. i'm uncomfortable in thealternative and so right up to death. and death being, in the sense, out of business. i'm very comfortable ifvaynermedia has to go back to six people. i prefer not, that wouldfeel weird and bad

but i'm comfortable. i deserve it means i fucked up a lot in a row. - [woman 2] you talked aboutthat one person (inaudible), how do you approach that? - the truth is i think imight've fabricated that 1% of doubt as, i don't if you heardof the trying to remember if that was there, i basically deal with doubt by not doing anything that i have doubt in andonly doing things that i have

complete confidence in. i'm a little bitcountercultural to this. i think you shouldn'twork on your shortcomings. i'm serious. i think you're far betteroff putting all your energy in accentuating your strengthsthen spending your time on your shortcomings and so the reason i feel confident is 'cause you've never seen me read inpublic because boy would i feel, don't even read atpassover fuckin' dinner.

i don't even like reading mydaughter now really knows how to read and i'm like (groans). i'm not gonnaread to her anymore. let's make up stories, misha. like, i'm such a poor reader,i'm being dead serious right now but then i can speak in front25,000 people like i did last week like cake. right? to answer your question, i thinkfor me to give you the real answer, for me i level it up andjust eliminate things that bring

doubt into my world and justdon't do them and only spend more time doing thethings that i'm good at. that might've worked out for me. there may be some hard-core things like confidence in itself. this doesn't map for everybodybut that's my real answer like i mean there's a lot of things i know i can't do or i would have doubt in, i just don't do them. and that might sound weirdbut like it's just the truth.

i don't know.i don't know. i just don't thinkthere's that much time. i really don't want to use iton things that i can't solve. we have way too manythings are hardwired into us. it's kinda how i think aboutminorities and sexism in the market like you can sit here,there's minorities in here, there are females in here,there's people that came from bad family situations. you can sit here and listeverything that is bad about why

you don't have as easy asthe white boys in here. the problem isnobody gives a fuck. the market doesn't care. in the same way it will reward you, it doesn't care where you came from. if you've got the best product, if you're the best at it it will reward you. it's the thing i'mmost proud of here. it's why people winhere like i don't care.

i even, we evenhigher patriot fans. you know, so like that'ssomething i would really. that's probably the one prejudice thing of vayner. so, you know, i thinkof doubt that way too. dwelling on how you wish it was or being aspirational to this nirvana of a perfect world is about as big a waste of time as it gets. i'd rather just lookat what it is and go.

- [man 3] so at the all handmeeting, you emphasized speed. - speed. - [man 3] my question to youis actually piggybacking off of what james mentioned at hisfireside chat about controlled speed and chaotic speed.- yeah. - [man 3] what's your take onmaking sure that vaynermedia continues at a controlled speedand how can you apply that to us making sure that our careersin the future we maintain controlled speednot chaotic speed?

- well, i mean i have no way ofreally controlling that for you other than inspiring the debatewithin your head if you thought about, if you never thoughtabout controlled speed and chaotic speed before you leavethis experience with like, "oh, that's something," and you may recognize it in the wild one day, right? as far as how i think about it,i think that much like culture or meritocracy or anything in life, it depends on the judge and jury.

i can promise you that themendoza line difference of what i think is controlled andchaotic speed and what james thinks is control and chaotic speed are verydifferent definitions. just like what you may think ispretty or cool or relevant is different than otherpeople in this thing. so i think it's aboutunderstanding yourself. i'm way more comfortable goingchaotic than james is and i think it's super in control.

it's why i've had businessesthat have been successful. you know? i mean i love when i bring inpeople like james or even the way aj looked at the world orother people they're like, "no, no, no," i'm like,"no, no, you don't understand, "i've done this." i do this. like how do youthink we got here? because if you go too controlled speed

we're still 49 people doing 6 million. so how do i define it?the results. - [woman 3] you talked a littlebit online about what you think a political candidate should succeed in today's world. can you elaborate a little biton that and would you ever take on a politicalcandidate as a client? - i wouldn't take on a politicalcandidate as a client right now because i don't think thematurity of this company is in the right place to do that.

i think it would be a lotof conversation and a lot of emotion and a lot of debatein this company if we did. i just don't thinkthat's the right thing to do. as far as what i think theyshould do, i think they should attention arbitrage justlike the vaynermedia does. like everything is basedon that, nothing else. where is the most underpriced attention and i would try to get that. and so it comes in alot of different forms.

for example if i was running forpresident united states right now i would spent all my timein the battleground states and i would try to scale one-on-one. i would literally be in ohio right now knocking on every door. and maybe i'd have drockfollowing me around to make the content that i need to spreadfor the rest of the world but i would be there one-on-one because that's wherei need to win. got it?

so i think it's doinghand-to-hand dirty combat, getting dirt under yourfingernails where it matters and then using content collectionalong the way as distribution. so whatever i told anne-marie indayton, ohio might've been smart and cool or clever or quotable,take that clip and deploy it across the entire country.got it? but be in dayton, ohio but be in florida because that's gonna be it. ruth.

- [ruth] where doyou think (inaudible)? - where do i think thiscompany's gonna be in 20 years? - ruth, i've no fucking idea. - [ruth] what are your dreams? - you know, ruth, i don't reallydream about stuff like that to be very frank with you. i don't know if i ever thoughtabout, you know, i took over the company reallyday-to-day five years ago. we're 30 people and i don't knowif i, i didn't think five years

ago i'm like, "ooh, in five years we're gonna "be 700 people in this." i don't, i really just thinkabout buying the new york jets professionally and then i don't think about anything else in-between. i just kind of execute and i feel like if i execute, it will work itself out. but i will tell you ona more strategic level. i knew that i wanted to buildthe best marketing machine in

the world whether that meantbecause i wanted to have it for myself to sell stuff, to if oneday i do want a political person in place, i can do that. i knew, i've builtthis for myself. like the reason i knowvaynermedia doesn't sell is because nobody is to pay, for me to jump off of having this for myself is not at number that any sane person would payfor this company. right?

- [emily] you mean doesn't sell.- right. - what do you mean doesn't sell? - well like why won'ti sell vaynermedia? right. like the reason i won't sell is'cause i want it for myself and if i sell it theni'm not in control. now, if your an old schoolwrestling fan like i am the million dollar man used to say everybody's got a price and he's right.

if viacom wants to walkin and pay me $5 billion for vaynermedia right now, i'mfuckin' selling but i wouldn't sell vayner for a billion today and it's on paper worth 350, right? so like nobody's gonna pay whati want to give up the dream of having it for myself. and so when i think inlong-term, i just want it. when i look, you knowwhat i think about, ruth? you know actually what i thoughtabout when i walked here.

i said, "i wonder if the ceo of "vaynermedia is sitting inthis meeting today." i think about who's gonna run this when i decide to use it for something else. if i go and buy k swiss sneakers because i think i can compete with under armour and nike because wedo our thing better than anybody else that means i'm gonna be theceo of k swiss, who's gonna be the ceo and the management teamof this company so i think more

now about who and when then like anything else. hey. - [woman 4] so i'm onthe animation team, (inaudible) - yep. - [woman 4] (inaudible) forad work, where do you see vaynermedia in five years in terms of different in order to compete with all the agencies out there?

are we going to be doing more vr stuff? or where? - guys, i figured i'llstart repeating the question. i realize i'm not setting youup for success so how we are we gonna differentiate in five years? are we gonna do vr stuff? how are we gonna be different? i think the reason we'll alwaysbe special, especially if i'm really controlling it, and bythe way i don't know if i'm gonna be ceo for 15 years, 3,19 as long as i'm the ceo we're

gonna win because i'm really good at buyingunderpriced attention. right, so like the way we'regonna differentiate is the way we differentiate today which iswe just fundamentally understand the current state ofmarketing better than others. and so that's it. that's the easiest question forme the answer because i don't know anything other, of coursevr, of course ar, of course the thing that karen in tulsa,oklahoma, you know is right now

inventing that's can beimportant in three years. yes, because i onlywant to break us. the only job i have every day isto wake up and put this company out of business by us being theones that put ourselves out of business versus lettingsomebody out there do it for us. got it? so we'll only innovate. you guys heard all hands-on. the only thing i canpromise is change.

you don't like change get thefuck out because this is not gonna be a good place for youbecause it's the only norm. and just so you know at scale,big companies, hundred people, 10 million inrevenue that gets hard. people don't like change. you're on the little bit of theyounger side but even your own dna may not like change. change is what most people hate. definitely after certain periodin your life, mid 30s, hate and

even 50% of this young creahate 'cause it's hardwired. change is hard. - [man 5] so i'm in a similarsituation you were like 20 years ago. my dad owns a hardware store-- - (inaudible) what are yourtips on improving it and also what platform should webe using (inaudible)? - question is he's ina similar spot as me. his dad's got a hardwarestore, he wants to blow it up. what general advice?

so i'm gonna give you avery interesting answer. the first you have to do is get religious and mental buy-in from your dad. it doesn't matter what thetactics are. shopify, micmac, you know, nfc technology, multiple locations, jvs, influencer marketing none ofthat shit matters if you don't have the room to do it. so let me ask you,

do you think you're gonna have the room to do it? - [man 5] yeah.dad is super open. - great so then, then i think sure. and what i mean bythat is you're here, you're paying attention. i'm not gonna tell youanything that's super crazy. if you're not on e-com yougotta make that investment. it's gotta be shopify, it's gotto be amazon services,

ebay my biggest advice to you is to build the brand. hardware stores arenot differentiated. is it in new york or new jersey? you know, as you know likeso many people go to hardware stores herecompletely based on location. it's completelyconvenience based. what you need to do and this iswhat i did in my dad's store, i remember thinkingin retail everybody says, "location, location, location,"right?

and i remember thinking that'sthe only thing i care about breaking and i think if you havethat religious mentality that the one thing you don't wantto be at the mercy of is the location of the store then youstart thinking about selling to people through online. then you start thinking aboutbecoming a destination people want to go to. why? is your brooms and screwsand drills so much better? absolutely not so thefuck are you gonna create?

so you have to cratethat differentiation? - [man 5] thank you, man.- you got it. - [man 6] do you thinksoccer leagues overseas-- - one more time. - [man 6] soccerleagues, soccer teams-- - soccer leagues.- [man 6] they have-- - brands on the jerseys. - [man 6] there's beentalks about the nfl-- - not talks, thenba is doing it.

- [man 6] right. so what do you think will happenwith them bringing brands and bringing sponsors on to jerseysin the four major sports? - all-- - [man 6] if you somehow ownedor was the manager for the nfl, nhl, nba what would you wantto do with that opportunity? - so i think it's inevitablethat all four sports, you have to understand,sports is business. the nba's gonna do this, we'renot gonna freak out that there's

a pepsi logo onthe bulls jersey. we don't give a fuck. the leagues will realize that. the next day they'll all do itand that's going to be a big business for them because i cantell you one thing i don't want our clients to do: buy signage in stadiums. because it's overpriced. because when i was a kid yougo to a stadium and during stoppage of play you lookedaround because you have anything

else to fuckin' do and yousaw the pepsi sign, oh pepsi. now you grab your phone and you don't look around and they're just overpriced. signage is shit in stadium. it's one of the most overpricedproducts in the world and the brands are getting pissed andthey want, you're going to have to look at the players so i think everybody will do it. - [man 6] howabout (inaudible)-- - [man 6] (inaudible) on a jersey would be more like--

- 100%. remember i only trade attention. i can promise you as much as youlook at the table as much as you the one thing you're always looking at is the fuckin' player. yeah i think they're gonna bepimped out head to toe with every fucking logo you know.(laughter) - [man 6] thanks.- you got it. - [man 7] (inaudible) last year of school.

- yeah, sorry. i'm kidding, i'm kidding. i hated school, you maylove it plus it's so fun. it's so easy and you'regonna hookup, have fun. - [man 7] i mean it's probablythe last chance to get to learn any skill that you think you'dneed to learn without having to go and do that on your own and achance for someone to teach you. so in this industry what skill do you think we should make sure we come in before graduation?

- you mean on the side or in theclassroom at your university? - [man 7] in your classroom.- none. - [man 7] so on the side?- it is my 100% belief-- you know i thinkthe question is what you we learn in our last year ifit's our last year since we're getting paid to learn or i thinkyou're paying them, oh, you're paying to learn?yeah, okay. yeah, man i got to tell you like the whole college business model is the mostfascinating so, you know, and

that's the point, right, you'reliterally paying and i genuinely believe in marketing there'snot a school right now teaching anything that's right. they're just not. how many of you arein marketing classes? what is it look like? right. so like fuck me. anyway, i think the best thingyou should do, to be very frank with you, bro, honestly i thinkyou're about to start the part

of your life where you're gonna learn where it matters on the field, right? i may throw you guys for a loopon this one, i actually think you should just enjoy the livingshit out of this last year. i'm not kidding like, you know,if you're me well then you be selling shit and starting abusiness on the side anyway but if you're not like dying to do, i wouldn't've gone to a fuckin' internship. i was broken like, i couldonly do it my way, you know?

like i barely even wentinto my dad's liquor store. i was making $3000 a weekend selling baseball cards when i was 14. i was good. i think that my intuition is ifyou even have this internship, right, that the real answeris fucking don't fail i guess 'cause maybe your parents would be upset but then like, i don't know. and if you want to learn, i think you'll learn more,

the truth is unless you startyour own business which will take a lot of time which i'mtrying to debate is that valuable to you in last yearwhen you should probably milk this ridiculous year thatyou're living which many may think is the greatest single year of your life. right? other than that you're gonnalearn more in the first hundred days of your job coming out thenthere so to me it's us back to betting on strengths andweaknesses though the value

exchange here feels likefuck it, just you know. yeah, you're into that? sounds like a good strat. - [man 8] how would you suggestan intern, a low level employee, you or someone above you(inaudible) without being an asshole about it? - first, to make sure that youalways deploy a lot of humility because nobody wants to, because you might be wrong

and if you're wrong you're fucked. because if you're the internthat said to my face this is garbage and you'rewrong, that's bad. now if you're right, it's phenomenal so i, even if you really closely payattention to my public content, i'm really good at giving youhoney before i give you vinegar. so my answer is to hedge it. like, "hey mark evans, "i think your, you're the best and

"i really don't know. "i weirdly for some reason feel "compelled to tell youyour idea is shit." right? i think you have to hedge it. because you have toreally be sure you're right. plus the other thing, my man,that you really need to pay attention to davidis it's subjective. so one of the biggest problemsis you may have something that's an opinion and then you'retelling somebody above you that

they're wrong, there's no way toprove if it's wrong or right and they're just going to imposetheir seniority on you and it's gonna suck shit. that's why the battles i fightare, you can prove them out. i also think you should go homeand try to figure out why that matters so much here becausei think it's actually a very interesting question that hasboth good and bad in it and you should break it down. we need to jam on that.

- [molly] i know earlierthis summer you made a videoabout internships,-- - i did. it did really well. - [molly] but last summer i read an article that you-- - uh oh. - [molly] yeah, i don't want tomisquote you but the jist was, "the intern program is bullshit "and you should be emailing someone, "getting in touch with them--"- yes!

- [molly] and it would bemore useful in shadowing them. - i'm a big believer in that. - [molly] but my thingwas i was frustrated-- - frustrated?- [molly] yeah. - 'kay. - [molly] obviously, it's really hard. when you really admire someoneand really came to you and your email signature says,"basically i'm really busy." - yeah, go fuck yourself.go ahead.

- [molly] i guess my questionis like if there's (inaudible) that's very high up. - molly, what do you wantto do when you grow up? do you know yet? it's okay if you don't,i'm just curious. do you? - [molly] i think i want to workin this space but i'm not sure. - so to me like if you when i hear that somebody wants to be the next puff daddy or the nextme or the next whatever anybody wants to be, whatever, whateveryou want to be, at whatever

level, right, i genuinelybelieve that you should spend all your time to try to go get an internship to be as close to that person as. if anybody here actually wantto be the next me, i think that they should have tried to bethe intern on my team versus an intern at vaynermedia, i believe that. i genuinely believe the closeryou can get to the sun of what you want to be, themore likely you'll learn. - [molly] my question islike how do you do that?

- by relentless fuckin' pursuit. - [molly] even if your email says, "don't talk to me for a year."- especially. i mean that. it's just the audacity to find the right balance, it's really actually interesting. it's not super different thandavid's question in some ways how do you find the rightcadence and balance to be aggressive withoutbeing fucking annoying?

there's people to try to reachme every day, lots of them, some of them immediately through thefirst three attempts go in to i will never fuckin' interactwith this person ever because it's coming from a bad place. i get to be the judge and thejury of that's what it tastes like and other people win andeventually get their at-bats. there's a kid i met today forfive minutes like some these people tried for 15 times toget like, to me it's like if you want it so bad.

first of all, there may be 34 people that look like you want to be. right? so, you know, there may be 11hip hop business mogul people and you can go right down theline and try to hit up bird man and p diddy 50times each, right? i think it's worththat, mol, honestly. i think it's worth it. you have to understand the upside's greater thanthe downside. to me,--

- [molly] how do yousay (inaudible)-- - how do you makeyourself stand out? - [molly] how do you-- - you need tounderstand that person. so you fuckin' really tryto figure out who they are. one of things i would do isfollow them heavily on social and figure out what, there's alot of ways to break through. for example, everybody thinksthe best way to get a hold of me is to write in theemail subject,

"i am gonna help you buy the new york jets", "i've got an idea that's gonna help "you buy the jets," "i'm gonna help you buy the jets." the problem is that's whateverybody does which means that none of them get through. the answer is i don't knowbecause everybody's got a different unlock. here's what i do know about ron howard and all these

different fancy people i know. all of them have beenpenetrated, all of them. because winners want togive other winners at-bats. we feel guilt and we have topayback to the thing that put us there and they all do it. and so to me, i think you know it's fuckin' cool to try to like pull that off. and i actually think, especially when i think about it froma college, still in college

internship level i think it's a fun journey. i actually think it's a coolcontent series to start in september and spend all ofseptember through like march trying to become anintern on team xyz. think it's kinda cool. yeah and you know what's funny? it's actually got similaritiesto my advice in that video which is i think the kpi for you guysbeing here is there especially vayner, especially if youare considering to be in this

industry, there are 100 people in here 50 which you can be very unbelievably senior here one dayand 50 that are gonna run shit out there that wasworth the hello. i love that you run in littlepacks with each other and that's great but you can run with packs of each other in fuckin' october. this is the easiestplace to randomly say hello. your friends and homies havemuch time for jobs to penetrate

that where they're at. so i just think it peoplemake the, it's all people. it's all fuckin' people. 80% of you got herebecause of people. you had some rabbi that gotyou into this fuckin' place. it's gotten so hard for us,to your point, our biggest problem right nowis everybody wants their child or best friend's child tobe an intern here now. next year's a disaster.

i got like a fuckin hundred-- - we just need anotherfloor that's my only. - got it. okay. - we just need a seat for everyone and then i'll be very happy.- on it. - [man 9] sup gary? my question for you istechnology is advancing at an incredibly fast rate nowadays. - yes, merritt.

technology is moving fast. - [man 9] some insights andgaining information on people. what do you think about the waythat companies are doing it now and in the future? and do you think that the individual's privacy isbeing (inaudible)? - privacy is being invaded 'cause you're allowing it to be invaded. you're giving up privacy every

fucking day for convenience and time. they're not invadingyour giving it up. you know you'rebeing watched right now. you don't give a fuck. - [man 9] it's true.- i know. - [man 9] do you think we'llgive up more in the future? - here's what i think happens. do you guys knowwho len bias is? - [man 10] yeah,basketball player.

- len bias was one of the bestpossible players of all time in college and unfortunately twodays after he was drafted third overall in the nba hedied from a drug overdose. he overdosed on cocaine. he was from theuniversity of maryland. nancy reagan was superanti-drugs very conservative president on that issue andthe gun, and the gun it's funny where i'm going with this youcan see where my head's going, my punchline is the druglaws changed here forever.

here's my thing on privacy, wedon't give a fuck because the punchline of society ispeople are unbelievable. as much of the mainstream mediawants to tell you about the one person who has emotional issuesthat will shoot 25 people in a club and it's the worst. it's the worst.you know what? do me a favor if you're curiousabout this, do you know that cnn did a series called the 60s and the 70s. i don't know if this hityour radar, probably not.

but they did. there was eight series ifyou have netflix go to it. go watch the one onterrorism in the 70s. there were more terrorist actsdomestically in the 70s in this country by 10x thenwhat's going on now. it's unbelievable actually. so what people don't realizeis we paint the wrong pictures. the reason none of us care about privacy is because people are good.

we're not doing thatmuch bad with the privacy. what are you sad that toyota'sfollowing you around the internet and puttingbanner ads in front of you? we don't do that many bad things with it and so i think we give up privacy. now here's the punchline i believe that somebody like beyoncã© or rhianna is gonna getkilled because of a social media post of where she is. somebody with the wrong mindset

and that everything changes that next day. because we can kill 50 childrenin a school and not react but when somebody kills one of ourtop 10 celebrities because of this, everything will change. it's just who america is sounfortunately what i'm trying to figure out is what happens toprivacy post the assassination of a celebrity on theback of no privacy. we got deep.- yeah. you like that one, right?

that's why they'repaying me the big bucks. this is the shitthat i think about. gina. - [gina] two part question.- gina. - [gina] it's not twodifferent questions, two parts. - not everybody's gonna be ableto ask their question and you've jumped in with atwo-part question. - [gina] the first one you can just give a real easy answer to if you want.

okay, so, you always talk abouthow this company is growing. - [gina] and there's rumorsthat the studio is expanding and getting a bigger space. - that's not arumor, that's true. - [gina] and they're all talkingabout how there's gonna be more open positions.- yes. - [gina] so may 2017--- yes. - [gina] i'm gonnabe up for grabs. - great.

- [gina] let's rewind, you saidwinners give winners chances. - yes. - [gina] i think i'm a winner.- you do? - [gina] and i think youshould give me a chance. - well i think wealready gave you a chance. aren't yousitting in front of us? - so let me say this, gina. listen, here's the good news ourratio of people that have been interns that even as long asthey were not the worst thing

we've ever seen and superinappropriate our conversion rate on interns that wantedto work here is staggering. i promise you that you have aunbelievable advantage over anybody else that wantsyour spot in may 2017. now, when i dig under the hood i may found out that you are the single worst person that's evercome through this organization and that wouldeliminate that statement. but my gut tells methat's probably not the case. - [gina] so then the second partof it is you are like a firm

believer in the whole notionthat people work their way up. like meritocracy.- love meritocracy. - [gina] being said, if i wereto come back here next year to get a job, right now, everybody loved me but they think i'm the bestphoto assistant. how do i break that notion intheir head that i can do more than carry gear around? how do i get it in their heads?

'cause the more i hustle, the longer hours i stay, i'm just an even better photo assistant. so how do i make them realize i can do this? - that's the dna this com--,that to me is like the easiest, that's almost as easy, i saidthe other thing was easy like this is easy. that's what we do every day. the good news is unlike when i promised these guys that they didn't know, i don't know.

go talk to every fuckingperson that works here. they got the samefuckin' story you do. 'cause it happens every day. cool.- [gina] thank you. - just, good man. - [justin] you speak about yourdislike of modern education. - i'm not the biggest fan ofmodern-day education under the context of the following: anybody who takes on debt to

learn entrepreneurship ormarketing in today's college environment is getting fucked. - [justin] withthat being said,-- - [justin] what's your advice to young adults without a formal education? - you need to find the placeswhere a formal education isn't a prerequisite to success. justin, it wasn't in my bestinterest to go try to get a job at goldman sachs.

they weren't looking for me so i went to the place that i could which is my dad's liquor store,where the market was going to decide who i was. not different thanmolly's thing, right? like if you're a hustler go talkto other hustlers they know what it looks like. harvard stan is not going tolove it as much, you know? so don't sell to the unsellable. this is back to minorities,women, things that nature,

find a place where it's sellable. don't try to impose your will. don't go try to prove tosomeplace where you know they give a shit about what schoolyou went to that you've got it. they don't get the fuck. they're gonna find the kidthat's got it and has the fucking degree thatthey give a shit about. find the guy who disrespectsthe degree and work there. you're lucky bro becausei didn't grow up in the

environment you did. do you know how much a hero i would've been for making $3-4000 a weekend as a kid? i looked as a loser. i was making $3000 weekend but because i got a d infuckin' english, i was a loser. i wish i was growingup in this generation. i'd be in fucking magazines and heralded as the next this and that.

but i didn't, you're so lucky. we've never lived in a world where formal educationhas mattered less. that's just the truth. i lived 20 years ago whereanybody here who's going to fancier school thanme looked down on me. now people are smarter to belike they still may look down, and i don't think they're wrong,it's just enough people know there's a lot of alternativesbrewing and shit's gotten weird.

just the way it is. kens. - [kens] alright, in terms ofpersonal branding on your social media platforms,--- yeah. - [kens] how do you believe thatsocial media has altered the way that individuals perceive otherindividuals and how individuals perceive themselves? - so the question is with socialmedia how do people perceive others differently now because

of it and how do theyperceive themselves? i believe that all of youare the pr agent of yourself. i believe that you guys go toplaces and concerts and events just to take the photo to deployso that you can message to everybody who you are. i think it's fuckin' cool. some people think it's sad or whatever, i think it's always happened. it's what we do.

you're wearing the clothesyou're wearing right now to tell us who you are. that's what we do. we express ourselves. it's just what we do and i think we now all have scale of media to do it. now when you asked the secondpart of the question it gets really interesting because i do think that, for example, young teenage girl, some of youmight've gone through this,

social's in a little bit of adifferent place than some of you, one of the most interestingthings i find is that i think, for people in analytics worldhere, i think that there's a lot of 13-year-old teenage girlsthat understand analytics better than people that work herebecause just literally putting up content looking athow quickly it's liked, understanding where it'sgonna end up with how many likes pulling it down 'cause youdidn't like the engagement or the, that whole game isfascinating to me and i do

believe that people, some peoplethat lack self-esteem, are wrapping their self-esteem upinto their engagement, their likes, their followers andthat has its dangers just like anything else hasalways had their dangers. so i think an interesting timebut i think you subconsciously don't even realize thatyour pr'ing yourself at scale. that's i love live events andlive divisions because i think it's unbelievable how much, i don't think people realize the rise of music festivals has a lot more to do with

social media than anything else. - [woman 5] what isyour biggest challenge? how do you overcome challenges? - what's been mybiggest challenge? how do i overcome them? i think the biggest challenge i've had is, i would say the transition from, the thought of leaving my family business was really tough.

right, i didn't want tolet my dad down, you know? aj was coming and i knew he wantto do something with me and i knew that he didn'twant to do it with my dad. there was just a lot of-- that was really atough period for me. i'll be very honest with youlike it's no different than the 1% doubt, i'm sure youguys get this sense. i struggle withholding on to negativity. i actually think our culture is good because

i'm uncomfortable in negativity. and that's why nobody's able toreally roll with it more than anything becausenobody's better than me. nobody's gonna drive biggerbusiness results for this company than me and thus ifthey're bringing negativity they'll bring me down enough tonot let me do my thing and so, it's so funny i hate yourquestion not only because i want to give you a good answerand i'm gonna bullshit it. i don't know.

the realist answer is i haven'tdealt with my toughest thing yet because i haven't dealt with the death of one of my innerseven people. right? that will be my hardest whenone my parents, my wife, my children, my siblings or theirspouses if god forbid one of them were to die that'smy biggest challenge. other than that like i got real fuckin' lucky. i just think it's all easy. i really do because i don't,

here's why because if you told me right now vayner could be40,000 people and $8 billion in revenue but i have to losetwo of the people that i just mentioned in the next five yearsor it will never get bigger than this and i get to hold ontothose eight people for the next 30 years guaranteed, right, it'sjust not even a conversation. so that's cool i just knowwhat i'm wired in which is as hard-core business as i am andentrepreneur and i want to buy the jets and all that it justdoesn't mean that much to me in

the scheme of things.you got it. oh, i'm sorry. we got yours too? - [woman 6] right now.- let's do it. - [woman 6] if you could go backin time right now and give your 21-year-old self advice, what you say? - ha, drock knows this answer.(laughter) oh god, is hr around? - [emily] we're all hr, so yeah.(laughter)

you can say it, you can say it. - so this is the real answer,'cause i don't wanna, i want to stay consistent, i literally would've said to hook up more-- because you heard like i really went all-in in my business. i literally like cute girls werelike, "let's go out," and i'm like, "no, no, i have to goto the baseball card store." real weird crazy shit in

hindsight so that's the real answer. i don't know if thatmaps for you guys. that's the real answer. - [man 9] maps for me. - you know, i think, here's whati will say, here's something that will bring you guys valueif you knew that i'm sitting here is as a 40-year-old twiceyour age and i know not only that i truly genuinely feelthat you, i'm laughing right now inside because i literally thinkthat we're friends and homies and

the same age andi really mean it. when i play basketball withthose guys, those are my guys like we're the same, right? i genuinely think you andi are the same but i also know that when i was 20 and i saw a40-year-old dude i was like that dude's so fuckin' old.(laughter) it's so crazy how old i knowyou're thinking i am and how insanely deeply i feel likewe're, aren't we the same? i genuinely believe we're thesame and here's why i'm telling

you that if somebody told methat, if i'm able to break through to one of you that truthyou'll be much more patient and you'll think aboutshit differently. if i told you're gonna feelexactly the same on fire, hungry, change the world, doyour thing, make your mark all that stuff in 20 years, exactlythe same, maybe more but exactly the same i think itwould change you. i wish you could know that tobe as true as i know to be so i think i would tell my20-year-old self and it goes

back like hook up where it'slike look you got plenty of fuckin' time to do it all. yeah, it's gonna take a lot ofhard work to the insanity you want but that's whati would tell myself. that you will not believehow young you will feel at 40. what's that? - [woman 6] i said (inaudible).- cool. - let's keep it moving, i want you guys to get your questions answered.

- what do i have on the backend? - [man 10] (inaudible) yougot to be outta here at 6:30. - what do i have on the backend?show me 'em. go ahead. - do you want your phone?- yeah. i got it. - [woman 7] so you called socialmedia the cocktail party, i was wondering if you feel like it'sbeing overcrowded as a lot of these major platforms areadopting similar features. like where you see the future of

social going in the next 10 or so years. - so i think twitter is thecocktail party of the internet because it's the one place we can all go whensomething happens. everything else we just pushout content even, you know, even people with small followingsstunningly don't read every comment when the push somethingout and things that nature. i'm not sure where it's going. i think the thing that's really,you know the truth is i get a

lot of credit forlike predicting shit. i don't predict things,i just react quickly. i'm just putting a lot more time figuring out musical.ly than you guys. that's all so i'm not sure. i really don't know. i do know that vr will be the thing that trumps the internet itself. that you guys are young enoughto live in a vr platform world

versus an internetplatform world and that's crazy. the fact that all of you willbe walking around with contact lenses and seeing randomother shit right now, fuck. you know, there's real shit, youknow, you're too young to know what i know which is when i wassitting in here and i would've raised my hand if i was hereand was like i'm gonna launch a website for my dad's liquor. everybody would've laughed at meand thought it was the stupidest shit they've ever heard.

i don't think you guys realizethat at your young 40-year-old self you just might be sittingon a beach in san diego full time and livingyour life from that. shit's gonna get crazy. i actually think you guys might be young enough that youbecome robots one day. - i know that that's not ajoke which is why i'm laughing. i know that he's not joking. - i genuinely think some ofyou may live to 200 years old.

i'm so pissed i'm not you. i think i just missed it. i'm gonna be so pissed-- i'm gonna be so pissed ifthat's what ends up happening. - aj gets it, you don't. - i feel that there's thisweird thing that happens where there'll be some technologychanges where we're like okay anybody who's super healthyand 35 and under they're gonna actually live to 250 buteverybody else and above is

actually gonna live itnormal and i'm gonna be pissed. - (inaudible) now,it could happen. - so i don't know but here'swhat i can promise you and it's super not different than howwe're gonna differentiate and stay ahead is i don't know but i promise you i'll react with real fuckin' fast. - [woman 8] i was wondering what is it that you feel really drives you and also what are you looking forward to in the olympics?

- what am i looking for to in? - [woman 8] in the olympics? - in the olympics, it isunbelievable to me how little i give a fuck about the olympics. - maddie, it's so crazy.i don't give a shit. they've somehow been able tocreate a scenario where it is become the most irrelevant thingto me in my life and i know and i'm like born in russia so likethe olympics were super cool for me as a kid 'cause it was russiaversus america when i was a kid.

i was like, "oh, who do i root for? "why am i weirdlyrooting for russia? "am i a spy?" so weird but so not much. for it to be over and then asfar as what was the first part of the question? - [woman 8] what drives you?- what drives me? i think i'm an underdog. i think ultimately my story'sgonna be pretty basic which was

i wasn't born here, my firstinteraction with american kids when i was like four in doverthat i don't talk about at all ever was they forced me todrink pee out of a pepsi can. you know, yeah didn'tspeak english like outcast. i was 4-foot-11 myfreshman year of high school. that was an underdog. i was a bad student and thesystem told me i was shit. i hated kobe bryant his wholecareer until the last two years when he was washed up.

i hated tiger woods wheneverybody loved him and he was dominating. now i love him whenhe's not winning. i'm just underdog driven. the yankees and rangers i don't give a shit about anymore because they won. so i only keep the teams and care about teams that are climbing. i'm just, i'm in for the climb.

i have a chip on my shoulder and i'm underdog driven and it drives the fuck out of me. it's genuinely why believe myson has no prayer to beat me ever because he'll be superprivileged, he's gonna live on the upper east side, he hasa home in bridgehampton, he fuckin' gonna go to town school,he's gonna fly private to the fucking super bowl. he's fuckin' finished.

- you know? kill him. hannah.- [hannah] hey gary. can i get some advice forsomeone who wants to be a social media influencer? - yeah.- [hannah] like an influencer? - sure, to be a social mediainfluencer, hannah, you have to have something to say thatpeople give a fuck about. so cool like

you basically said how i get a bunch of people to give a fuck about me.- [hannah] yeah. - and i think it starts withlike, i'll give you a really good piece of advice it'sprobably the thing i can probably answer the best, only your truth. only your truth 'causeit's the only thing you got. everything else islike everybody else's. only your truth.

you know what that means? you gotta be brave. you gotta go to thoseplaces you don't want to go. got it?- [hannah] got it. - and then you got totell the world about it. - [hannah] thank you. - that's all you got becauseit's not hack, it's not be smart with hashtags, it's not gojv with another influencer. at the end the day, i canfucking give you love on my

snapchat story for the restof the year, if you can't do anything with thatlove you're not to win. the only thing that i've seenreally, really work that has any longevity, look you can havecute little blue eyes and be nash grier for two years, right? you can be like youcan (stammering). what i don't think peoplerealize there's only so much tits and ass you canshow on instagram. to have true longevity the

only thing you've got is your truth. - [woman 9] can you just talk alittle bit about when you and aj were talking aboutchanging locations. what was the discoursebetween you and stephen ross? was he like, "hey i think vaynershould be in this location," or we're you like, "hell yeah. this is it,"? - how do we think about moving here with stephen ross and this and that? so steven's obviously our business partner,

he's the biggest real estatedeveloper in the world. he's building the biggestproject in new york, we're growing and the funniestpart is the whole time i'm like, "no way, no way.i'm not going fucking fancy. "i'm not payingthat fuckin' rent. "no way, no way, no way." and then truth is i just reallynegotiated hard core with them and price kept coming down,terms keep getting better. we kept growing, there was onlyso many floors available and

i was just like, "ugh," so likethe truth is it just worked out that we became big enough to afford it at the time that it became available. but i never aspired, i'll be very honest with you. i've said it.i mean it. i'm really worried thateverybody here is gotten too fancy because of it. i'm super scared of it. this is fucking nice.

i mean there's been real seriouspeople coming through the last week and they're like,"whoa," and i'm like, "fuck." like if this fuckin' fancy fucker thinks this is whoa we're in deep shit. i mean it. i genuinely mean it. now on the flip side,you know how nice it is? i'm so happy, do you know how nice is that people get to have flavored seltzer? so that's really just how it worked out.

- [woman 9] did thefuture of this get real? influence you in any way? - no. there's no romanticstory of how we got here. it was just fuckin', we're not like, "oh, i couldn't wait for neiman fuckin' marcus." - this is what she'sworking on right now. - i get it. - yeah, she's like whatare the talking points. she's hustlin'.- yeah.

you're not gonna sell $5 million apartments on my thesis. andres, i'm talking to youafter so i'm gonna skip you. - [man 7] you need to the(inaudible) meeting though? - like right this second? what time is it? - [man 7] it's 6:10 we canpush it back to 6:20-- - yeah, okay. cool, we'll figure it out.

when you out?- [andres] friday. okay. go ahead. - [woman 10] with all theadvances in technology, so many people and adults nowadays arelike, "i wish we could go back to the good old daysof we talk in person." are there any apps or advancesin technology that you wish didn't come out?- no. evolution is evolution.right, like, no.

the good ole days arenot as good as you think. that's just old people talk. tell grandma sueshut the fuck up. - respectfully. - do you guys remember, haveyou guys seen that photo that everybody loves to point to? i don't know if you've seenthis, it's the photo when the pope came and everybody's gottaa camera and there's that one 90-year-old woman and she'slooking and everybody wants to

make her a star forshe really captured. she didn't capture shit. she's 90, she already forgot andif she took a photo she could've enjoy yourself today. but instead she had no idea. i'm being dead serious. i think that old woman lost and everybody wants to make her a hero. no because thisis the way it is.

and we have proven for muchlonger than our grandparents have been around that we evolve. if a caveman was dug up rightnow from fuckin' 3000 years ago and plopped right herehe'd be like, "what the f--?" they thought, they toldus the telephone was bad. do you know what, do you seethis article i sent you guys. you might have saw it andres,are you on the team gary alias, did they put you on or no? got it.

the kaleidoscope. do you know what the biggestproblem in the world in 1816 was was people walking around with a kaleidoscope in real life and it ruined us. no, so no youcouldn't even imagine. i love debating with people that have ideological romances of how it was. no, you take thegood with the bad. whatever makes you sad about the way we are now,

there's 8 billion good. do you know that my generationand i'm still not that much older than you lost touch withhigh school friends and never to be talked to again until nine years later miraculouslyon facebook. there's so much good. do you know muchmore social you are? i love when people arelike, "you're not social." you're dramatically moresocial than your parents were.

it may happen in different form. so what writing a letter is so much more noble thantexting somebody? what the fuck is thematter with people? the girls that i grew up in highschool that had a phone in their room and laid there all day andwatched "saved by the bell" and talked on the phonefor 14 hours a day. that was so much greaterthan what you're doing. that's just oldpeople talk who are sad.

it's defense. - [woman 11] what kind of clientfor vayner do you think we do the best work and (inaudible)? - that's a great question. i think one that found that, the best client for us to do the best work. i think one that was open mindedbut was grounded in truths. so not letting us get to likeyou need to do the next thing but was open, like just open minded.

in the same way i am about,around technology, i'm just open minded about it. everybody defaults toanything that's change is bad. let me just go back, kyle, i'm still so pissed about this question. - [gary] in a great way. i don't know if your parents orgrandparents or old people that you know ever did this when yougo to a restaurant or if you do it and see a couple sittingthere and they're both on the

phone and you're like,"oh, that's so sad." i don't think that sad. let me tell you from an oldperson's perspective what i see. that same couple 15 years ago,they were sitting there and they just sitting across from each other and not saying a fucking word. their relationship is broken,the phone isn't the reason. technology is just exposingwho you are not changing you. so the client open-mindedness.

- [man 10] so i watched yourvideo on august and how it's such a critical month.- [gary] yes. i'm obsessed with august. - [man 10](inaudible) hustle-- - [man 10] and i feel that therewere more things in that video that you wanted to so why is august so important to get your hustle on? - i just think august is themost interesting fuckin' month. it's the month when most peopleshut it down and i think the

best time to put it on iswhen everybody else isn't. it's also the monthright before shit gets real. from a business standpoint, september to december,that's prime time. that's when the culmination ofeverything kinda hits and so i find it fascinating thatpeople, it's kinda like if you're running a marathon andon a third the way through you stop and then you got to start up again, fuck. got it? so i really tookadvantage of august my whole

career but as you saw in that video there's the alternatefor people like me. next wednesday i'm ghost untilthe day after labor day and i'm pumped about it. i miss my family. i need that three weeks. you know?awesome. - [man 11] what'd you do withyour spare time in college? - [gary] i played out a lot ofmadden football and i sold shit.

i mean everyday in college, it'sfunny my college friends have been reminding me of shit i forgot like i would go to the dollar store by shit andtry to sell it on ebay. - [man 11] gotcha. - and i had verylittle downtime. i went home every single friday. think about this, i went homeevery friday to go work at the liquor store and thencome back sunday night. - [man 11] dedication.

- it's just what i wanted, you know. i just knew, i knew who i was. i knew what it was. i knew, i knewwhat was happening. - [man 12] kinda goingback to patience,-- - patience. - [man 12] when launching a newbusiness or your brainchilds, launching that, do you thinkit's important to get on social and start moving early oris it better to (inaudible).

- i think it's earlier tojulian's question, i think it's important for you, in thebeginning of your business, if anybody wants to start one, only do the thing that your best at. if you're just good atselling like just sell. don't worry aboutyour marketing. if you're good at marketing, if you learnsomething here, do that. what people do, you'll have thisexperience one day maybe like

it's like what you expectfrom a three-year-old child. my little guy, xander, he'sabout to turn four next week, sometimes he'll do things 'cause he's got older sister so we forget. we're 40 and 35, we forget. he's fucking 44 months old like what you want from him? you know what i mean. i think a lot of people try to do everything

in the beginning of a business. your business is a baby. vaynermedia didn't looklike this seven years ago. we're making up shit in aconference room half the size of that and like, "what do we do? "let's build websites."that's what i would do. alright, let's go. your turn. - [henley] (inaudible) how do you do that?

- henley, one more time, i'm sorry. - [henley] how doyou dream so big? - i dream so big because my mom allowed me to. and i will tell you that i will,that the single biggest reason i think i have a public personais because i feel so damn guilty of how perfectly parented i was and if i can give you guys even a little bit of something yourparents might not give you then i'll accomplish paying backwhat i think i was gifted.

that's why, henley, because my mom really made me feel like i could. what my mom did really wellwas she praised me for my good things but didn't alloweighth place trophies. meaning if i lost she wasn'tlike you won like all these fucking stupid modern parents. like, "no, no, no he lost." fucking, oh my god, i tell lizzie i'm like so petrified of the upper east side.

i'm like, "no, no ifyou lose you lose." like xander my little guy,xander, he will not score a basket on me in basketballfor the next 15 years. that's 100%. aj, i wish he was, he's here buthe just left, i wish you guys could talk to him, aj didn't score a basket on me until he was like 15. a basket and so she did that well but more importantly if

i open the door, i will never forget this, i opened the door for a lady atmcdonald's when i was like nine. you would've literally thought that i fuckin' won thenobel peace prize. she made that such a big dealand i think that's what she did well and so that's why think i can dream big because i just feel it.you know? - [henley] thanks.- you got it. la.

- [peter] during the last six orseven weeks or so whatever the fuck it is i've been trying towork as hard as i can to try to put myself in a position towork here and what have you. i guess what my question is isthat i've been working so hard and doing everything i can. people aretelling me, "good job." but it still doesn'tfeel like enough yet. like i remember one time therewas an article put out that you said that when you buy the jetsthat's gonna be like your worst

day ever because you'll finallyhave done what you've been trying to do all this time.- it's gonna suck. - [peter] so i guessthat's the question. what are we working towards ifwe're never satisfied with what we've got until we get it andthen it's over (slaps table). - what do you mean? if that's how you're wiredyou're just as lucky as i am. anybody who's lucky enough tolove the process more than the thing has fucking won becauseyou spend a lot more fucking

time on theprocess than the thing. - [peter] yeah. shit. - yeah.(laughter) - [emily] peter! - [gary] peter, and by the way,i promise you if you decide to apply permanently 'cause yousaid you wanted to get a job here, i'm personally, emilymake sure this happens, i'm personally gonna write youthe note that you got the job and it's gonna say i'm sorry.

i'm sorry got the job. harris, let's go. - [harris] cool. my question is i thought i was really competitive at first and then iplayed you at basketball at vm7, realized i'm not competitive at all. - okay.(laughter) - [harris] and then i had to step up my game. do you think you get more competitive with people that are around or--

actually, you know what? i'm so proud of you forasking this question. actually i really do, i'm surprised i'm so excited by this. i have a good pieceof advice, actually. start trimming your friend groupand start adding to your friend group predicated onwhat you want to be. the answer isabsolutely, my man. you absolutely.

i am stunned how much more i amlike my wife and how much more she is like me even though westarted a very polar places. it's just true. who you hang out with, there is such a smart hack to like and it's really like that clichã©thing like you are like the byproduct of people, all that. that's real, super real. so maybe this is a good year foryou to like kind of audit that

first day back, look aroundmaybe know a friend of a friend and if you like what you see goexplore it and try to be around it because, yeah man, i thinkthat you got more competitive by being around me and i can tellyou right now i know everybody on my team they're different. i'll tell you one thing that i can tell you firm about drock and nate for sure i'll giveyou those two examples they're a fuck load more confident thanthey were when they came into my life because myconfidence rubbed off on them.

straight up. andres? - [andres] my question is kindof like austin's, what did a typical weekend looklike for you in college? - [gary] i worked every singleweekend of my college life at the liquor store and then i watched the jets game on sunday in the fall and then i tookamtrak back to boston and during january through may i worked every weekend.

i literally spent seven weekendsin four years in college. seven, seven. so i just worked. - [andres] whatwere those seven? - new girlfriends. that's really it, - [woman 12] didyou ask a question? - oh, i'm so sorry. andres, you fuckin' jerk.

- so sorry, i didn't see you.- it's fine. at the all-hands meeting youwere talking about how the entry level position is moving more toward the accountstrategy path,-- - [gary] yes. - what's your advice toentry level creative? - the good news is creative'swide-open meaning you can go directly you can apply to be a junior copywriter, you know, the truth is

i'm gonna talk to babcockabout that later this year. there's a tricky littlething with the creative thing. we're in a place where, we're ina place where there's a lot of business advantages to hiresomebody who's done it for a year somewhere else but i don't like that part and so i'm trying to figure out what's right. i don't want to beromantic about my own thing. right, i don't want to beideological my own way. the truth is i don't know.

actually this is a great way to like end this which is i, this is one thing i really don'thave an answer for because i definitely don't have theanswer that i want for people, i don't know but i can tell youthat i definitely want to try to figure out a way that peoplecould get that job straight out of school because they do it at every other place so why can't we? i just need to know how stevewants creative to judge that person 'cause i need to understand it.

guys, thanks for your time. - [group] thank you.- yeah. (applause) - [gary] have a great day.

Thursday, June 1, 2017

rent apartment hawaii


>>beth-ann: coming up next oninsights on pbs hawaii, a midtermlegislative update. [intro music] >>beth-ann: aloha and welcometo insights on pbs hawaii. i'm beth-ann kozlovich.from hawaii public radio sitting in tonight.we're about halfway through the legislative session, andlawmakers have just decided which bills they'll send fromthe house to the senate, and vice versa.the transition is known as

crossover and this year,measures that survived including bills that helphomeless people find shelter and other types of support.other surviving bills call for increase in fuel tax tobenefit operations of state department of transportationand still other legislation would impose a new tax onvacation rentals. so, what does all of this meanat the midpoint of the legislative session for youand your wallet? we'd like to hear from you duringtonight's show.

so call us with your questionsand comments at 973-1000 if you're on oahu, or800-238-4847 if you're on a neighbor island,you can also watch insights streamed live atpbshawaii.org just click on title of tonight's show, orfind us on twitter @pbshawai'i.nowto our guests. senator will espero is vicepresident of the senate and vice chair of public safety,intergovernmental and military affairs.senatorespero also sits on the

committee that oversees billsrelated to commerce, consumer protection and health.he alsorepresents the district of ewa beach.representative marcus oshiro is former choir of housefinance committee. since 1994, representedcentral oahu district that includes wahiawa and whitmorevillage. majority leader.2012, he was endorsed by then speaker calvin say to succeedhim as speaker of the house. led to another faction led bysouki.

also joining us is tomyamachika president of tax foundation of hawai'i,private nonprofit organization dedicated toinforming taxpayers about the finances of our state andlocal government. tom is also a tax attorney inprivate practice. we would like to you know thatmembers of the house majority leadership team includingspeaker joe souki declined to appear.lets get started. here we are.mid point of this session.

and as sessions begin to takeon a character, usually by this point, i'm curious whateach of you sees as you look out at the session.i'll start with you. marcus oshiro well, halfwaypoint right now, i think we're focusing upon the mostimportant issues of the day. and that's homelessness.one of the key issues that's going to be do define whetherthis is a successful or unsuccessful session.how we deal with homelessness.one of the most importantish

use of the day we're wrestlingwith right no. primarily budget drivenissue. how much money to do weallocate to honolulu service. housing fund.to house the homeless individuals.that's one of the most important issues today.>> i'll have to agree with the representative.senate passed over to the house over half a dozen billsthat deal with homelessness, service to the homeless orfunding the resolving fund or

hawai'i housing authority.certainly, this is the top issue for the majority of thelegislators and even the public.this issue is impacting and affecting every community,every island, and certainly, we need to put our, put themoney where our mouth is and provide some results.i don't see too much in terms of a lot of tax increases.this is session, especially since it's election year.the state did pass over the gas tax, the weight tax andregistration tax.

it was the very contentiousduring our third reading on that bill with eight senatorsincluding myself voting against that measure.>>beth-ann: surprised you're not included in your listanything having do with police reform and occc.we'll talk about that in a little bit.i want to get to yamachikaings.as you look at the session and having just watched almost$14 billion budget being passed over p from the houseto the senate, what do you

think about this session as wehave now come to the midpoint? >> well, we're still reallyjust kind of holding our breath to see what comesthrough. and what kind of threats facetaxpayers wallets. all of these things thatrepresentative oshiro and senator espero talked about,are valuable, but they do cost money.money has to come from somewhere.it won't be just their pockets.it will be with all of us.

we try to be vigilant.watch what's happening and make sure that taxpayers stayinformed about what the legislature is doing or isproposes to do so they can be informed and let theirpoliticians who represent them, know what's going on andknow their feelings on this issues.>>beth-ann: you brought up homelessness first.top of the list for many people.watching some of these bills more of and change and lookingat one of them in particular

that says, well, our goalshould be to create 22,500 units.but this idea of defining a goal and having it amount to,well, let's study it some more.that seems to be wrangling some people.>> it should. crisis, short 22, 25,000homes. need to build at least 2500over the next ten years. no need is to study it anyfurther. the question is right now, dowe have the will to fund the

programs.governor asked for 75 million.we gave him 25 million. he asked us to give him31 million or 31 million or so for the public housingrenovation. we gave him 3 or $4 million.he asked for us to lift the cap on the conveyance fee to goesto build affordable housing. we didn't even hear thatmeasure, consider that measure.these are sums of money that the private sector is askingus to make available so they

can get in there, leverage thepublic moneys, and build these housing units forpeople. permanent units for people.that that's going to help us address the crisis facingtoday. being number one in thecountry embarrassingly for homelessness.>>beth-ann: you're on the other side on the senate.you just heard from represent oshiro had to say.how do you look at some of these measures where theylook to be, maybe there was

going to be some money therebut nothing what the governor asked for.each year, we have to look at the total budget from thegovernor requests to senate priorities, housepriorities, and then the bills that are introduced byall of our members. and it's quite a task to comeup with plan that everybody likes because at the end ofthe day, our revenue stream is only this big, but the desiresand the demands and wants of our constituents are thisbig.

and so we're at the point nowwhere we're trying to provide a little more focus on the keyareas that we can all agree upon.and then make that decision on how much we can provide thesenate now is looking at the house budgetment and therewill certainly be change, i know that.schools, for example, was a big item for the governor withhis plan to provide ac for a thousand classrooms.that would impact my district significantly.it doesn't look like he's

going to get full100 million, but that's still an area that we're trying tosee what we can compromise and come up with.but certainly, it's not easy when you look at total budget,statewide, and what everyone is requesting.>>beth-ann: we're already getting some questions in.some of them i'm sure are going to be directed directlyat you, tom. this one in particular,looking at senate bill 2938, would increase voterregistration, weight and the

gas tax.why would the legislature do this when the department oftransportation has hundreds of millions of unspentfederal funds. spending money wisely andwell, and being assured that we are ever the money that'scollected from taxpayers will go will be spent well seems tobe what's behind all of this. i want to talk to you aboutthat fuel tax though. mcaleer we are in an electionyear and people have gotten really used to going to thepump and not feeling such a

sting and along comes thisbill. >> this kind of a couplethings going on here. one is that there is part ofthe fuel tax law that kind of died at the end of 2015because it was part of the 2012 law, end of 2015, revertback to what it was for that particular law was enacted.and the effective it was dropped the tax down, droppedthe fuel tax down one cent. ied diesel down one cent anddid a number of other things that i guess department oftransportation didn't know

was going to happen.so now they're oh, my god, we had this money was we thoughtwas coming to us and it's now going down the tube.also doesn't help that the price of gasoline kind of shotdown so any, fuel tax is based on gallonage rather thanvalue, but certainly demand kind of a fit.now, in terms of how the department spents its money,i know senator tokuda this past summer, had hearings, anumber of departments to task for, okay, you have all ofthese federal grants.

are you spending them down.in most instances the answer was no and they were gettingin trouble with the feds for having all of this money thatgrants to them, weren't spending it and the federalfeds were starting to say, if you can't spend this moneythat we're giving you, why should we give you any more?i think the caller who gave that you request he is kind ofthinking the same for this this particular tax measure,one of the departments that was on the hit list or the hotles, past summer was

department oftransportation. because they have what iscalled federal backlog of about, i think it's down to$600 billion.which is basically they start afederal project, federal money get encumbered.but can't spend them all at once.so there's a normal and a expected level of backlogthat you expecting for a department of our size.feds told us $450 million. quite a bit of differencebetween 450 million which is

where the feds which theyshould be, and where we are, which is like 600 i believe.so the question then becomes, why can't we spend the moneydown? you know, there he delays,.>> let met interject. with the federal funds,usually, there is ceremony amount that's state needs tomatch as well. it's not like we have600 million that we could spend anyway we want.sometimes like 80, federal, 20, state.and then you're talking about

not only roads and freeways,but when you're talking transportation, for example,you're talking harbors, airports, and freeways.for example, lower south road when it was built in kapolei,that cost $155 million. so depending on a size of aproject, that money could be spent down quickly.the senate, vote on that bill was 10 were yes.six were with reservations. which means they weren't toosure, but they'll pass it at this point in time.and eight of us said no.

one reason why we felt thatthis was not necessary at this time because d.o.t. does somegood work, but they've also been criticized for beinginefficient. for example, conveniently,when governor ige came on board, there was $14 millioncontract that he canceled with the department oftransportation. it was financial accountingcontract. because of the just the factthat it was going nowhere and it was a waste of money.and then i can recall five or

six years ago, we had a groundbreaking or a pm zipper lane that would assist and helpcentral oahu, and west oahu, and millions of dollars werespent on that, and then couple years later, canceled that.so there's been cases of inefficiencies and evennational report that said, the state, per highway mile isspending $90,000 in admin costs compared to other partsof the nation that are spending $10,000 or less.and 1,000 or less. >> which is still 10,000 orless.

>>beth-ann: considerablyless. >> i think it's going tochallenge. from the rule of thumb, wedon't want to raise taxes in an election year.it doesn't help your reelection.number two, i think people need to understand the reasonwhy proposed that, these are the funding sources to matchthe federal dollars, requiring the federal drawdown, you need to have to the state match, for highways,freeways, by ways, all of the

improvements that peoplerequest. we get calls from.repeatedly day in and day out. eighty-four dollars a car, ayear. so break it down, 12 months,about seven dollars a month. 350, about 25 cents a day.if you spread it out over entire year.that's additional cost per vehicle.and given the price of gasoline today, where it isright now, record low i think the lowest it's it's beenseveral years now.

i can understand why thegovernor proposed this. this also the factor thatcongress recently passed some highway expenditure billthat's good for five years. so the governor wants to makesure we have access to all five years of drawing downthat money. but again, at the end of theday for all of these good reasons, i don't think we'llbe able to muster the votes to get it out.very challenging election year.unless you can make the case

that the monies will be spentappropriately, cut the overhead and we can deal withthe backlog of federal funds. but it's a tough go aheadright now. >>beth-ann: thanks very muchto sam from kalihi for the call.lots of questions here for u someone says, love the show.nice to know. rapid transit growth ofillegal vacation rentals have devastated coastalcommunities pushing out local families what areas theymoved in.

spectators are moving in,speculators are moving in. can't afford to rent.more vacation rentals in ko'olau and other areas.horrible housing crises as we're facing now, why is itstill being put forth. another question asking aboutthe air b and b bill. collects those funds.a lot of people concerned about the transient.>> i have concerns with the bill.i think the idea is intention is to generate the revenuesthat's being lost by this

illegal rental.the concern that many people have is you're going tosanction, condone illegal rentals that shouldn't beoperating in the first place. by allowing private collectorof taxes, might not be getting right now, might provideillegal screen for those illegal vacation rentals.that's kind of the dynamic going back and forthrightnow. >> what we're really talkingabout is just an alternative collection mechanism.for example, if senator here

goes to work, he gets paid bythe state, but he doesn't get all of it directly.he gets part of it with help because his employerwithholds tax because employer has the money, canpay it over to the state, much more efficient fashion thanjust paying it to willie and hoping that he'll pay thestate. now, at some point, you haveto look at a withholding mechanism.you realize it's more efficient the.that's why we all have

withholding if you're anemployee. there's several kinds ofwithholding. including there's scheme formultiple level marketing already in law.and that's what's being proposed here.now, the issue then becomes, all right, are you going touse this withholding mechanism to, quote, sanctionillegal behavior? so it's like, somebody going to anemployer and saying geez, shall i be asking all of myemployee, are you current on

credit cards, current on themortgage? if not, shouldn't i be paying the mortgagecompany, and credit cap? if i just pay the employeedirectly, am i sanctioning illegal behavior? at somepoint, you have to say, look, these employees, peopleyou're paying money to, did adults, business people, haveresponsibility for what they're doing.that's where the responsibility lies.then the part about collecting the money is just,and mechanism to collect and

pay it to the state moreefficiently. >> we heard the bill today inconsume protection and how longing.it would allow the brokers to collect the money from peoplethat are renting the rent transient rental units andbed & breakfast. >>beth-ann: agentings likeairb&b. >> exactly.they would be able to collect the t.a.t. tax, generalexcise tax and from that perspective, it's good idea.is there a way that we can have

the broker check on whetherthe unit that's being rented out is legal or illegal.if it's illegal, they wouldn't be able toparticipate within that program.and. >> not only to be collectingthe fees but also having to be that gatekeeper for whetherit's legal or illegal. >> they have to put an addressup. next to that address, puttheir tax number verification to show that, yes, we arelegal.

so that's the discussionright now we're having with these brokers.and that will probably help decide whether to bill movesforward or not. >>beth-ann: we going to talkabout honolulu ea homelessness and that touchedoff a number of calls from people.a will the off calls, seemingly have very similarsentiments. this one, i read where ittakes $40,000 to support houselessness.we have a job fair to support

themselves.how many of people working poor are driven into homelesswhen the state spends millions of dollars onhomeless people. why does the state have tofund homeless people that come from the mainland.you hear same things. some might be more myth thanbased in reality. level of understanding abouthomelessness seems to be one of the battles thatcollectively we've been fighting or hearing aboutcoming through the

legislature as well as justgeneral conversations about social services and thosepeople who providing them. how do you answer some ofthese questions to people who see clearly that there arehomeless people in our communities but really, don'tunderstand some of the ways in which they weave into thehealth and well-being of them.>> well, thank you. i think first of all, there isan urban myth or urban legend out there that we havethousands of folks from the

mainland flying over herefrom their respective state on the mainland.the facts are, majority of people are homeless are localresident. people born and raised here,families here, went to school here.that's the majority of the people.another fact that pointed out, majority of them willhave some sort of income. either through some type ofjob, employment, but they can't afford to pay rentalhousing or the other type of

housing.another fact maybe half of these individuals arerecently homeless. these are ones that because ofloss of jobs, catastrophic illness, something going onin the household, have lost their housing.so we can back into rental housing or some kind ofpermanent housing. but that's half of them.>> where rapid rehousing. >> giving them the first monthrent, helping them with 3, 4, 5 months rent.social services, mental

health service, drug plan,food stamp, et cetera, also those out there who havesevere mental challenges. mentally disabled.that's where we need to put more time and money into it.lloyd pendleton, he is the guru, best rock star, bestpractices called housing first.if you provide shelter, clean, dry or sober,providing shelter. other things will be broughtto them. mental health care, jobtraining, ged, domestic

violence kind of situations.but you need to start with housing.>>beth-ann: which is what they did in utah where theytook about a 20 people who were as lloyd pendleton justsaid, worst of the worst and put them into housing and ayear later, they still had most of them there maybe justa few who had dropped out. >> extremely successful rate,not having the recidivism that you might otherwisethink. it's kind of intuitive aboutthank you works.

good policy.with good spending, best policy and success.that's where we're going right now.to answer some of the concerns that have been raised.>> at the end of the day, if we need to provide moreaffordable housing, the sad thing is that housing is veryexample expensive in hawai'i. especially when you compareto the mainland. and the fact that many inlarge majority of our homeless are underemployed isan issue that we need to help

in terms of rentalvoucherses, and helping them find full-time permanentpositions for all members of their family.but if we don't provide and aren't creative working withthe private sector and nonprofit it's, theultimately, build some low cost affordable housing andrental, we're never going to fix this problem.and i don't see this problem getting fixed for minimum offive years at the very least. but we need to work togetherand many of us are hoping with

the rail system andtransit-oriented development, we'll be able tobuild high density communities around these railstations, microunits that they're looking at in kakaakofor example, and look at other ways to provide housing thatour residents can afford. >> unone. things that we maywant to think about is that right now, the way our taxsystem set up, very very different from how it is inany other state, we tax rent. so our general excise taxapplies to rent, so somebody

who is renting out a unit for$100, has to pay $4.50 into our state general fund.now, the question is as a policy matter is itappropriate across the entire spectrum? you would think itwould be appropriate for maybe higher end rentals, butwhat about the lower. >> i think the legislature isrying to address that right now.several years ago, we passed out a low income renters taxcredit. it was good for two years.provided $7 million in relief

to low income renters outthere. bill in the september rightnow that will tie that to the cpi.over several years. that's part of the solution tooffset the g.e.t. being plied.but certain class of low income renters out there.we're trying to address that. >> interesting thing thoughis that when you give people that credit through the taxsystem, you're making them file a very, very complicateddocument.

not everybody does that.>>beth-ann: that puts a barrier in front of them wherethey could have access it to it but perhaps don't know theycan or simply don't file the paper work.along the discussion that we've had talking about thevarious populations within those who are homeless,nobody mentioned veterans. as of the end of last you're,we were getting very near functional zero for veterans.theological would still apply to us where we are now, butbringing up the issue of how

much g.e.t. someone who atthat low end including a veteran would have to paymakes it more difficult to get somebody housed.>> obviously, veterans are important w he have to look ateverybody. whether you're a veteran or not a veteran.single parent, or elderly individual or unwith mentalhealth problems, drug addiction.we need to look at all the community.there are certainly others out there, nonprofits helpingour veterans and they are

several bills actuallyhelping veterans in other ways.certainly, that is an area that's being looked at.>>beth-ann: all right. tonight we're talking aboutbills that survived the legislative crossover.would like to hear from you. call, e-mail or tweet yourquestions and comments. call us at 9 73-1000 or800-238-4847 if you're calling from a neighborisland. we want you to know thatmembers of the housing

majority leadership teamincluding speaker joe souki, declined to appear.we're going to get back to it. lots and lots of calls andquestions coming in. a lot of them about housingand about homelessness. this one specifically goingback to housing, windward side, because of vacationrentals. adding to shortage because hehave rentals for fair rental price.some of the reasons why i don't approve the growingamount of rentals forced upon

our community every year.susan yamada sent that in. how would you answer her?>> first of all, regulation of illegal is with the city &county. that's their kuleana rightnow. as far as the political heentity, should be the city & county enforcing it.means of taxing it is what we're trying to bring as asolution. for the t.a.t. and the g.e.t.that we're not collecting right now.as far as enforcement, what's

appropriate in thatparticular district, or area, on the north shore also.that's also a problem there. but it's primarily with thecity & county. >> zoning issues are countylevel. so.>>beth-ann: this brings up a point.every time we have an issue that comes up, everyone runsto someone they feel is going to listen their case about it.do we expect too much from state government?>> do we expect too much from

city government?>> i don't think so. what's unique about hawai'iis we're the largest population of 1.4 millionthat's the furthest from any other land mass.and we are in a very unique situation in that ourpopulation is continually growing.next 50 years, i project there could be another 500,000people living on oahu. and as our populationgrowing, our land just finite, that's not changing.so sadly, it looks like the

cost of living is going tocontinue to grow and we might turn into a state of have andhave nots, if we don't address some of these major policyissues today in terms of land use, in terms of growth anddevelopment, housing issues, agriculture, they're all tiedin to transportation to our growing population.and we're going to have to make some very difficultdecisions at the city level as well as the state level.because that's what our job is in government.and we don't always please

everybody because one issuecould have three or four points of views.that's where it's difficult that we try to come up withwhat is best for everyone. >> let me, i guess challengeone of the prefaces behind that.seen a study, says over the past 7 years from kind of acrash to present, we've on average, lost 2% of ourpopulation a year. so there are starting here,they're going to other states.and this is something that

perhaps you would expect whenyou have a high tax system. people start voting withtheir feet. every ten years, ourpopulation has increased. there are dips and we do havea lot of residents leaving but we have a lot of immigrantscoming here as well, whether they're from the mainland,canada or asia. population wise, every tenyears, it's increased anywhere from 11 to 17,000every ten years. >>beth-ann: we're going tohave a little bit more concern

about how we use the land thatwe do. already, we've seenagriculture being front and center in all of in with a lotof the controversy where we're taking ago land turningit into housing or how we're going to feed ourselvesbetter. we're not going to be able todo it 50% perhaps. something do the move the needneedle. a lot of calls asking aboutwhen are we going to see support for agriculture.slowly disappearing.

that's sad.from honoka'a. dan from hilo, withagriculture disappearing in hawai'i, is it not a waste tocontinue funding the department of agriculture.others asking the question, how do we create a streamlinedand integrated plan for keeping ag in hawai'i.what's going to happen with hcns.they're going to be taking about 36,000 acres out ofsugar cultivation. this is a and b.alexander & baldwin property

on maui.the question there is what it's going to happen to 675employees within the next year or so.what the going to happen with the water on the east mauiirrigation system that's currently going to thoselands, that could be repurposed for diversifiedagriculture. that's one of the big issuesfacing us right now. it's highly controversialbecause you have a court ruling that declared fourwater permits to be in

violation of the law.they're not temporary. that was like a license.go for ten to 12 years. what happens in the meanwhiledepartment until department of land and natural resourceswater commission to figure out a procedure to addressuses and other use us of this water.shut the it tap off? what happens to all the lands outthere? that's been cultivated for 140 years.but the same time, you want to recognize the rights underthe constitution of water

being a public resource.public trust. exactly.you have the taro farmers. you have the nativehawaiians, storing their streams.flood plains and estuaries. all legitimate valid reasons.we're hoping the parties can come together and find somekind of understanding and common ground.there's a lot there. we all want to be foodsecurity, safe. we want to be able to grow ourown food.

>> some of our own food.talking about growing our own food.we have to remember we only have a certainly amount ofland and not be able to feed all of ourselves.>> if we can do 10, 15% locally, if we can do that,that's material difference of what we're currentlyexporting out of our state. >> we have been supportingagriculture in the wahiawa region and central oahu.looked at purchasing some of the private agriculture landsand make them public lands

that we could lease out to ourfarmers. we've looked at low interestloans. we've looked at supportinginfrastructure like irrigation systemsespecially on the neighbor islands.one of the major problems, however, is that our youth donot want to be farmers. everything is technology.and other areas. nothing we talked to some whoare very clearly looking at that and farmers trying tobring them in.

even richard haas saying withhis farm, love to see some new young farmers.trying to to that. >> not looking at agricultureas a career. farming land is tougher anddifficult. and if we can provideincentives for our young people in our youth to getinvolved that, could help as well.but organic farming is doing really well in hawai'i.and i know that larry jeffs, he has 3,000 acres on oahu,and he sells out.

he doesn't have a problem.so it can be profitable. but it takes a certainindividual. one area we're looking at a inproduct for us is hemp for example.and that's something that -- >>beth-ann: that bill isstill alive. >> yes, it is.that's something that we're hoping that can be a benefitto us because of literally thousands of uses that helpcan provide. >> part of broaderdiscussion.

here you have hawai'i.limited amount of land. limited amount of naturalresources. what do you put in oureconomic engine to make it run? right now, the onlything that's providing any significant output istourists. and the question becomes, dowe want to try to stimulateel agriculture.the manufacturing? kind of what being pushed last year.do you want to get a really big put a big push on hightechnology? let the market

desaid.what do you want to do? that's very good questions.>>beth-ann: speaking of questions, we have many morecoming in. thank you very much he forgiving those to us. asking you to please commenton the idea of home owners renting to people who arehomeless for a tax break. what are the pros and cons ofthis proposal? >> i don't believe there's abill considering that. but that's something we canconsider.

>>beth-ann: would you seeanything from a tax perspective where this wouldbe a good or not such a good idea, tom?>> i would have to kind of look at it further.>>beth-ann: talking about specifically.we're going to leave that one going.in from your percent peck defensive, do you seethe-perspective, did you see owner occupied rentals andrenter occupied. between of the disparity.equal or unfair.

people who have second homes,should there be a different tax structure.how do you assess that? that's what i think drivingthis question. >> right now, you have torealize the county issue because we don't own theproperty. and the state does not own theproperty. we used to.but now, that decision is driven back down to thecounties since 1980s. what the city & county ofhonolulu did was created this

secondary propertyclassification called residential a, which was like70% higher in terms of tax rate.property assessed over a million dollars is notqualifying for the owner, homeowner exemption.and there have been like growing pains with thatbecause certain issues have come up over the first becauseof couple of years, that that's happened, and peoplewere doing can all kinds of hand wringing trying tostraighten those issues out.

one way of dealing with that.>>beth-ann: we're going to move on in the interest oftime. here's the question that ithink is very much in your bailiwick.what is the status of negotiations for the state tobuy federal prison? >> right now, i'm not awarethat the federal government wants to sell that prison forstarters. because they need a federalfacility. it's really not a highpriority at least not at the

legislature.if anyone were to initiate those talks, it should be thegovernor and maybe reaching out to our congressionaldelegation. but that's nothing that we'renecessarily dealing right now with the legislature.>>beth-ann: we have been talking about occc.yes. >>beth-ann: what about moneyfor that which doesn't look like it's going to comethrough this year? >> right.that was priority for the

governor to move occc, maymake it more modern, more efficient and take it fromkalihi. the governor was looking athalawa where our prison is now.and the cost of that prison was the excess of$400 million. governor came in with aproposal that would have exempted the state from ea oreis and that got shut down quickly.i think the house wanted the governor to relook at kalihisite and see if they could

make a facility,, jail inparticular on a smaller foot print.honestly, right now, i'm not too sure where thatdiscussion is going to go. we still have to take up thehouse measure in the senate. but certainly, it's apriority. but we need to have same thingbetween the house, senate and the governor and we're not yetthere. >>beth-ann: what about issuesof overcrowding? because we have heard very often thatthere are two, three,

sometimes four times theamount of people who should be in a certain footprint.and glenn from hawaii kai would like to know, who makethe decision to decide how and when prisoners are releaseddue to overcrowding and what plans are in place?>> right now, there's no plans to release any inmates in thenear future because of overcruding.but that's always a possibility.if the federal government looks at stepping in.the director, there's a bill

where the director wants torelease those that have been sentenced to misdemeanors,low risk, nonviolent, and pretrial.and he's got a bill that address about 300 ininmates.but i have always been a strong advocate of electronicmonitoring, go. ps, 24-7, device, and puttingmore emphasis on rehabilitation and re-entry.because that's where an inmate is within our domainand if we can stop that inmate from going back to a life ofcrime, that means one less

criminal in our systembecause right now, the recidivism rate is about 50%.and at one point, used to be 60, 70.we're trying to get it down to 30, 40.and if we could just reduce the recidivism rate, we canreduce the overpopulation and prison population.>>beth-ann: we're talking about all of this, putting iton the side, look at hpd for reform.several bills including the body cam about i will.including of creating overall

panel looking at issues ofstandards and able to investigate properly, somesay that's really missing. there aren't any teeth in anyof this. >> we have three bill from thesenate that went to the house. one has to do with bodycameras. and providing standard onbody cameras in terms of the video and the film.and making it standard across all counties because rightnow, it's each county doing things individually.we're hoping that will move

forward.two major, independently review board in the case whereofficer is involved in a shooting or a death incustody, and serious bodily harm.and the third one would be the standards and training board.we're the only state in the nation that doesn't have thestatewide standards and training.post professional officer standards and training.and it's done at the county level.but we have bills that are

alive.we think those bills can still be amended.and we're trying to work with the law enforcement agenciesas well. we're not only talking aboutcounty police. we're talking about statesheriffs, harbor police, airport police, conservationpolice, department of taxation have policeofficers. prosecutor had policeofficers. you may have heard about thatgun that went off within the

prosecutor's office.we're hoping that statewide, we can make some positiveimprovements. >>beth-ann: now that's overon the house side, wait and see what happens with that.>> that's correct. >>beth-ann: one of the thingsthat everyone is concerned about and not just in a yearwhere we're going to be casting votes, about youlooking at income tax. last year, we watched thosenine, ten, and 11% rates sunset.and it looks like they're

coming back.>> at this point, there is a bill alive senate bill 2454,looking at willie's cheat sheet here, that wouldretroactively bring those tax rates back.to january 1 of this year. so that is supposed to be arevenue neutral bill. so i call it a robyn hood bill.basically takes from the rich and gives to the poor.and again, i think the technical probable almostswould come in because it's retroactive.but we, you know, looked at

bills like that last year, andwhat we said at that time was, okay, you guys in 2009promised the taxpayers that this tax increase would betemporary. five years and that would beit. taxpayers believed you.if you're going to do this kind of thing, retract it tothe beginning of the year, isn't that breaking apromise? maybe not you, about you your predecessorsmaybe. >> just to be clear, we'retalking about single

individuals who are makingover $150,000 a year. and couples i believe, it'seither 250 or $300,000 a year. and it's a lot about taxequity. with this bill, manyindividuals, the lower income residents, will not have a taxburden and right now, it's about 45 million of bothways. 45 increase and 45 millionless of a burden on low income and poor.>>beth-ann: there are still going to be some costsassociated with having to

switch other and having itactually happen. it's not go just going tosimply be totally neutral. >> there's always costinvolved. but i mean, that's, you justhave to do that if you're going to make these changes.>> but even with top tax, quarter% i think kicks in at100,000, maybe less, you've still got one of the top taxrates in the nation, around number 15 or so.when we adopted 9, 10 and 11, we became number one andcalifornia since knocked us

off the top spot, but that'sreally not a place where you want to be.>>beth-ann: what would be a better way? if it were toaccomplish the same things that those in the ledge aretrying to by reinstating this?>> you really need to ask yourself what is the moneybeing spent for. is it being spentefficiently. spent for things we reallyneed to have as opposed to what we want to have, or somepeople want to have.

it's about pry orders. youhave to decrease-priorities. take the scarce dollars thatpeople have, you're making them part with it and i thinkthe in general, make wise use of those funds to get themdeployed efficiently and to do good work.>>beth-ann: common criticism comes across as well, stateisn't spending my money well and i don't like this and idon't like that. you hear a lot of that.certainly, you get that too when you're down at thelegislature.

looking at how you're going tospend taxpayer dollars. and looking at how it's goingto be, looking at what just came over from the house tothe senate. doesn't look like we're goingto have a year where we're going to run into deficitspending. >> this is going to be theyear. both the governor's financialplan and his budget requests tell us we're going to bedeficit spending this year and the next fiscal year.so '17-'17, i think we're

going to be deficit spending.fortunately, we're coming out of record increase in fundbalances going back to 2013, 844 million.2014, 664. 2015, 820 million.these are high level fund balances.i finance committee, when i chaired, we had about$500 million. talking about that was a bigbudget back then. let's not forget, greatrecession, 2008-2012, barely skipped by.i think prudence dictates

that we spend our moneycarefully, budget appropriately and take a goodclear, honest assessment what we need, what we can pay for,and how do we get the most bang for our buck.real quick. i think what chair tokuda islooking at is should be a little more progressive.carry a higher burden for our taxpayer, pay for essentialservices. that's why she's pursuingthis. i don't know about the retroactivity, i think that's

problematic.generally notions i think is a fair one.i think it's legitimate one. as far as who can best bear theadditional cost in our society.>>beth-ann: one more thing to ask you p.when we talked to carl about the u.h. economic researchassociation. this may be as good as it getsthis year and last year. at some point, we're going tobe looking at another recession.how much are you concerned

about that as you're look atpossible deficit spending this year and what may happenas we go forward?. i think carl is right on.i think if you look at what's going on in the stock market,price of oil right now, what's going on in europe, look atwhat's going on in japan, look at, interest on this willmonetary front, something is going on out there.i think the caution approach, is the better approach, moreprudent. and watch these trends rightnow.

every seven years average,economy goes into a cycle of a recession or somethingclose to that, definitely a marketplace disruption.and there are signs out there right now.signaling that we might face come fall, or early part ofnext year. >>beth-ann: what would haveto go in just a moment. certainty will espero, i wantto have you answer that. how concerned are you aboutdeficit spending. >> always concerned aboutdeficit spending and the

revenue.constituents request eye demand.we're in our 56th, 57th year as a state.since statehood and a lot of our infrastructure built inthe sixties and seventies, even eighties, they'regetting older. and much need to be repairand/or replaced. and so like i said, the costof a new prison alone would be $400 million.so the last thing we want to do is raise taxes.but then the last thing we

want to do is also cutgovernment services. and that's the delicatebalance that we have in government.and in the legislature. every year.>>beth-ann: tom, deficit spending as we look at thisbeing the potentially the one of better years we're going tosee. >> one of the things we haveto consider is that we are obligated for billions andbillions of dollars for our state worker he benefits.unfunded liabilities.

we have tons and tons ofthose. numbers that are less thanwhat we have now. took down a big city inmichigan. we really have to be carefulabout what we do and how many demands we think we cananswer. because we have to berealistic when we look at this.>>beth-ann: thank all of you for joining us tonight.good to be able to talk to you. we're going to see whathappens as we go into the

second half.certainly, we weren't able to get to all of the questionsthat people gave us tonight, although many ex-many of themi must tell you that we didn't get to, had to do withhomeless and people saying you need to do deeper into theissue of homelessness. couple people thinking it wasclueless at this point. we know that this is anongoing conversation and we hope that we're going to behave able to have more of them with you and with others.so thank you very much for

being here.i appreciate your time. before we go, we want to letyou know that members of the house majority leadershipteam including speaker joe souki declined to appear.next time on insights on pbs hawaii, we ask what's it liketo age out of hawai'i's foster care system at 18.you'll hear from former foster children and we'lltalk about a new program that extends foster care.what do hawai'i's foster youth need to transition intoa successful adulthood?

thanks to pbs hawai'i forletting a colleague from hawai'i public radio sit intonight. i'm beth-ann kozlovich.aloha.