Friday, April 7, 2017

rent apartment den haag


>>> council of the city ofnorfolk is now in session. please remaining standing forthe pledge of allegiance. appreciate it.>> dear heavenly father, thank you for this day and for yourmany displays of love through tangible and intangibleblessings too numerous to measure.bless the city of norfolk and every citizen who resides withinit's boundaries and every city employee who works to make ourcity great. father, bless our mayor, ourcity manager and this council as

we labor together in the callingof pluck service. give usã¡-- public service.give us the wisdom to govern fairly and ethically withequality, integrity, and compassion, and allow us torepresent our city in a spirit of excellence.i pray you will guide us through these difficult economic timesand give us the strength and wisdom we need to make thedecisions that face us. these and all other blessings weask in your son's name. amen.>> amen.

>> i pledge allegiance to theflag of the united states of america, and to the republic forwhich it stands, one nation under god, indivisible, withliberty and justice for all. >> thank you.thanks very much. clerk will call the roll,please. >> mr. burfoot.>> here. >> mr.ã¡protogyrou.>> here. >> mr.ã¡smigiel.>> here. >> dr.ã¡whibley.>> here.

>> ms. williams.>> here. >> mr.ã¡winn.>> here. >> mr.ã¡fraim.>> here. moex to excuse mr. riddickplease. >> mr. burfoot.>> aye. >> mr.ã¡protogyrou.>> aye. >> mr. smigiel.>> aye. >> dr. whibley.>> aye. >> ms.ã¡williams.>> aye.

>> mr. winn.>> aye. >> mr. fraim.>> aye. >> motion is to dispense withthe reading of the minutes of the previous meeting.mr. burfoot. >> aye.>> mr.ã¡protogyrou. >> aye.>> mr.ã¡smigiel. >> aye.>> dr.ã¡whibley. >> aye.>> ms. williams. >> aye.>> mr.ã¡winn.

>> aye.>> mr.ã¡fraim. >> aye.>> read the resolution of the closed meeting.>> a resolution certifying a closed meeting of the council ofthe city of norfolk held in accordance with the provisionsof the virginia freedom of information act.adopt the resolution. mr. burfoot.>> aye. >> mr. protogyrou.>> aye. >> ms. williams.>> aye.

good evening, ladies andgentlemen, and welcome to the norfolk city council chambers.thanks for coming out on this rainy night.story we're getting startedã¡-- sorry we're getting started alittle late, but i promise you we were doing the city'sbusiness down below before we stepped up here.for those of you who do not regularly attend our councilsessions, the process we'll follow is the first thing we dois take up the public hearings and i think there are three ofthose matters i'm sorry, there's

six and then we move to theconsent agenda, probably vote on all the consent agenda items atone time and then move to the regular agenda.we'll vote on all these matters in just the way they are numberon the printed docket. at the conclusion of the regularagenda, if any member of the public would like to address thecity council on a non-agenda item, something that's not onour printed docket, you will be given that opportunity and anumber of you have elected to do that.all you need to do to get your

name called is sign a slip ofpaper which the clerk has made available in the waiting roomoutside of the council chambers before the meeting began.so those are the rules. if there are no ceremonialmatters, so the first thing we're going to do is movedirectly to public hearing number one, please.>> public hearing scheduled this day pursuant to action of thecouncil on july 10, 2012, under the state law, on theapplication of the city planning commission to amend the generalplan and the zoning ordinance of

norfolk 1992, to createdefinitions for character districts within the city andshow their location. by 6-1 vote, planning commissionrecommends approval. >> the first thing we'd like todo, mr.ã¡manager, is to have a brief presentation by thedirector of planning, frank duke.frank, will tell you usã¡-- come up here for the benefit of thepublic and the council, how we got to are with we are, and howthe ordinance is drafted, please.>> yes, mr.ã¡mayor.

first let me stress that this isnot something that we've just come up with in the past fewmonths. this is an issue that councilasked us to look at several years ago.any city that has developed over time obviously has developedwith different patterns, different characteristics indifferent areas of that locality reflecting the prevalentdevelopment requirements at the time it was developed.and norfolk is no different from any other city in that regard.our current ordinances, however,

are all drafted as though thisis a suburban place. i believe mr. burfoot was theperson who asked me several years ago, can't you figure outa way to recognize that we have very urban parts of this cityinstead of continuing to regulate everything as part ofthe suburban place? and that's really what this isthe beginning step of. this is not a regulatory changewe're making at this time. this is a planning process thatwe're in right now. the regulatory processes willhave to come later.

i wish i could tell you this isgoing to be the end, the final vote on this.it is not. you're going to continue to seethis issue come up as we look at trying to revise some of ourordinances, particularly ordinances that council has saidyou want us to look at regarding parking and open space.but the first step is to define the boundaries because once wehave the boundaries defined, we then will be able to place thoseboundaries on the map to begin to set up that regulatory step.so the first step as planning

step.the ordinanceã¡-- you've two ordinances in front of youtonight. the first one is simply toapprove a general plan amendment that in general areas depictswhat should be or what weã¡-- the planning commission hasrecommended to you should be the boundaries for the characterdistricts . it is not defined as any legalboundaries, although that will have to be done as the next stepof this pr ses. but this is is a general image,the general map revision saying

these are the general areases ofour city that have the characteristics of downtown,these are generally places that were developed in the 19thcentury or earlier, places that are urban, which are largelythose places that were developed prior to the 1950s.they are largely the older neighborhoods of our city andplaces that are more suburban, the areas that have beendeveloped essentially in the last half of the 20th century.so the first thing is just do we have the boundaries right.the planning commission by a

vote of 6-1 has said these arethe correct boundaries. can you change those boundariestoday? absolutely.you just simply would have to tell us you would like to havethose boundaries changed, and we work with the city attorney'soffice to change the attachment or the exhibit to that ordinanceand we can make that happen. second part of this is purely adefinitions change, defining what is urban, what is suburban,and what is downtown. once we have this general mapplanning amendment taken care of

and we have these definitions inmace, we would then be bringing forwards to you the next ofthese ordinances, which we are working on, and that would dealwith parking changes, again reflecting the general characterof the areas of the city so that we do not try to apply one sizefits all across all of norfolk. >> okay.any other questions for mr.ã¡duke?>> frank, many people are confused that they don'tunderstand why we're doing the boundaries.we're not doing the boundaries

and the specifics of the parkingand green space at the same time.can you make that clear to them that this is not something we'reable to do? >> it's not something we can dobecause in order to begin refining those regulatorychanges, i've got to be able to have a legal definition of theareas where they would take effect.so we are going to have to create a legal definition.we've already begun working with the city attorney's office tocreate that legal definition,

looking at the boundaries thatthe planning commission has recommended.once we have these general boundaries, we can create thelegal descriptions so that we can then begin to create thoseregulatory changes and have them in front of you.>> if i may, i think what mr.ã¡duke means is a legaldescription of metes and bounds. the use of the map today islegal, but it's not metes and bounds.>> mr.ã¡pishko is correct. thank you, bernard.>> okay, frank.

stand by, we may want to ask yousome questions. >> i have one.>> sure. >> frank, i looked at thedropbox and i've got map upon map upon map.i can't figure outã¡-- and maybe it's justã¡-- i can't figure outwhich oneã¡-- there's one that says staff and i apologize, onesays cpc recommendation. another says administrationrecommendation. another one says staffrecommendation. another one saysã¡-- and thenthere's a different one.

frank, which one are weã¡-- whichone are you asking usã¡-- which is the 6-1 vote of planning?>> the planning commission recommendation is the map thatis shown on your attachments as cpc recommendation.and this is that map. the second map you have is thevote that the minority of the planning commission recommended,which included two properties that the majority of planningcommission did not recommend. >> all right.so i can get this right, cpc recommendation, and we'retalking about the properties on

the north side of brambletonwhere the hague medical building and it's the hague tower.>> yes, sir. >> and it's the red crossbuilding. >> and the red cross.>> that was not in the cpc recommendation, nor was that inthe minority recommendation. that is showing, when you seethe administration recommendation, and that isbecause after briefing council, you had asked do i have an easycategory where the red cross building could fit in and theanswer is no.

it is currently zoned as part ofdowntown, so it was the easiest way to keep them whole.what staff is recommending and what the administration isrecommending is the graphic that is relates to downtown of theurban areas that is shown as the administration recommendation.that is also consistent, you look at the attachment to theordinance with the graphic that is shown there, which iscitywide, because those other maps are simply blow-ups of thearea where there have been the greatest conversation and thegreatest contention.

>> mr.ã¡president, are theattachments to ordinances labeled cd 6 characterdistricts? i'm not sure i understand youranswer to dr. whibley, but the red cross is included downtownin the cd-6 characteristic district attachment.>> and we're voting on staff recommendation andadministrative recommendation. >> the administrationrecommendation is what we have in front of you, but yes, again,as i indicated, we have spoken to the attorney's office and youcan make modifications in this

map tonight and that then willbe the basis for the regulatory changes of the metes and boundslegal definition that we need for the regulatory changes.>> all right. so, again, you just said staffrecommendation is the one that we're voting on tonight.not cpc recommendation. >> that's correct.>> and the staff recommendation for the ordinance is labeledcd-6, characteristic districts, so this is one attachment to theordinance. the others were given to you forinformation and i'm not sure

they're shedding light on it.cd-6, characteristic districts, attached to the ordinance, andit has the boundaries that mr.ã¡duke just described.>> i'm going back toã¡-- >> this is a staffadministrationã¡-- staff and administration have labeleddowntown to include red cross, hague tower, and hague medical.and that's what we're voting and if we vote yes, then thosebecome in the downtown district. >> downtown.>> yes. >> okay.i'm sorryã¡--

>> the administrationrecommendations are the same then?>> i have cd-6 characteristic districts and it does show, so ican better understand what terri is saying, it does show that thehague medical building and the hague tower and theã¡-- itappears to be the red cross will be in the downtown district.frank, how would this affect, if we were to look at the areanorth of brambleton and to decide that we wished that areato be an arts district, a thriving arts district toconnect at some point the

chrysler and the opera house toscope and beyond. how does this, characterizing itas downtown, does that very effect if we were to decide todo that in our discussions at the retreat?>> as it relates to these three properties?>> yes. >> no, sir.the area we have looked at at trying to create this artsdistrict where it would be able to connect the opera house, thechrysler, scope, that's the area that there is a consensus fromall parties ought to be included

as downtown.>> okay. >> because what we need to do toenable this arts district is modify regulations to relaxparking, to relax the open space requirements, so that we canaccommodate kind of an arts district.>> higher density and make it more of a downtown and that'swhat everybody is seeing. >> yes.>> so it would have no effect on that.>> that is alreadyã¡-- that's the area that i think everyone hasagreed on should be part of

downtown.>> right. >> tommy, go ahead.>> frank i thought staff's recommendation was for the eastbeach area to be suburban, but on this one it's showingã¡-->> you're correct, that was our original recommendation was thatthe east beach area be suburban. i have indicated to severalcouncilmembers who have asked me that question my only personalbelief is it probably should still be suburban.that area has a plan that calls for it to become a very urbanplace, but it does not have

those characteristics today, andi think until we begin seeing the more mix of uses that theeast beach plan projects happening, it would be prematureto move that into the urban characteristic district.we did not dissent when planning commission wanted to move thatinto urban because weã¡-- the focus appeared to be at thattime on the downtown area, but i would still have greatreservations about putting east beach in the urbancharacteristic district at this time.i think it's premature.

>> the community has asked forthat to go back to sub barb ban for right nowã¡-- suburban forright now and councilman winn and i askedã¡-->> why don't we do this. why don't we listen to everybodyand then we'll start making motions because we may get someother feedback. >> i guess my question was, ithought staff had recommended suburban, but it's showing upurban still, so if you just went with planning, i understand nowwhy that's still showing up that way.>> the only area where we have

come up with a differentrecommendation was where there seemed to be a great deal ofcontention, but i'll tell you as i have indicated to othercouncil members, my personal belief as a planner is that areashould continue to be suburban. it exhibitsã¡-->> we can narrow the discussion. if everybody believes we oughtto pull itã¡-- >> i don't know anybody has aproblem with it. >> i don't.you want to make a motion? someone?>> i move that we change the

east beach area to suburban fromurban on the characteristic district recommendations.>> do you understand that? i mean, you got it?>> i've got it. >> okay, breck, you gotã¡-- okay.we don't need a second, but i meanã¡-- take your time.>> is there a vote on the motion?>> yes, are you prepared to vote on it?>> mr. burfoot. >> aye.>> mr. smigiel. >> aye.>> dr. whibley.

>> aye.>> ms.ã¡williams. >> aye.>> mr. winn. >> aye.>> mr. fraim. >> aye.okay. >> let me haveã¡-- the red crossbuilding was not in any of the discussions at the planningcommission level? is that what i'm hearing.>> that is correct. >> and it is zoned in thedowntown district already? >> yes, sir.>> and i guess the thoughts of

staff was that we ought toinclude that in theã¡-- it's already in there, so we're goingto include it in there. >> well, we have other areasthat are currently zoned downtown, the chrysler museum,for example, the harrison opera house.i have other zoning districts that should council want to havezoning in the future conform to these boundaries, i can put themin. i do not have another zoningdistrict that would accommodate the red cross building, thehague tower or the hague medical

center at this time.>> and the hague tower and hague medical are now in the downtown?>> that's what we're recommending to you.>> what are they? >> they are zoned downtown.>> characteristic districts, what are they zoned right now?>> both zoned as part of downtown, both have shown up inall of the downtown plans as far back as i can go.>> okay. >> and what about the red crossbuilding, that district in there?frank, you just want to leave it

the way it is for the timebeing? is that what you'rerecommending? >> that's my recommendation toyou, yes, sir. >> you say leave it the way itis, you're saying in the downtownã¡-->> that would be my recommendation to you, yes, sir.>> so if we were doing nothing, there were no characteristicdistricts, weren't trying to work for improve our city, tomake it more consistent, then the hague towers, hague medicaland red cross would beã¡-- fall

into the downtown situation?>> yes, sir. >> so if we change them topotentially something that would have a lesser use, we would be,i guess, downzoning is not the right word, but we would betaking away rights of people that own property.>> potentially, but i can't tell you that you would be doing thatuntil we actually have those regulations drafted and you'reactually dealing with them. at this point, because allyou're dealing with the plan amendment, you're not in thatprocess, the potential would

exist in the future and i thinkit would be heightened if they are included in the urban asopposed to the downtown characteristic district.>> when you say heightenedã¡-- >> there's a greater chance thatyou would at some point remove development rights from thoseproperties. >> okay, so if we weren't doinganything and somebody said they wanted to develop it and thishad never come up, it wouldn't be an issue, we'll wouldn't betalking about it, they could do what they could do within theirrights.

>> yes, sir.>> but the idea with characteristic districts isactually to change some of those and that's part of this.for instance, the north brambleton area, we're limitedso if we did no, we'd still be at the same zoning, which wouldbe sub sush ban for that area and we wouldn't be able to makethe necessary changes. you can go both ways on this.you have to get rid of the zoningã¡-- we're not talkingabout zoning right now. we're talking about makingcharacteristic districts, and

that's a different ball of waxhere. so it's true that if you lefteverything the same, then we'd have everything the same, butthat's not why we're here. >> so we are potentiallydamaging people's ability to do whatever that now exists.>> you're creating a framework right now and if you carry thatframework through, that potentially could happen, yes,sir. >> is that a defensible thing todo for the city? >> i'd have to defer to the cityattorney.

>> the only changes that areidentified right now with the characteristic districts is toreduce parking and open space, which would be positives fordevelopers. they could also do more than theminimum, they could do what is there today if we lowered it.that's all that we know right now and there are any number ofpossibilitieses that i couldn't identify, whether they could benegative, they could be positive as dr. whibley says, but the twoitems that have been identified would just be positives fordevelopers.

reduce parking and reduce openspace requirements. so the only two things that areknown to be coming to you. there could be others, butthey're not known. >> i thought nothing was comingto us now. >> nothing tonight, but the nextitems are going to be reduction of parking requirements andreduction of open space requirements.and there will be nothing passed without this council's approval.but the planning motivation right now is to deal withreducing parking requirements

and open space requirements.>> and mr.ã¡mayor, if i could elaborate on what mr.ã¡pishko hassaid, currently you have the authority to completely waiveparking and open space requirements or to substantiallyreduce them, so part of this is also to try to benefitneighborhoods and communities by creating certainty becausethrough those ordinance changes we're talking about bringingforward, we would be eliminating some of the ability to waiveordinanceã¡-- parking and open space and create a standard thateveryone could rely on.

>> but i'm hearing differentthings from you and bernard. i'm hearing the potential ispretty good that they wouldn't be able to do what they could dotoday tomorrow, and you are saying, no, they're going to beable to do more today than they were tomorrow.>> i think what mr.ã¡pishko is looking at is the issue thatyou've already told to us deal with and i would agree witheverything that he has said. but my concern is, you may wantto go and do something more down the road and because we aresupposed to be looking at the

general plan for guidance, i amconcerned about that potential at that point.>> okay. well, frank, stand by.we may have more questions for you because this is not veryclear. >> this has nothing to do withthe architecture. >> no, sir.>> of it and i think a lot of folk are caught up with, youknow, in terms of what you want to do with those particularproperties. and that's just not the issuethat's before us this evening.

>> i think potentially the shapeof the buildings isã¡-- >> but that gets into a wholeother conversation and there are still restrictions and thatwould have to be dealt with, again come back to planning tobe dealt with. one of the things thatã¡-- youcouldn't put a two-story building onã¡-- where the medicalfacility is because you don't have the parking, and, you know,this helps. where are you going to park, onthe other side of brambleton? i think there's some reasonableassurances in what we're doing

and i think that at the end ofthe day, i think the people think that we're biting theentire apple off tonight and we're not.and so, again, this is addressed to one part of it and i don'tthink thatã¡-- my personal opinionã¡-- that it hurtsanything. but i think it's necessary.>> so are you saying, anthony, that because of the parkingrequirements, the building in itself, if it were to beredesigned or something, could only be so high?or onlyã¡-- i mean, we don't only

do so much because of thelimited amount of parking? >> no, what i'm saying isdowntown you have certainã¡-- the parking requirements, whether itbe over by the alexander or whether it be downtown, what i'msaying is on thisã¡-- you have three pieces of property there.you have that medical property there, you have the hague towerand you have the red cross building.again, i would hope that as a council, you know, that, again,that we would set policy and restrictions, you know, for daysthat we're not here and i think

at the end of the day, we'rejust creating a blueprint, but i don't think that anyone on thiscouncil want to do anything to the detriment of downtown.i don't think, when you look at what you have, you don't want toexacerbate the problem of density in that corridor, and soi just think that you begin to define those properties, butwhen you start to get into an architecture discussion andsaying whether or not these buildingsã¡-- let's say the hagueburned to the ground, or like the young lady told me, asteroidhit it and destroyed it.

what type of development do youbuild or replace it with? is the architecture consistentwith downtown? and so you get into that, andwhat is the architecture? is it compatible to, you know,the surrounding areas? so i just don'tã¡-- i look at itand say you're starting to talk aboutã¡-- i've heard so manydiscussions and it centered around architecture and what youwould build there and what would it look like, but again, thishas nothing to do with architecture or buildings.i mean, it's beginning just to

framework and blueprint to beable to define the boundaries of downtown and within that, youcould begin to work within that framework.>> i could be wrong, frank, butã¡-->> frankã¡-- >> i would agreeã¡-->> but the architecture thing never really comes before us.>> no, it'sã¡-- >> but i would finish what mr.burfoot isã¡-- i would agree with him because really what you'relooking at if you maximize the restore plates that would beallowed to the hague medical

center site and you structuredparking, you would be looking at probably no more than a 10 to12-story building. it could go to a taller buildingyou had more open space because now you're reducing the overallfloor play, creating a smaller ff.a.r.floor area ratio. >> your recommendation that itbe in the downtown district is because you feel that it is moreappropriate there? >> yes, sir.>> okay. they're aboutã¡-- i think we have13 folks signed up to address

the council on this matter.as you know, the council still has some questions.we're going to ask mr.ã¡duke to come back and maybe if you havequestions, try to answer a couple, but we're here to listento you tonight for sure. all i ask is when i call yourname, if you come to the podium, identify yourself for the recordby giving us your full name and present home address and pleaselimit your remarks to three minutes.if you agree with somebody or you don't agree with somebody,please, you know, we'd like to

respect everybody's opinionshere, so keep yourã¡-- you know, keep the noise please to aminimum, if you could. ray king.>> good evening. my name is ray w. king.i'm an attorney with the firm of leclair ryan here in downtownnorfolk and i reside at 5608 shenandoah avenue in thelakewood sub division. i'm here to address you thisevening as the chair of the board of directors of thedowntown norfolk council on this issue, the downtown norfolkcouncil represents 325 members

in the downtown area whichinclude businesses, property owners, and people who reside inthe downtown area. specifically i'm here to expressthe downtown norfolk council's support for the proposedamendments to the community design chapter of the generalplan of norfolk to create the definitions for the threecharacteristic districts in norfolk.as you've already been talking about, the three proposedcharacteristic districts of downtown, urban, and suburban,downtown norfolk council is

particularly pleased to see thatthe proposed boundaries that you've been talking about forthe downtown characteristic district will include the granbydistrict north of brambleton avenue.we believe this is a critical part of the plan to help make itsuccessful. for many years, the zoning inthis area has been so restrictive and the parkingrequirements so stringent that compatible developmentsupportive of the division of an important city and developmenthas been difficult to achieve.

the opportunity provided by thecharacteristic district amendment will, we feel, allowappropriate and compatible development to occur in thisarea and will enhance the opportunity for the district'spotential to be finally realized in the city.the downtown norfolk councilã¡-- and there are several members ofthe council here tonight. i would ask those present toplease stand and be recognized. anyone supporting our position.the downtown norfolk council is supportive of the threeprivately owned properties on

brambleton avenue which you havebeen discussing to be included in the downtown district and notin the urban district. we feel that to maintain themaximum potential for these properties and in keeping withtheir current character, that they remain within the downtowndistrict. on the citywide basis, it is ourfeeling that the simplicity of the three character districtapproach brings far greater charity to the planning processand permits the city to move it's land use regulations insuch a way to encourage new and

compatible development withinthe city. we respectfully encourage you toadopt the proposal to amend the community design chapter in thegeneral plan of norfolk to create the definitions for thecharacter districts including the proposed boundaries as ihave discussed and i'm available to answer any questions you mayhave. thank you for your time andallowing me to speak tonight. >> thank you, mr.ã¡king.jack plumgren. >> good evening.i'm jack plumgren, president of

the ghent business association.i reside at 200 college place, but my business is located1611-b colley avenue in ghent and i'm here to speak againstthe proposed changes. just as background, a group ofindividuals, including people from downtown, got together,originally put together a plan that had those three buildingsnot in the downtown area, but actually had them in the urbanarea. that has changed subsequently.the negotiated deal that we had come up with fell through, and alot of it had to do with a

developer.having said that, you know, the purpose of the characterdistricts to me is to define the character of a neighborhood.irregardless of which property is on there now.i mean, what we're talking about is two buildings that areseparated by a foot bridge from some of the most extensive realestate in the city of norfolk. the hague and the area aroundthe hague. i don't think we have adequatepeople here to represent those people, but if that area becomesmore fully developed as

downtown, what will happen isthe parking will spill over into those neighborhoods.you'll be far more likely to park in though neighborhoodsthan to park across the natural barrier of a six-lane highwaylike brambleton avenue. i just feel like the characteritself of those areas belongs more in the urban setting thanit does in the downtown setting. the earlier speaker spoke abouthow restrictions were keeping it from being developed, but yetearlier, we heard that it was already zoned as downtown.so if it was restrictive, what

was restricting them if downtownwould make it less restrictive. this whole issue has gotten veryconfused. i've sat through threepresentations on this issue and every time i sat through thepresentations, they said it won't make any differencebecause he has this letter and it won't make any differencebecause if it's zoned this way or that way.it just seems to me there's a tremendous misunderstanding andi heard a lot of the discussion here this evening, but i'm hereto represent the ghent business

association and we unanimouslysupported the original agreement, which had the threebuildings in question as part of the urban zoning and the ghentbusiness association is also unanimousã¡-- the board hasunanimously voted to continue to support the original agreementand be in opposition to these changes.so thanks. >> thank you.bruce bishop. >> my name is bruce bishop.i reside at 1405 south voe loop in norfolk.i speak as a norfolk taxpayer

and as chairperson of thedowntown norfolk council's street level diversity taskforce. i endorse all the commentsincluded in ray king's presentation and his letter,which was sent on august 28th to members of the council and urgecouncil to approve the staff proposal to amend the communitydesign chapter of the general plan of norfolk to createdefinitions for character districts within the city ofnorfolk. i commend frank duke, who isincidentally an outstanding

planning director and his stafffor their hard work in defining this concept and shepherdingthis proposal through the planning process to council forits consideration. this proposal, in my opinion, aswin-win for the city, its residents as well as theexisting and new businesses that will eventually be drawn to thegranby district north of brambleton avenue as a result ofits passage and subsequent regulatory amendments.thanks have much for your time. >> greta gustavson.>> good evening.

my name is greta gustafson and ireside at 421 west duke street in norfolk.i've been a resident and property owner in the freemasonhistoric district for the past 35 years.i'm here tonight to really not either support or oppose theestablishment of character districts.i'm here to pose some issues that will need to be addressedif you choose to go forward with the establishment of characterdistricts in norfolk. i understand the process thatmust be followed.

however, it is extremelydifficult to support a change that could dramatically alterthe fabric of our urban neighborhoods.as many of you are aware, the boundaries of the freemasonhistoric district have been shrinking over the past tenyears, primarily because of changes in zoning from hcwf-1and hcwf-2 to d-3, which has allowed an increase in density,loss of open space, and the dreaded battle of parkingspaces. our neighborhood is locatedmidway between downtown and

ghent, and we reflect some ofboth of those areas, and had it not been for businessesrehabilitating some of our old homes, many more of our historicbuildings would have been lost through neglect or throughdemolition. while we strongly encouragereturning those structures to residential use, we respect thebusinesses that have been good stewards of their property, andinvolve them in our neighborhood activities and events as much aspossible. although i've been told bymr.ã¡duke that creation of

character districts andinclusion of the freemason neighborhood in the downtowncharacter district will not affect those portions of westfreemason covered by chapter 9 of our planning ordinance andthe historic district guidelines, i do not have thatassurance for the part of our neighborhood which is the bulkof our neighborhood now, that is zoned d-3.much of the neighborhood's d-3 zoning was established throughelimination of areas previously covered by hcwf-2 zoning.the d-3 zoning allows for

greater lot coverage, lessrestrictive height requirements, minimal parking requirements,fewer green and open spaces, and fewer restrictions related tobuilding design and materials. my overriding fear is thatinclusion in the downtown character district wouldincrease the likelihood of even further erosion of our historicdistrict. how will these issues beaddressed? nobody knows at this pointbecause we don't know the rules. as a former athlete and as aformer teacher, i would have

been a fool to play a game withrules that had not been developed and i would have beenremiss to test my students without first giving theminstruction. it is an equally difficult taskto consider a proposed action for zoning without expressedplanning. if you choose to move forward onthe establishment of character districts in norfolk, i stronglyurge you to insist upon readable written documents developed withneighborhood input and to critically review thosedocuments as they are presented

to you.>> thank you. >> i also urge you to listen tothe residents because we're the ones who have to live there.>> thank you. warren tisdale.>> good evening. my name the warren tisdale.my office is at 440 monticello avenue.i'm here representing the owner of the hague medical building.described in the august 24th council interest, a memorandumto city council, the three character districts, downtown,urban and suburban, reflect

different development charactersthat typified norfolk's development over time.the downtown character district reflect areas of city developedfirst with a broad range of higher intensity uses, limitedonsite parking and pedestrian and transit accessibility.also the zoning ordinance definition of downtown characterdistrict that city council is adopting today is as follows.the area of the city that historically included thecentral business district and those areas immediately adjacentto it in which high intensity

mixed use development isanticipated. that is the character districtdefinition that both historically and currently bestfits our parcel. brambleton avenue does not markthe historical boundary between downtown and the first suburbsof norfolk. brambleton avenue as we know itwas not constructed until the 1960s.what is now the hague originally was an inlet with two creeksstretching north well away from downtown.historically, the areas to the

south and east of the hague werepart of downtown and not part of ghent.and from a current compatibility standpoint, the development ofproperty between the hague and brambleton avenue, residentialhigh rise and office, is more in keeping with downtown thanresidential development in ghent.i think he reliance is important consideration.the property on which the hague medical building sits has beendowntown zoning district 4 sin the downtown zoning districtswere created and imposed by

adoption of the current zoningordinance in 1992. to my knowledge, all applicableland use studies and initiatives conducted or pons sword by thecity haveã¡-- sponsored by the city have considered theproperty south and east of the hague to be a part of downtown.to change that now penalizes those who relied on the zoningand it is not as if current zoning is lacking in protection.the current downtown district 4 zoning of our parcel confersultimate power over structures and uses within this district onthis city council.

downtown zoning districts arenot like other zoning districts. the city council controls whatcan be built and what uses can be pursued.certainly that level of control is sufficient comfort.in conclusion, we request that with regard to the hague medicalbuilding parcel, city council adopt the character district mapwhich from discussion i gather is the administrative staffproposal before you. it's the only sound approach atthis early stage in the overlay process before any overlaydevelopment standards have been

established.the sound approach is to impose character district boundariesthat match current zoning. thank you.>> page rose. thank you, warren.>> good evening. my name is page rose.i reside at 524 grayton avenue and i'm president of the ghentneighborhood league and i think to begin, we would all agreethat norfolk is comprised of distinct neighborhoods, eachwhich contributes its own vitality to our community andtreasured city scape.

these neighborhoods couldconceivably be divided into three distinct areas.we're not here tonight to discuss the merits of thecharacter districts, the boundaries and reasons for themand any potential reasons for carveouts.when the ghent neighborhood league learned of the proposedcharacter district amendment for the city of norfolk's generalplan, it began working collaboratively with nearbyneighborhoods and organizations to ensure boundaries relatedwell to each other between the

districts, were reasonably andserved unique neighborhoods well, especially as boundarieswould impact neighborhoods with subsequent zoning decisions,open space, parking and other potential areas.the impact details of which are still undetermined.it was agreed to have one of the major boundaries for the urbandistrict to run north of program tellton avenue, which is thelogical boundary between downtown freemason and ghentfrom an aesthetic, historical, and transportation perspective.despite the earlier

collaborative neighborhoodprocess to define the boundaries, it was subsequentlyrecommended by the city staff at the behest of a local developer,as we understand it, to carve out medical tower, hague towerand more recently the red cross building from the urban area andplace these buildings in the downtown designation.as explained to the gnl by the city, that a developer stands tolose potential income if this carve-out did not occur.when the information presented, it seems the developer coulddevelop the site properly under

the urban designation.this proposed carve-out is troubling on many fronts.ghent residents have voiced their opposition to thiscarve-out which brings downtown style development with less openspace and less parking requirements in addition toother potential downtown style development allowances into theghent neighborhood abutting the foot of the storied ghent bridgeand in plain view of many residents, especially thosehomeowners on the historic moebly arch area.this also brings many additional

parking issues which havealready been addressed. the carve-out would leaveyarmouth streels and the ghent district boxed in and mostneighborhood feel this is inappropriate regarding thecarve-out. as no one knows the final zoningimplications of implementing the carve-out, it seems impossibleto make such a decision in a prudent matter without thezoning information available. apt a recent gnl special meetingto discuss the situation, a straw poll was taken and theoverwhelming majority are

opposed to the carve-out fromthe urban to the downtown designation.thus, it was seem the voices of many residents should be heardover the voice of a developer. if the character districtamendment is approved, the ghent neighborhood league respectfullyasks the boundary between downtown and urban areas toremain at brambleton avenue as earlier recommended by theplanning commission and without the carve-out.this would help preserve and protect the ghent neighborhoodfor generations to come, for

current residents and also forthe developer to enjoy his right for a financial gain.many have asked what's the rush? and as we consider the decisionsfor boundary lines, the reasons for them and potentialcarve-outs without knowing the specific zoning information andthe realization this decision will affect all neighborhoods,especially those which co-exist in close proximity.thank you. >> thank you.mr.ã¡moss, cannon moss. >> hello.my name is cannon moss and i

live at 732 yarmouth street.i appreciate to opportunity to stand before the council anddiscuss my concerns. we met with city officials lastweek to get an overview of the districts and some of thereasoning behind by certainly areas are classed urban ordowntown. while we appreciate theopportunity to be briefed on what is going on, the meetingleft many of us with more questions than answers.from what i understand, the character districts boil down toparking and open space

requirements, which mattergreatly to my neighbors and me. i chose to buy my house in thedowntown area. while i like where i live, iunderstand with a great location comes some sacrifice and parkinghappens to be one of them. this is why i'm so sensitive tolosing what little parking we have.the parking on the street is extremely limited.we're surrounded today by the hague towers, the chrysler, crambelton avenue and duke street. once our street parking istaken, there are view for you

options for us.we understand the requirements for each of those districts havenot been outlined. if that's the case, how can youvote for the boundaries of the districts when the impact to thesurrounding neighborhoods is unknown?i look at the hague medical building and i think if thisgets developed into a downtown style high rise development,where are all the people going to park?i know there's no parking on brambleton, so that leaves thearch across the way.

i look at the red cross buildingand wonder if that becomes some sort of high rise with limitedparking requirements, what happens to me, where am i goingto park? i'm not standing here and sayingstop the progress. i'm asking you to consider thecitizens that live in these areas, not the developer.it might be unfairã¡-- excuse me, it might be unfair to thedeveloper as we were told in our meeting, but what about thesurrounding residents? did the developer who built thebrambleton apartments have to

fight for a parking spot at5:00ã¡p.m. because the ymca is busy?i doubt it. before you vote so thedistricts, i think it is very important to understand theimpact on the surrounding neighborhoods and there's no wayto nah that if the districts themselves are not defined.i look at historic yarmouth street with it's beautifulhistoric homes, surrounded by what?skyscrapers? you might think i'moverreacting, but that could

become a reality with thedevelopment of red cross building and adjacent open spacein i'm not asking you to stop progress.i just want to make sure that my fellow neighbors and i knowexactly how we will be affected and howã¡-- how we'll be affect.right now, you guys can't answer that.thank you. >> lee snyder.he didn'tã¡-- okay. thanks.bob bobreck? mr.ã¡bobreck?>> good evening.

my nape is bob bobbreck.i live at 414 marbury arch for about 18 years.don't buy an old house, by the way.live there, it's a great neighborhood.i tell you what, i had a go-around when i tried to put asatellite on my roof for satellite tv and now they said,oh, bob, they're putting a 10-story building on the hague.from what i can see, it's going to be maybe ten stories, eightstories, 12 stories, parking around there like cannon said ishard as it is now.

i'm totally against it, like togo on record about that, and it sounds, the confusion factorhere, i don't mean to say confusion.there's too many variables to make an intelligent decisionfrom what i can see right now. thank you.>> thank you. sharonã¡-- is it plevens?pam clapel? >> good evening.my name is pam clapel and i'm a property owner at 804 through814 granby street and i'm here to support the creation ofcharacter districts in norfolk's

general plan and for theresulting zoning changes where appropriate in these characterdistricts. my granby street property islocated between brambleton avenue and princess anne road inan area called north of brambleton.it is the weak link between two renovated and prospering areasof granby street. it's a two blocks with littlebuilding renovation and limbed enticement for new tenants.the parking ordinance here requires that the number ofparking place allocated to a

business be tied to the size ofthe building which houses the business.therefore, restaurants, bars, theaters, and other businesseswhich bring feet on the street do not consider the 7 and 800block of granby street. it's such a shame when this isso close to the harrison opera house and to the chryslermuseum. both of which are majorattractions in the city of norfolk.one of my tenants has considered creating a space for his bridalflower customers to have

weddings and receptions.the current zoning does not allow such innovation.the zoning is so restrictive north of brambleton thatattracting new tenants and maximizing the locationalopportunity has been almost impossible.i personally have had one building vacant for an entireyear. with the inclusion of the 800and 700 blocks of granby street in the downtown characterdistrict, parking requirements should become the same as southof brambleton.

this would bring consistency inparking regulations to the downtown improvement districtand encourage more businesses and tenants to consider lockingin these two blocks ofã¡-- locates in these two blocks ofgranby street. therefore, i ask you to pleasevote for inclusion of the three character districts in thegeneral plan as recommended to you by your city planningcommission. irene o'brien.>> thank you for allowing me to speak.my name is irene o'brien.

i live at 833 brandon avenue,which is right off of colley near blair middle school.i am a second vice president of the ghent neighborhood leagueand i'm also liaison to the ghent business association.i come here before you as not somebody who lives along thehague but is concerned about my community of ghent.i feel a lot like we're putting the cart before the horse notknowing what exactly or even just a general idea of what thefuture zoning will be for these areas.and i feel that right now, if we

maybe kind of left that areathat is north of brambleton, near the ghent area along thehague, out of the character district to be decided uponafterwards once zoning was figured out, that would be moreproductive for the character districts to move forward and,you know, resolve these controversial and unknownquestions. the area of north of brambletonnear ghent, i feel, has already hadã¡-- is already a greatdividing line. you know, a six-lane road is apretty good indicator, i think.

the area north of brambleton ongranby, though, that is an area that needs development and ithink it, you know, being characterized as put intodowntown is something that is very important, but not all ofit, you know, the area north of brambleton needs to be done.i do ask that, as far as parking, many people, you know,that's one of our biggest concerns.nobody is going to walk across six lanes of road to go park ina city parking lot near the y or any parking lot.they're going to go walk across

the foot bridge and park inpeople's neighborhoods and parking stickers in ourneighborhoods, while in downtown may be effective, they are noteffective in ghent, and by example is sentara.people, they have plenty of parking garages and probablyplenty of pa,ing for theirã¡-- parking for their employees andvisitors, but employees still park in the ghent area and it'shard for the city of norfolk, you know, parking, you know,people that watch or the police pay attention and monitor theseareas.

so, you know, lastly, i ask thatyou, you know, support the ghent neighborhood league and theghent business association in our opposition in allowing thisarea to be carved out and put into the downtown characterdistrict. thank you.>> tanya banks says she's opposed to theã¡-- i guess to theordinance the way it's drafted, doesn't wish to speak.unless you have somethingã¡-- charles snyder doesn't wish tospeak. he lists himself as an opponent.tom johnson is here to answer

questions if there are any.does anybody have any questions? okay.does any statements, any questions anybody want to make?>> i just wantã¡-- >> comments?okay. frank?>> maybe you can tell me, but what's the difference betweenurban and downtown? i mean, just in the generalsense, because urban usually consists of downtown.>> urban in the context in which we have described it includesneighborhoods in which uses

exist in proximity to oneanother, such as you find in ghent where you do have thecommercial areas that back up immediately to the residentialareas of the neighborhood. whereas downtown, you typicallyhave them more intermingled, where you have more of theresidential immediately above or even in freemason where you'vegot them directly next to one another.>> so we created our own definition?>> we have created our own definitions.what we looked at was the street

pattern, so you're look atsmaller blocks in your downtown area.they begin to get larger as you get outside of downtown into theurban areas. the mix of uses is different.building heights is different. downtown, you have very smalllots, yards whereas as you get into urban, they begin to becomea little more gracious. you get into suburban and you'regetting into the much bigger lots.>> okay. i was justã¡-- you know, i thinkwe had created our own

definition, but i mean urban,you knowã¡-- >> it was a challenge to try tofigure out how to word this. we did the best we could.>> okay. >> let me say a couple things.i think the big problem we have is that nobody knows what we'regoing to have. after we establish the district,i think, you're saying by law and then establish what goes inthe districts. the idea of exempting these,leaving these three properties in no man's land, is thatagainst the law, until we figure

out what's going on go indowntown and what's going on go in ghent and what impact thatmight have? >> legally, you're under noobligation to do this at all. >> i understand.and that's my next question. if we vote for this and it's inthe downtown district, then, you know, that's finished.if we vote against it, then character districts arefinished. >> yes, sir.>> so we're in a terrible position in my mind because whatall this work and all this staff

has gone through for months andyears, if it goes down because ghent wants one thing and getstheir way, which, you know, may happen, then we have nocharacter districts. so why can't we, if we make thelaw, exempt those three properties and put theã¡--everything else as you have it, find out exactly what you'regoing to put downtown, what the rules are going to be there,what the rules are going to be in urban, and then react tothose appropriately and then put those in the placeã¡-- so thatthere's not in uncertainty that

people have out there?the down side of that is they stay exactly like they're zonednow, so whatever by law they could do, they could do until wesettle this issue. >> but if you put them in thedowntown district, they stay exactly the way they are anyway.is thatã¡-- >> in terms of theã¡-->> we don't know. >> what we're talking about withregard to parking is that the downtown parking requirement onthe north side of brambleton would be consistent with therecommendations of the institute

for transportation engineers andthis outlined area which is roughly three-quartersã¡-- i'msorry, two-thirds of what would be required in suburban areas.and then you get into urban areas and it's roughly 80%.so that's the difference you're talking about.parking is the one thing where we have done research where ican tell you those are the standards that we've presentedto you before that would beã¡-- we'd be recommending with regardto parking. the challenge that you've got ifyou just leave these areas

exactly the way they are now,parking requirements is to be determined at the time you doã¡--deal with the approval of the individual project.there is no define standard. >> but we can do that until wehad something that everybody understood.>> but it would not allow us to make the progress that we'rehoping to make in the north brambleton area.the idea behind this character district was to give us theleverage to have the ability to bring in development in thenorth brambleton area and to

stop this constant, every time adevelopment comes to us, that we as council, because we're undersuburban rules right now, we waive the restrictions.it has inconsistency, it wastes people's time, it brings a greatdeal of confusion. the thing thatã¡-->> but there's nothing pending, there's nothing going to happenin the time i would hope we could get these rules set.>> but again, you can't get the rules set without theboundaries. but there is one thing, andfrank, correct me if i'm wrong,

because i've sat through a lotof these meetings and frank always presents to us what wouldbe essentially the requirements for green space in urban, therequirements in downtown, the requirements for parking.you will even tell us what the percentage difference is betweenthe two. so the impression that many haveleft or are left with, that these areã¡-- these arerestrictions that are just floating around with noframework at all, is incorrect. there are frameworks.they may not be voted on yet,

but there certainly are frameworks that we've all listened to, we've all talked about inthe meetings, so it really isn't as nebulous as many people say.i understand people that are saying how in the world can wevote on the rules when we don't know the rules?we actually do know the rules. we may not have it down to thefinite, but frank, am i correct on this?>> yes, ma'am. >> secondly, my frustration onthis, very frankly, and this is just because of the way i'mvoting, is i feel very strongly

about having characterdistricts. we need character districts, buti am frustrated that we can't vote on what our planningcommission's recommendations were, which was no carve-outs.it was character districts, because the way we've got itnow, it's either up or down. like barclay is saying, and thenyou throw the baby out with the bath water.and i understand there are many people that want to support thecarve-outs. it doesn't seem like we're giventhat option for a vote for each

of theã¡-- those possibilities.>> frank, tellã¡-- >> can i say, first of all, thisthing called the carve-out, i mean, you can call it acarve-out or a carve-in orã¡-- i mean, the original staffproposal, the original proposal as i understand it, when itoriginally went to the planning commission, wasã¡-- what was it?>> it was to include these properties in downtown.>> okay. >> as well as to includeã¡-->> it was to include the properties.>> yes.

>> it wasã¡-- when the communitydiscussion was had with ghent, that they moved, so it's notlike it's the folks who areã¡-- or theã¡-- that piece of properwas carved out. it sounds like we're creating aexception and what we've heard now for 40 years, that thetradition has been that they have had downtown standards.and so i mean, i think there's a misimpression being created hereby somehow theseã¡-- that this property is being treateddifferently. i mean, by its inclusion in thestaff recommendation.

and it's not.it's the way it's been treated since we've had a downtowndistrict and for the lastã¡-- since the 1960s.it is not a change, it is not, you know, a carve-out.it's not an exception, if you will.the exception would be to do something else.let meã¡-- would it help the council if we just sort ofclosed the public hearing and then tried toã¡-- you know, maybecame back and tried to deal with the issue in another meeting oranother discussion orã¡--

>> i've got one question to askfrank. frank, let me ask you aquestionã¡-- >> wait a minute.hold on. >> it's going to help me andtheã¡-- >> fly question?>> what you're asking me. >> all right.>> frank, if we did nothing and somebody wanted to bid on thatproperty tomorrow, okay? and this body had to vote, theycould actually get a variance, right?>> no, sir, they wouldn't be

able to get a variance becausethey still would have use of the property.they would have to come before you showing if they have adevelopment that would meet all the standards that have beenestablished in the ordinance or ask for waivers from you forthose standards that you can waive.>> so you would call it a waivers, you wouldn't call it avariance. >> by code they are calledwaiver, yes, sir. >> so basicallyã¡-- and so today,somebody could build a 12-story

high rise and if it was the willand consent of this council, they could do so.>> yes, sir. >> okay.>> they could do that presumably with no waivers.>> today? >> today.>> okay. with the character districts inplace, then what would the requirement be?>> the issue is that the parking standard would be fixed insteadof being something that a developer could come to you andsay we'd like to waive it.

you would have an open spacestandard that would be fixed instead of it being somethingthat the developer could come before you and say we want towaive it. >> so today, they could do itã¡-->> yes, sir. >> and tomorrow, if you wouldput the character districts in place, it couldn't because itspeaks to specificity of what we're trying to accomplish?>> when we bring forward the remaining ordinance, yes, sir,that's intended to provide certainty to the process.>> what happens to theã¡-- if we

approve it today and we bringitã¡-- >> do you want to vote tonight?>> i want to vote. >> what happens between now andthe character districts not really knowing the rules anddecember when we get the rules if somebody wants to develop it?>> not a thing because what governs the use of the propertyis the zoning, which is why i stressed at the beginning, thisis not a regulatory change, it's a planning change.>> that's exactly what they could do today?>> they could do exactly what

they could do today.>> not until we vote in december for zoning with there be achange. >> okay.so back to my question about leaving out the threeproperties. only three properties in thecity that areã¡-- why couldn't we just create an island untothemselves, let those sit out there until we understand, andthen create the character districts and then make thedecision which character district to put them in based onhow it affects the neighborhood

or how it affects the developer?and how it affects the developer.>> the challenge we would have is as we begin developing theparking regulations, for example, we're going to havesome concrete regulations, so my recommendation to you would beto put them in one of the three character districts, actuallyone of the two. could you put them in urbantonight? absolutely.by simple motion of council just as you took east beach and movedit from urban to sub barb ban,

you could do the same thing withthese three properties. >> well, could you moveã¡-- iknow that. i understand what we can do, buti want to understand how it impacts all involved before i doit because people are saying they don't understand, you know,the parking situation, by the way, is just as an aside, nodeveloper worth his salt would ever develop a piece of propertythat wasn't properly parked, enough people that lived there,that worked there could park. do you agree with that, frank?>> i would and in fact one of

the cautions we've heard fromdevelopers is a fear that our proposed standards may be toolow. until we begin talking andworking through what they are, and then they feel morecomfortable. >> i can't conceive of any typeproperty where you would lease to somebody and say, by the way,you have to find your own parking, so i really don't seethat as a huge issue. i still think the unconcerns isthe thing that has everybody worried.>> andy?

>> if i could recommendsomething. i have my opinion of this andi'm not going to say that at this point.however, we canã¡-- and this is just a matter of procedure,paul, and correct me if i'm wrong, just a recommendation.i will move at this point that we take those three propertiesout of the downtown property district, move it into urban.we canã¡-- >> okay.>> we can try to see if that goes up or down.and then i assume that we can

come back andã¡-->> sure. >> i mean if that makes sense,because i have a gut feeling this is going to be a 4-3 as itis. if not 5-2.so i mean, that's my gut, to move it along.>> yeah, okay. i that i that's fair enough.>> well, you know, are we going to still put in jeopardy thecharacter district principle that weã¡-->> no, because weã¡-- >> he's sayingã¡-->> we're going to have the vote.

it's either going to be up ordown with the carve-out or carve-in, and then if thatdoesn't go, then we can vote it through the other way.>> right. because i have a feeling it willbe 4-3 as it is. >> so theã¡-->> if notã¡-- >> i still don't understand whywe couldn't exempt the three properties.>> because they have to have all the boundaries delineated beforethey can do it, that's just the rules.and if you look at theã¡-- well,

look up.if you look at the specifics that he's got delineated, it isreally pretty well spelled out. it really is there for you, soit's not some floating issue. >> okay.the staff's recommendation is that those properties, the northbrambleton properties by the hague that we've been talkingabout, be in the traditionalã¡-- or in the downtown characterdistrict. and the motion is that they bemoved into the urban district. okay?>> so we can call the roll on

that.>> mr. burfoot. >> no.>> mr.ã¡protogyrou. >> no.>> mr.ã¡winn. >> no.>> mr. fraim. >> no.pardon me? >> i said that will beã¡-- well,3-4. >> all right.so we need five votes and we don't get there.now we vote on the character districts.okay.

>> two ordinances for this sidemr.ã¡president. i have an ordinance to amend thegeneral plan of norfolk, 1992, so as to define characterdistributions within the city and to recommend theirlocations. >> if i may, mr.ã¡mayor, i don'tremember voting on whether east beach is urban and sub barb ban.>> no, we did. >> it's been a long night.>> we're not done. >> okay, we're not done.>> beginning of a long night. >> okay.>> dispense with the charter

requirement for reading theordinance and adopt. >> mr. protogyrou.>> ky speak at this times? >> yes.>> i think procedurally, my preference would be to movethese properties into the urban district and that's why i madethe motion, and there are a couple reasons behind that and ireally would like to give some rationale as to why.first of all, i think that in listening to the speakerstonight a majority of speakers tonight and the majority of thecontact we've had has been from

citizens who live in the areaand i really think that we have to, when we weigh out thebusiness side of it, and i appreciate bruce being here andthe others that come, and ray, and i appreciate that, but youdon't live there. i don't live there, and i haveto really respect the individuals who live in thearea, and you know, it was interesting, most of the mostcompelling arguments really is that foot bridge and i know thatfoot bridge, what you're going to have is, yes, you wouldhaveã¡-- i can see people being

on one side, coming across,parking over there, which was really something that really hithome with me and i made sure i wrote that down when it wassaid. i'm going to go back to frank.frank, you may have given anthony the credit for thisã¡--no, you don't have to get up. i think what struck me was as towhy character districts are significant, when we first cameon council a little over two years ago, it seemed that everydeveloper was coming in, wanting to build apartments all over thecity and it was willy-nilly and

i remember saying, and atsomeã¡-- i was voting against them, saying if you want anexception, you're not getting it or if you want some kindã¡--we're not, i'm not agreeing to a variance, i'm not agreeing,you're stuck with the law as it is.that's the density, that's how it is.and finally, i remember going to frank and saying go block byblock within the city and come up where we can have apartmentsand where we can't have them because they're going upeverywhere.

and then frank and the characterdistricts, whether they were in play at the time or startedcoming about because we do need to get some control of this.as terri said, we do know where we are generally in ourunderstanding of, of theã¡-- of the zoning issue.we know generally the density issues.we understand those and there are going to be someadjustments. in the end, i'm somebody whowants character districts, but i figured that we could vote up ordown on this issue and having

lost that issue, i will now voteyes for the character distributions because i thinkit's a significant issue and something i've sought.it's unfortunate that we lost amending it to consider what wewere doing with regard these properties, but i will vote infavor of it at this time, so it's aye.>> mr. smigiel. >> no.>> dr. whibley? >> i similarly amã¡-- have toreally thank frank duke. i call him about every threedays regarding this issue, and

he's been a real trooper and hasgone to all the civic leagues, even when he wasn't requestedto. he's really done nis duediligence on that and i really want to thank him for that.i am struck by that the neighborhood came.i've heard them speak, they're concerned as i about thecharacter of that corner and the surrounding yarmouth.once we vote this in, it's voted in through perpetuity.i understand nusbaum being concerned about loss ofdevelopment rights, but then it

goes to the next and to the nextand to the next. when it came to east beach, theneighbors spoke and we voted. this time, it came to theneighbors and we didn't. so i'm disappointed that ithappened. but character districts areimportant and, i like andy, am not going to throw the baby outwith the bath water, so i'm going to vote aye.>> ms.ã¡williams. >> yeah e.>> mr.ã¡winn. >> i'm going to vote aye, buti'm going to make one more

punctuation point here.first of all, we appreciate everybody coming down here andtheir involvement in this really important issue.i would say the downtown norfolk council, those folks haveã¡-- imean, they're enlightened as well as the ghent neighborhoodleague is and the ghent business association.you can tell this council is divided.we see this stuff differently, and we're trying to move thecity forward. the issue about here on thenorth of brambleton, the thing

that i keep coming back to is wehadã¡-- is that zoning and distinctions of thesedistributions are sort of social contracts that you have withpeople. and you have people who haveinvested in property there who have a stake in it, who weareã¡-- we would be changing the game on them right now.and as far as i can tell, i know what frank said, we're going totalk about these frameworks, that very little, if nothing, ischanging by maintaining the present tradition, the presentdowntown designation for this

property.i justã¡-- and we're also maintaining that social contractwith people who invest in our city, soã¡-- anyway, i'm sorry,but iã¡-- so. >> second is an ordinance toamend and reordain section 2-3 of the zoning ordinance of thecity of norfolk 1992 in order to create definitions of characterdistricts. mr. burfoot.>> i will say this. that, you know, everyone up herehas a level of expertise in various areas.i think at the end of the day,

we're protecting the communitiesaround, in and around downtown by creating these characterdistricts, but more importantly, by putting this in the downtowndistrict and, you know, again, if we do this right and i'vespent a lot of time with frank, the community willã¡-- thecommunities around it would not be negatively impacted, and itensures that we have the proper controls in terms of dealingwith developers and i think at the end of the day, that's whatyou want to establish. you want to try to protect theintegrity of the communities

around it, but also make surethat you get the right mix of the development, whether it becommercial or retail or residential in those communitiesand preserve those communities for years to come.so i vote aye. okay, thank you very much forcoming down. we really appreciate theconversation and the interest everyone has demonstrated.thank you. public hearing 2, please.>> hearing scheduled this day pursuant to action of thecouncil on july 24, 2012, under

the state law, to hear commentson the sale of approximately one acre of city owned land onmonticello avenue between 16th and 17th streets to chick-fil-a,inc. >> there's no member of thepublic signed up to speak to the council on this matter.call the roll. >> i have an ordinanceauthorizing the land disposition and development contract to beentered into with chick-fil-a and authorizing the conveyanceof real property to chick-fil-a as provided in the lddc.dispense with the charter

can i speak?>> sure. >> is this aã¡-- is thisã¡-- isthis a contingent contract should chick-fil-a not besatisfied with what planning is saying or doing with regard tothe setting of the chick-fil-a on the property?>> we have design review. >> right.>> so that if chick-fil-a is not willingã¡-- if we don't reachagreement on the design, closing is contingent to that.>> okay. >> so this is a contingentmatter is what we're voting upon

to allow?>> the contract is not contingent on that, but thecontract requires the design to be approved by us.so that it would be in violation of the contractã¡-- the contractrequires design review and approval.>> if our design review and approval says we don't like yourbuilding, we're not breaching the contract?>> no, so we'reã¡-- >> they're allowed out.>> they could enjoin or terminateã¡-->> they're allowed out, so

that's a contingency then, am icorrect? >> yes.>> all right. aye.>> mr. smigiel. >> aye.public hearing 3, please. >> public hearing scheduled thisday pursuant to action of the council on july 24, 2012, underthe state law, on the application of faith in actionchurch by william m. verebely, jr. to amend the general plan ofnorfolk, 1992, to change the land use designation from mediumdensity residential to

commercial/office, and for achange of zoning from r-11 and c-2 districts to conditional c-2district on property located at 4603 cape henry avenue.by a vote of 6-0, planning commission recommends approval.>> and fred gallop, who i see out here, on behalf of the civicleague is here to answer any questions.he's a proponent, and william zaraby is here as well.he is the applicant. no otherã¡-- no opposition.no other speakers. call the roll.>> i have two ordinances.

so as to change the land usedesignation for property located at 4603 cape henry avenue frommedium density residential to commercial/office.dispense with the charter public hearing 4.>> i have a second ordinance. ordinance to rezone propertylocated at 4603 cape henry avenue from c 2 to traditional.dispense with the charter requirement to reading theordinance. application of rainbow buildingcorporation by donald koester to amend the general plan ofnorfolk, 1992, from low density

residential to medium densityresidential and for a change of zoning from r-8 district toconditional r-9 district on property located at 3316 marneavenue. by vote of 6-0, planningcommission recommends approval. >> call the roll.>> i have two ordinances for this.i have an ordinance to amend the general plan of norfolk, 1992,so as to change the land use designation for property locatedat 3316 marne avenue from low density residential to mediumdensity residential.

dispense with the charterrequirement for reading the ordinance and adopt.mr. burfoot. >> aye.>> mr. protogyrou. >> he's not seeking to buildmultifamily here, is he? >> look at the two separateunits, which is the lot with it. >> no, sir, what the request isis to rezone the property so it can be sub divided and createtwo single-family houses. >> aye.>> i just pull it up fast enough and i look at it, but understandit.

public hearing five.>> second ordinance is an ordinance to rezone propertylocated at 3316 marne avenue from r-8 to conditional r-9.dispense with the charter public hearing 5, please.>> public hearing scheduled this day pursuant to action of thecouncil on july 24, 2012 under the state law, on theapplication of robyn thomas for a change of zoning from i-1district to c-2 and pco-21st districts on property located at901-921 west 21st street. >> and robyn thomas is here asthe applicant and the proponent

if we have any questions aboutthis. okay.>> i have an ordinance to rezone property located at 901 to 921west 21st street from i-1 district and pco-21st district.dispense with the charter public hearing 6.>> public hearing scheduled this day pursuant to action of thecouncil on july 24, 2012, under the state law, on theapplication of vicki s. hatch for the closing, vacating, anddiscontinuing a portion of kincaid avenue from the westernline of early street to its

terminus.by vote of 6-0, planning commission recommends approval.>> no one signed up to address is council on this matter.so you can call the roll. >> i have an ordinance closing,vacating, and discontinuing a portion of kincaid avenue andauthorizing the conveyance to the abutting property owner ofany interest the city may have in the underlying fee of saidportion of kincaid avenue. >> aye.the consent agenda, there are nine items here and is c-7 goingto be voted on at the end of the

docket as a regular agenda item,right? >> that's correct,mr.ã¡president. >> does any member of thecouncilã¡-- would you like to have any one of these mattersconsidered separately? >> c-8.>> c-8? okay.>> to approve the consent agendas with exception of c.7 and 8. mr.ã¡burfoot.>> aye. and this is to advertise for apublic hearing, correct, c-8?

>> yes, sir.>> and gel leah, do you haveã¡-- >> no, i'd just like to talkwith the civic leagues and what not on this issue more before wemove forward on it. >> before we schedule the publichearing? >> yes.>> okay. then why don't we just delaythis one until the next meeting, what is that, the 11th?of september? >> yes, sir.>> the next night meeting? okay.continued until 9/11 on the

consent agenda.>> mr. burfoot. >> if i could ask, i havenoticed there seems to beã¡-- and it's coming up often, we'reseeing a lot of auto repair facilities, tire facilities, andi justã¡-- auto repair and truck facility.within the city. and i don'tã¡-- i understand wewant businesses here, but there's a lot that comes withthese, cars on the lots, parts laying everywhere.i mean, i really have an issue with this.it's somethingã¡-- and i

appreciate angelia wanting topull it and i want to wrap it up with this.that being said, this is reallyã¡-- if we can have franklook at this because it's almost to the extent of check cashingfacilities and things like that, that they're coming up, and thisis not the first one. this is about the third in thelast four meetings. little creek road is a greatexample of what went wrong, so i'll agree with putting it offand say aye, but we really need to examine this.>> frank, we don't need toch

because we can talk about it inan informal session of the council.>> just wanted to let you know you do have a letter of supportfor this item from the eagle side civic league.we did not move this to planning commission until we had thatsupport. >> and the planning commission'svote was? >> they recommended supportbased on the recommendation of theã¡-- from the neighborhood.>> okay. then the motion is to continueto september 11th.

>> and i'm at mr. smigiel.>> and just real quick, looking at the map of this, this istotally within an industrial area, not on a main road, butaye. >> ms.ã¡williams.>> and ingleside at mangrove is industrial and residential, sothat potential for those extra cars, that's what the concern isfor me. i just want to go back to thecivic league and just double check and make sure with them.aye. r-1, please.>> we didn't do 7?

you're going to do 7ã¡-->> at the end of regular agenda. all right.>> trying to help you out, man. >> r-1.>> an ordinance accepting $100,000 from the virginiadepartment of emergency management fiscal year 2011homeland security grant program and appropriating andauthorizing the expenditure of the funds for the purchase oflicense plate readers for the hampton roads urban areasecurity initiative region grant program.dispense with the charter

r-2.>> an ordinance accepting a 2012 public safety grant award of upto $1,500 from the target corporation, and appropriatingand authorizing the expenditure of the grant funds to supportthe norfolk police departmentäºs citywide national night outevent. >> aye.r-3. >> a resolution acknowledgingand concurring with the june 20, 2012, resolution of norfolkpublic schools 55512 electing the employer-certifiedcontribution rate of 11.10% on

behalf of employees who aremembers of the virginia retirement system effectivejulyã¡1, 2012. >> aye.>> mr. riddick. r-4.>> an ordinance accepting grant funds in the amount of $337,050from the virginia department of criminal justice services forthe continuation of the victim/witness assistanceprogram and appropriating and authorizing the expenditure ofthe funds for the program. >> aye.r-5.

>> an ordinance granting aspecial exception to permit the operation of a commercialdrive-through facility on property located at 1818monticello avenue. by 4-0 vote, planning commissionrecommend approval. >> and mr.ã¡jeremy rives and robheb ner are here to answer questions.all right. >> dispense with the charterrequirement for reading the >> aye.r-6. operation of an eating anddrinking establishment on

property located at 420monticello avenue, suite 100. by 3-0, the planning commissionrecommends approval. dispense with the charterrequirementã¡-- >> just a second.phil garrison is here to answer questions if we have any.i'm sorry. go ahead.>> dispense with the charter r-7.>> an ordinance granting a special exception to operate anentertainment establishment on property located at 241 granbystreet.

planning commission recommendsapproval. >> aye.r-8. operation of an entertainmentestablishment on property located at 123 west 21st street.planning commission recommends approval.>> mr.ã¡sum williams, are you here?and allen basen is here to answer questions.okay. cal the roll.>> dispense with the charter >> in protogyrou.>> aye.

r-9.>> an ordinance permitting cape view village i condominiumowners association to encroach into city property at 1878 eastocean view avenue with a wood walkway and stairs.dispense with the charter requirement to read theordinance and adopt. r-10.>> an ordinance granting riverview associates, llc,permission to encroach into the right of way of 1907 colonialavenue and approving the terms and conditions of theencroachment agreement.

>> aye.r-11. >> an ordinance to amend andreordain section 25-321 of the norfolk city code, 1979, so asto add a section to authorize the operation of electric golfcarts in berkley and pinewell. >> jane bethel is here toã¡--she's a proponent. jane, do you want to speak?you wantã¡-- catch you later? okay.call the roll. >> just real quickly, i votedagainst this one time for a condominium complex that wasasking for this.

pinewell, which is in ward five,had asked for this. they're adjacent to a golfcourse. that makes sense.i meanã¡-- >> you voted against it whenlockhaven came. >> i think, there's placements,we have to be careful with these golf carts, communities, broadcreek, there are a couple other communities that make sensebecause they were defined that way, but when we start allowinggolf carts in neighborhoods that normally wouldn't handle golfcarts, i don't knowã¡--

>> like larchmont?>> i don't know if later onã¡-- we're next to an airport.>> i don't know what kind of conversation this leads to.should we have character districts for golf carts, frank?>> leave frank alone. he'sã¡-->> i know. i don't know, down the road,when we're lookingã¡-- >> i depends on if there'senough parking for them. >> it was ward two.>> and berkley said the shipyardsã¡-->> yeah, i don't know.

i'm just saying down the road,just, if we're looking at the plan 2030, i don't know ifthat's being addressed in here or not, but, of course, aye.>> we need some air time. >> oh, man.>> it's a golf community. they can't even haveã¡-->> what am i voting on? >> golf carts.>> aye. >> we know you're behind that.>> he reminded us that he voted against it before, but now he'svoting for it. >> it was a one to complex.>> ms. williams.

>> that's because i didn't likeyou then. go ahead.>> mr. winn. >> barclay.>> mr. winn. >> yes, aye.r-12. >> an ordinance permittingbarbara smith to encroach into north shore road right of waywith an existing house and overhang.dispense with the charter r-13.>> an ordinance approving the terms of right of entryagreement with adams outdoor

advertising relative to certainvacant property located at 1301 north military highway in thecity of norfolk. >> aye.r-14. >> an ordinance to amend andreordain sections 25-653, 654, and 656 of the norfolk citycode, 1979, so as to add one new yield intersection, 21 new stopintersections, and one trucks of one-half tons or overprohibition. >> this is r-15.>> okay. yes.>> i'm sorry, 14.

>> yeah, this is theã¡-->> yes. >> stop signs and stuff.>> i said aye. >> i'm sorry, i didn't hear you.mr. smigiel. >> aye.r-15. >> an ordinance authorizing theacquisition of an easement for right of way improvements overcertain property located at 2900 cape henry avenue in the city ofnorfolk, approving the terms and conditions of the deed ofeasement, and authorizing the expenditure of the sum of $350from funds heretofore

appropriated to pay the purchaseprice for the easement. >> aye.r-16. right of way improvements overcertain property located at 3000 expenditure of the sum of $600from funds heretofore >> aye.r-17. >> an ordinance authorizing theconveyance to the city of norfolk by childrenäºs hospitalof the kingäºs daughters, incorporated, of certainproperty located at intersection of the southern portion ofgreenway court and hampton

boulevard in the city ofnorfolk, virginia, and authorizing the city manager toaccept the deed on behalf of the city.dispense with the charter r-18.>> an ordinance to amend and reordain article x of chapter 25of the norfolk city code, 1979, so as to allow the riding ofbicycles on sidewalks by amending section 25-398 and toeliminate the registration requirements for bicycles byrepealing sections 25-377, 25-379, 25-380, 25-381, 25-382,25-383, 25-384 and 25-385, and

amending section 25-378.dispense with the charter r-19.>> a resolution approving the norfolk community servicesboardäºs performance contract with the commonwealth for fiscalyear 2012 renewable by mutual agreement for fiscal year 2014.adopt resolution. r-20.>> an ordinance amending ordinance number 44,654 so as toprovide health benefits for one previously authorized specialproject position. >> special projects position?>> yes, this is previously

approved and the intention wasthat it would have health insurance with it.generally it doesn't, so this is just to make the provision forthe health insurance. >> okay.aye. r-21.>> an ordinance vacating the western five feet of a ten-footdrainage easement located along the eastern property line oflotã¡2, block 5, subdivision of sussex, also known as 604sterling street, in the city of norfolk.dispense with the charter

r-22.>> an ordinance to change the starting time of the regularweekly city council meeting scheduled for tuesday,septemberã¡25, 2012, at 7:00 p.m. to september 24, 2012, at9:00ã¡a.m. and to move the location of said meeting.dispense with the charter r-23.>> an ordinance directing the city treasurer to issue a refundto quarles petroleum, inc., based upon the correction ofbusiness license tax assessments.dispense with the charter

r-24.>> an ordinance directing the city treasurer to issue a refundto cca financial, llc, based upon the correction of businesspersonal property tax r-25.>> an ordinance directing the city treasurer to issue a refundto cma-cgm america, llc, based upon the correction of businesslicense tax assessments. >> aye.r-26. >> an ordinance directing thecity treasurer to issue a refund to port norfolk transport, inc.,based upon the correction of

business license tax assessmentstax years 2007 through 2008. >> aye.r-27. to crofton diving corporationbased upon the correction of business license tax assessmentstax year 2012. >> aye.r-28. to nyt shared services center,inc., based upon the correction of business personal propertytax assessments. >> aye.r-29. >> an ordinance to accepting agrant in the amount of $29,684

from the virginia department ofcriminal justice services for the norfolk court-appointedspecial advocate, casa, program, appropriating and authorizingthe expenditure of the grant funds for the program,appropriating up to $41,005 in city matching funds and creatingand funding a special project employee position for the casaprogram director. >> just a quick question,bernard. with those grants that we haveto approve, can they get lumped together in oneã¡-- do they haveto be individual or can they go

on to our consent items?>> let me pay attention to that. it will vary, so that this onehas with it an appropriation in addition, and probably needs tobe on the regular agenda, and separate because it's not justto accept the grant, so thatã¡-- let me see if i can't get moreefficiency, but this one needed to stand alone.>> okay. great.thanks, aye. r-30.>> a resolution establishing the mayoräºs commission on povertyreduction.

>> just a second.dan montague? >> good evening, mr.ã¡mayor,council, mr.ã¡jones. my name is dan mon ta gu, i liveat 4605 creek street here in the city of norfolk.i have to take part in this poverty reduction committee,commission, because my hrusb bill this month is half again asmuch as it was a couple months back.i keep telling this council, this little bag here, i put outevery week, and it doesn't weigh ten pounds when i put it in thecan.

but yet, my rate keeps going up,and the thing about it is, we have got to draw the line onthis because, you know, my pension checks don't keep goingup and so therefore, you know, i mean, i'm putting out the samelittle bit of trash, you know, but you guys keep raising therates on me. you know, and i can understandif it was three or four dollars, but, you know, when you'remaking half again as much as it was in the spring, that's alittle bit much. so makeã¡-->> so you're against the poverty

commission?>> huh? >> never mind.>> i'm for it because i need it. >> got it.thank you, dan. >> to adopt the resolution.mr. burfoot. >> aye.thank you very much. r-31.>> an ordinance to amend and reordain chapter 2.1 of thenorfolk city code, 1979, as amended, so as to add one newarticle. and this item establishesmilitary economic development

advisory committee and themayor's advisory commission on veterans affairs.>> john willis. mr.ã¡willis, will youã¡-- i'll beright with you, tom. >> excuse me, i'm not doing toowell. my name is john willis, i havelived in the city of norfolk at different addresses for thebetter part of 50 years. i live in a 2200 block oftarrallton drive right now. i lived there for about 30years. okay.i'm also president of branch 60

of the fleet reserveassociation, veterans association for sea serviceveterans, navy, marine corps and coast guard.we currently have some 900-some-odd members.having lived here for a long time, i've seen the city'sinterest in veterans go from enthusiastic embrace todeafening indifference. i am for this advisorycommission on veterans because i think the city needs to payattention to their veterans. how they think, how they live,and what their interests are.

i applaud captain forã¡-- that'sall i have to say. >> thank you for coming down,mr.ã¡willis. tom lasher.>> good evening, tom lesher. i reside at 4912 cape henryavenue in norfolk. the city of norfolk has withinits boundaries reputation of just about every major veteransorganization this country has, and in some cases, there aremore affiliatesã¡-- we have two or three three affiliates ofã¡--even three affiliates of each of those organizations.this change to the ordinance

will give the city council adirect line to all these organizations.now, with assistance at patriotic activities, questionsyou may have about different veterans affairs that the citywould like to conduct and in turn it gives all theseorganizations a direct line to the city council.now, the idea is that we would have to assist the veterans inany help that we can provide the city, so i obviously am going tospeakã¡-- i speak in favor of this resolution.i've been working with john

andrews on this and we're inplace and all we're waiting for is the go-ahead and away we go.thank you very much. >> if i can, tom isã¡-- was thegenesis of this effort to create this advisory commission, and hestop me one day in my tracks, i don't know, year and a half ago,tom? longer?>> just about, yeah. >> and said norfolk needed acommission like this to address the concerns of the veterans andwe would have a veterans day ceremony.there are lots, all sorts of

things, especially as thepopulation is declining and growing, and we have a lot ofyounger veterans coming out obviously who need our help, andtom has beenã¡-- he's been involved in a lot of really goodefforts, and this isã¡-- tom has agreed to serve on thecommission and to be a part of it and i want to thank you forthis. and john, thank you for comingdown. we intend to take this earusly.thank you very much. >> thank you.>> all right.

>> aye.r-32. >> an ordinance to amend andreordain chapter 6.1 of the norfolk city code, 1979, so asto add a new article viii creating an animal advisoryboard. >> ellis james.>> thank you, mr.ã¡mayor. members of the city council,mr.ã¡jones, my city manager, my name is ellis w. james.i reside at 2021 kenlake place here in the great city ofnorfolk. first of all, i'd like to thankyou very much for the action

that you've just taken on 31.very important for our veterans. i would like to rise in supportof this new committee or commission, whichevertechnically it is, and i would like to keep it simple becauseyou've been through a long meeting.i'd like to recommend to the city that as you set this animaladvisory board up, that you consider appointing person orpersons who have studied the behavior patterns of raptors atthe norfolk botanical garden and as an example, as you well know,eagle experts, photographers,

scientists, etcetera.in view of the proposed harassment of birds aroundnorfolk international airport, which borders the garden.i think it would be very appropriate at this pointbecause we are in for a tough slog in the months and severalyears ahead, i'm afraid. thank you, mr.ã¡mayor.>> thank you. >> thank you.>> call the roll, please. >> it's about time.aye. >> dr. whibley.>> obviously you haven't been

here long enough.this is likeã¡-- aye. >> mr. fraim.>> no. i'm kidding.aye. [ laughter ]>> the next item was c-7, mr.ã¡president, and it is aordinance approving the third amendment between the city ofnorfolk and directing invest llc for the premises located at 500east main street in the city of knock, authorizing the citymanager to security the third amendment to the lease andauthoring the expenditure of a

sum of up to $121,870 from fundsheretofore appropriated to cover the lease payments incorporateremainder of fiscal year 2012-2013.dispense with the charter mr. burfoot.>> that is lease? >> yes.this is a renovation of the existing lease.the development has negotiated a lower rent in consideration ofextending it, so yes, it's the lease for the estate on mainstreet, the department of development operates in theoffice building that

mr.ã¡protogyrou represents.>> you have to give him that shot.i mean, one time we talked about consolidatingã¡-- we have abuilding on granby street that's pretty empty, other than i.t.being in that building. why are we still leasing fromother folks instead of putting thatã¡-- saving that money?>> city manager question. >> i was looking at bernard, i'msorry. >> well, i mean, that's exactlywhat we're trying to do in terms of getting out of space thatwe're leasing.

this was something that wasn'tplanned as one of the moves, moving a department, but i willassure you when the opportunities arise, we do havea list of departments we'd like to consolidate and get out ofleasing space. >> and that's an opportunity, imean. my goodness, i mean, we're notmoving from downtown, but i mean, we have aã¡-- i'm sureyou've been over to that granby building and the space that wehave available over there. i just think that we'reã¡-- youknow, we can complain about how

tight times are as relates toresources, 120-some-thousand dollars to me is a lot of moneywhen we consider we don't have to be utilizing that money forrent space at this time. so i just hope that we do abetter job in terms of looking at these opportunities andmaximizing the spaces that we do have.i'm going to vote no. >> mr. smigiel.>> just real quick comment. i think one of the purposes ofhaving the economic development in that space is because ofbeing able to market our city to

potential developers and it is awonderful conference room. i've been in there a coupletimes and i think it shows off our city.but, you know, regardless of that's a good reason or not,it'sã¡-- aye. >> i have one additional item,mr.ã¡president. a resolutions a pointing arereappointing 18 persons to four boards and two commissions forcertain terms. adopt the resolution.mr. burfoot. >> aye.>> that's all i have, mr.

president.>> that conclusion the formal portion of tonight's agenda.captioning provided by caption associates, llcwww.captionassociates.com

Thursday, April 6, 2017

rent apartment dc


today's may 11 this is lessons of thesixties. we're interviewing marie nahikian a community organizer the interview is taking place at 1844mintwood place a block that me live on many years. present at the interview isanne gallivan and bonnie rowen from the lessons of the sixties project our videographer is eddie becker and marie's husband gene seymour is here too i'm aka decker. hi marie, hi anka. tell usabout where you came from. i came from north carolina. were you born there? grew up and was born an asheville which is now so hip no one can stand it butwasn't so it when i grew up there. went

to college at the university of northcarolina the first year it became - not the woman's college - it had been thewoman's college of the university of north carolina and the first year that iwent with the first year they allowed men on campus. good choice. yep 64 yeah 64, fall of 64 were you an organize your on campus? ohi ended up being yes. what happened? well it was the sixties it was a lot going on civil rights civil rights was a really big deal we did not have we still we stillreferred to african-americans as negroes

the press even referred toafrican-americans as negroes i guess there were two or three thingsthat went on campus one was civil rights organizing and being supportivebecause greensboro north carolina had a whole history you know with the thedemonstrations at woolworth's etc anti-war was a big deal because thevietnam war with a lot of energy there and locally we ended up organizing a huge studentstrike of the cafeteria in support of the cafeteria workers who were trying tounionize and today you look at north carolina and said you know that wereunion organizer yes there were

and we want that strike but we ended uporganizing places for people to eat we get a lot of baloney sandwiches becausewe didn't want people to eat in the cafeteria while the workers were onstrike. so that was that was important and i got involved with student pressmovement which was a very important part of what was going on at the time i wasthe associate editor of the uncg newspaper student newspaper that hadhere 24 been published maybe once a month and we decided topublish it three times a week that we were really christ we thought we werebig-time journalists and published the paper three times a week so that wasthat was for me

i had friends who were involved with sdsand chapel hill you know it was it was all of that . of the mid you know istarted 64 65 have been 66 67 68 that i think a lot of that happen because ittook me five years to get out of college see difficulty to be that createdactivists that your family that band no i don't i don't know that it wasdifficult my father had been involved in unionorganizing or union whatever at the in kenai lon rayon plant in and cut out north carolina outside ofasheville where they made parachute cord among other things for the war world wartwo and he remembers prior to going in

the navy demonstrating for union andbeing hosed down by water hoses in the cold winter mountain weather with dogsyou know they brought dogs out my grandmother's head was a widow and she hadbeen a matron at the nylon ran planet the inca plant and my mother you know my mother grew up in anorphanage in southern florida so i think the one thing that she used to impart isthat you got to take care of everybody and she did she took care of everyone a lot of our life centered around thechurch actually an episcopal church of st. george's and we spent a lot of timetaking care of people so i don't know

maybe that's the history let that be a lesson oh us student press association i had been very involved with them as acollege newspaper editor a number of experiences along the way and in 1969after i graduated i came to washington in the fall of 69 to become theconference coordinator of the college editors conference which took place infebruary 1970 and of course the anti-war demonstrations were going on and we wereall living around dupont circle we're publishing daily the college onnew service college press service and my

job was to organize what turned out tobe ironically the very first now national gathering around ecology andthe environmental crisis and there were a lot of things born at that conferencein february the ecology symbol we turned into a button which i think i still havemany of black and white we-we use the phrase from pogo about wehave met the enemy and he is us so that led to the organizing that wenton that became the first earth day in april of that same year this was a huge gathering there had beena split between liberation new service

and college press service so marshallbloom and others who were involved with liberation new service when ray mongowas there at the conference college newspaper editors from all across thecountry the hog farmers came from where it wasit was held and yeah well the hog farmers came from vermont to theconference which was held at the key bridge marriott and the reason it was atthe key bridge marriott is because the year before the college newspapereditors conference was at the shoreham and there were some pretty heavy-dutyprotests at that conference around the vietnam war and there was also aconference of college football coaches

going on at the same time and it endedup with the college editors and the football coaches and this wouldhave been in 69 kind of having a big fracas in the middle of the shorehamhotel so no hotel in washington dc would takethe conference back again the key bridge marriott was kind of i think night they didn't really know who we work sothat's where the conference was and i don't even know if the hotel still thereactually still there anyway the hog farmers came and saidwe're here to provide security from vermont and wavy gravy

who you can see in all the woodstockfilms wavy gravy was there at the end of the conference i almost joined the hogfarmers in left hand but i shouldn't they would have probably changed my life anyway there were a number of thingsthat happened at that conference walter hickel was a speaker confrontedby members of the hopi indian tribe him in an elevator as he was leaving i happened to be in the elevator trying toescort him out and they confronted him and they said nickel we've come to give you a message and theelevator started to close and his

security detail said we gotta go wegotta go and he said no no i want to hear what they have to say and theelevator opened up again and they said we're here to tell you that we're dyingand the elevator door closes i mean i'll never forget that and you know what was it two weeks laterthree weeks later that he resigned i don't remember i don't know the timingexactly but it was it was a huge impact um probably excuse me probably the biggest impactwas one of the speakers and all these peoplecame because we ask him to speak it was

amazing one of the speakers was robert ohanderson who was the president of atlantic richfield oil and i'm on thepodium beside robert o. anderson who's giving this speech in this impeccablewhite shirt tie you know suit and some people came up on the stage and i'm likewhat's going on here and walk up behind him as he's giving a speech and takes acan of sludge oil and pours it over his head and i was like the hog farmerswouldn't probably who did it that was supposed to be doing security it was really liberation new servicethat did that some of the folks from

there and anderson was amazing he reached into his breast pocket pullthat his handkerchief and white the oil off his face finished his speech and left, was like, ohsludge oil over my head so what the other thing that was hugesignificance at that event was that the all of the defendants from the chicagoconspiracy trial came except of course for bobby seale who had been separatedbut all of the chicago conspiracy defendants from the 68 democraticnational convention events came to that conference and brought with them

these yellow signs or yellow flags that were waved constantlyby all of the people at the conference because the flag said bullshit bullshitbullshit and you know where they were with the chicago conspiracy folksbrought their flags with them so that's what brought me to washington that's a long story about getting to dc what did you do next? i actually got whatwas the most probably the first significantly paid job, that i had i wentto work for a non-profit as only you can in dc trade association called theinstitute of scrap iron and steel and

the guy who was the head of this tradeassociation was really trying to cash in on the possibility of the environmentalmovement so i mean what better thing to hire me who would run the conference andhe hired me as a writer and i worked there and wrote a series ofbooklets on the job occupations in the scrap yard we wereall funded by the-the old seta comprehensive education training actright a seta funded program and we were training very low level you know, i remember that my the booksthat i had to write like how to drive a forklift and how to be a metal sorterall of his books were written like it

the third or fourth grade level becausewe were training people for these jobs and we made super 8 movies so we had a whole little film crew thatdid super 8 movies for uh and i actually still have copies of those books, i don'tknow what happened to the movies, but i so i had this job paid me pretty well atthe time and that's was my first job until this it but didn't i also that waswhen it was shortly after that i moved to mintwood place and got very involvedwith the neighborhood in the community and there was an organization around thecorner called the new thing art and architecture center and it wasupstairs right on columbia road

i don't know what's there now perry's isthere an upstairs restaurant or something yet african drummers world yes melvin dealafrican heritage dancers and drummers were there too and topper carew who wasassociated with the institute for policy studies topper and alice carew livedright on columbia road 175 across from what was in the midtownpharmacy and they had this art program for a community-based art program that did unbelievable stuff lord mcneil was anartist who did things with the kids there

i have some of the original posters ithink of new thing architecture center and they did jazz concerts at theepiscopal church there on that's right on connecticut avenue sevenmarket sent mary's writing yeah that margaret so they did jazzconcerts i think topper started doing some filmsfrom there and because i knew people at theinstitute for policy studies and karl hess was the friend of a mutual friendand we found this house and met with place 1829 and we moved into a grouphouse karl didn't move in right away he movedin later i think and wilson clark who

was an environmental activist arm movedin a friend named david preston who believe it or not was in the navyassigned to the white house and his job is that he was the only white member ofthe kitchen crew everybody else in the white house with scylla pinot except for david and david's job was toserve spiro agnew but he lived you know he just went tohis day job which was the navy job and i can remember going to the white houseone halloween to pick david up from work and we were in this volvo station wagoni don't know who's stationed way it was but we all had on nixon mask and the endyou know the secret service was like oh

that's got a funny you know can youimagine you know that many years later david was not real happy in the navy andhe finally got himself out of the navy he was actually a quite accomplishedartists so david lived there one of the first things we had to dowhen we moved into that house was that wilson clark had been living and judascoburn's apartment on biltmore street judas coburn was clifford clarke'sdaughter right no like a child of god child or nice orsomething anyway she was very involved withanti-war journalism and at the time that

we that wilson was living her apartmentshe was working for the village voice's a correspondent actually quite well noone at that . and she was in cambodia so when wilson moved in with us we hadto go move all the things out of judas coburn's apartment and that's when wediscovered five years worth of village voice's stashed under her bed and wenever knew what i don't know what happened to those papers i just don'tremember having to carry them down flights of stairs but we live at 18 2min meantwood which is how i got involved with neighborhood work it was some sort of equipment

in 1if 197people's constitutional convention largely dominated i don't know who all the parties werethe dominated it but obviously the panthers were very involved and karl wasinvolved in the conference it was at all souls church and it was held itsthanksgiving and i'll swear i think it was thanksgiving morning that karl cameto me and said marie do you have a credit card and i was like i have acredit card that belongs to the institute of scrap iron and steel and hesaid we need this credit card right away and i said okay what do you need thecredit card

he said we have to rent a car and i'mlike okay we have to run the car in time he said look i have to run a card forthe panzers because huey newton is coming 2 down and he has to have a carand i was like okay so we get on the phone and the only car we can sign onthanksgiving morning is at national airport so we drive out to up we were we have to drive the nationalairport to get the rental car but we stopped on the way at all souls to pickup to black panthers who were going to be the drivers so we get to the airportand the two guys i don't know their names but the two guys say oh we can'twe can't have this car and i said it's

the only car we could find it has to bea black car i said we it's a yellow ford and he was like no noshe won't ride in this car and i said it's the only car we can rent so theyfinally, you know took the car drove it off and i never saw the car again huey newton and the panthers kept thatcar for a very long time because this was in november of 7early nineteen seventy-onethat one day these two people show up at theinstitute for scrap iron and steel and i'm asked to come and sit in theconference room with these two gentlemen

and guess where they're from they'refrom the fbi and so it's it's a good cop bad cop because the bad cop guy looks at me andsays how long have you known she would notin and i said he who anyway there were a series of interviewswith the new york with the fbi about my having rented this car but the amazingthing was that the panthers paid for it i i was always afraid that you know ithink my boss at the institute scrap iron and steel were kind of concernedbecause they've had this car for several months now that no one would ever paythe bill on the american express card

but we'd have to pay it immediatelybecause no one kind of put the two and two together until the fbi showed up and shortly thereafter i no longer had achop the tickets - tickets crapper and feel thank you karl house thank you hearingthis it was a great job i mean it was you know a regular salary so that's umthat's when i karl has got me a job working for richard barnett at theinstitute for policy studies and the rest that guess they say is historybecause my active as life continued my organizing life from that pointforward

well is it huh ips was with like no place i hadever really experienced before burnett was working on roots of war his book roots of war and then the nextone was the was the corporate a boy and this is terrible and global reach he had just started research on globalreach his office was across this little hallway from mark raskins office and iwas dick barnett's quote assistant he evidently had gone through a lot ofassistance and you know it was fine i did research for global reach

it was also the period of time whenellsberg was there so it was kind of exposed a bit to the research that wasgoing on around the pentagon papers i mean it was ips was clearly a centerof a lot of the national organizing was going on i however would got more and more deeplyinvolved with the neighborhood and what was going on in adams morgan you knowadams morgan had a history already there had been some early neighborhoodorganizing out of st. margaret's church i think there's even been probably somesun during if i remember it was steven klein who had the archives fromthose years of stephen lived on the

fillmore street so they're always been and he worked ata id at the state department but they're always been a lot of kind ofneighborhood civic activity as it were and it was that that particular time iwas also exposed to milton kotler's work at ips who wrote a book on neighborhoodgovernment and it was that whole seed of neighborhood government and reallyleadership from a number of people but specifically i think proper guru armcertainly milton was involved although he didn't live in the neighborhood buttopper was the one who knew a lot of the the key people in the neighborhood andso we embarked on this project to

organize a neighborhood government wewere going to have our own independent government because there was no homerule and so we figured well we'll just select their own government and organizeit and we met every saturday for hours at the potter's house which had beenopen too long but it was there and it was a coffee house and we met thereevery saturday morning to try to come up with the constitution and a bylaws onhow we were going to organize our neighborhood government and we came upwith the whole concept of single-member districts and selecting five delegatesfrom each single member district within adams morgan and i'm i'm trying toremember the exact boundaries certainly

16 street and connecticut avenue probably what's the street right off of thebridge ashmead calvert ashmead thatway over to connecticut avenue as far south as went down for the swannn “t” idon't remember what the southern boundary was but it includes swan streetand “t” street and as straight rap oh yeah rap was there onwillard street you know so was that far down, anyway was so wehad these five single member districts and we move forward to elect ourneighborhood government and we formed

something called the adams morganorganization which took on an amazing kind of a series of things that we did.there was there was an economic development committee that led tocreating a worker-owned co-ops like fields of plenty stone soup was a little bit moreindependent i'm not sure they were really connected so much directly butthey were further down the hill but certainly fields of plenty and one of the funny stories i could remember from fields of plenty there has never been a store where you had items in bulk

where you had something where you putthe scoop in and scoop it into a bag and you bought nuts or fruit or whatever itwas the health department went whacko ohyou can have this and we ended up having a rather protracted back and forth withthe dc government and the health department over how we could displaythings that start at fields of plenty which was which was on 18th street i think right where this coffeehouse isnow the amo office was a few doors down from that and hess had organizedthe science and technology committee and decided that among things we were goingto build

entrepreneurship around issues of food so in a warehouse on champlain street hestarted growing fish had a lot of youth involved and growing the fish the problem was that the electricity inthe warehouse was not particularly reliable, the electricity would go off andthe fish would die and we would start all over again i'm not sure we ever had any fish thatwe were able to eat because we couldn't keep the electricity on in the warehousenow karl if he were here rest his soul would probably tell methat yes we did eat fish from the from

the community technology but he wasinvolved in all kinds of things around technology and community science & but the fish were the bigproject community park west came out of an amo committee walter pierce lived in the neighborhoodwalter and his you know the whole group of youth in that neighborhood had playedon that park for years one of the great lessons that i learnedabout community about community organizing came from the community ofthe community park west experience there was a garden

it was a community garden and a lot ofdifferent people grew in this garden but it was kind of like a hodgepodge i mean they were not plots that was notthis it was not that but a lot of people you know had tomato plants and beansand whatever and it was a very diverse group lot of latinos who were growingyou know older white folks lot of black folks were growing in the garden andthere arose a big controversy because someone one night stole a lot of thetomatoes the tomatoes were gone and people were very upset because that itnever really happened before and what resulted from that was thatthere was a big discussion and they

decided okay we have to have individualgarden plots, divided up the community garden assign these plots, and you knowwhat, the garden never worked again after that, it was like well that's my plot nowthat's my plot you know and it was this constant back and forth i don't know what's happened to thecommunity garden whether it's still there but i hope it's just peoplegrowing tomatoes that would make a big difference. can you tell us that you workand how is he in the right there's one other community part storyyeah oh what a beautiful

it's called the walter pierce park and the way we ended up getting the money to buy it because it was owned bythe shapiro family is that we had this huge television and someone because wehad this community technology committee learned how to make a video of some sorti think it was nick demartino, that started that project and we made a movieabout shapiro park and what became community park west and we had thiswalter pierce did this we loaded this big hunk of wooden television on like adolly that we took to congress and we hauled it around from congressman tosenator to congressman to senator and show this movie to anybody who wouldwatch it because we wanted congress to

approve the money to allow the districtto buy community park west it took about two years but it workedand that's how the park got to where it is today with now walter pierce park but that was an important learning kindof curve for me as a community organizer because you can have a lot of ideas andstrategies but if you can't think through how you're going to deal with itultimately and on the money side was a really important one and that kind ofbecame a really key issue around housing you asked about my work and housinghousing became a big issue because

gentrification was starting to reallytake off in adams morgan we started organizing and doing rallies and havingtenant groups and probably one of the most powerful organizing tools we hadwas antioch school of law which was up on 16th street and they sent a lot oftheir law students who became interns and worked as you know legal folks witha lot of the tenant groups they worked out of the amo office so the housing committee because amo hadthis series of committees that i've described but the housing committee wasa big one the housing committee i mean there wassending became so much going on so many

blocks and so many buildings and isdeveloping and always pressure a couple of things that happened rap incorporated with the fluid streetit was it was it was a drug treatment program in it was much more than thatwith the community organizing arm that really pulled in a lot of kids rap youknow i can always be depended on to to be there when you needed people and wewe were doing with in college gentrification impressive we called itdisplays so we would do these and displacement isthis is what 773 the beginning your congo'sconversion of all departments , most

right condo started doing some condomsconversions the law had changed that made the only rental housing not sowonderful in terms of the favorable tax treatment and change nixon was in the white house and for allthe things you can say really awful about richard nixon when he came to thedistrict of columbia nixon was in the interesting and wage and price controlsis what allowed us to get a local weather the wall which allowed us to have a lotof the very progressive housing

legislation that came out of that and itwas you know who's wage and price controls that he did federal national level that allowed thathappen in the district of columbia we organize we got a very good at that timei felt very strongly in control probably the strongest parts of the lawwere right of first refusal if you live at that time initially in asingle family house you have to be offered a right to buythe house before the owner could sell it because so many of our family touringrental housing and the second thing is that it is set out basic controls onfiction

so you couldn't just walk in and walkpeople out which you can still do with some places in the country but in thatsense it was a very strong legislative framework but prior to that it was a lotof of organizing a lot of tenant organizing it went on and that after the first rent controlwall there was a second law that was passed that extended the right of firstrefusal to multifamily building and ultimately down the road after marionbarry was elected mayor we converted three thousand units in three years totenant ownership from and a rental - 1of the building still remained to that

up and down columbia run uncle lives in one certainly i would andone at one point having been gentrified off of mental place you know when i leftit with place to watch the of actually wrote an article about how i was beingquote displays network was already become an issue oh yeah becoming you're gonna needan initial right first to tee up things he was amazing i got a call from this harvey videoalready there was another key person in this

and her name is fanny hill this fannywas amazing woman who cooked she cook for everybody and somewherealong the way pg pg the gasworks washington guess and why in hip yeah but it wasn't thatwas what he had my had hired her she has kind of this communityambassadors who would show up all over the city and show people how to cookwith no honey i actually still have her i helped her write this email somerandom restaurant on 18 31 for that that's another story anyway miss fanny was this kind of person whoshe lived in a little house on the

street and you know she would justmaterialize all this food and she used kids her kids bank everything cookedeverything and so a lot of the organizing that we were doing wassuccessful because people would come to the new miss fanny was cooking so peoplewould show up for any me so miss fanny was a key part of thecommunity organizing that went on in adams morgan because she was she washired by watching gasps work i think they paid or almost nothing butmiss annie did food demonstrations for all of these community events where shewould come in and show you how to cook with no money

she did some amazing things as i said istill have her cookbook which i helped her write miss danni was a part of thebusiness success of organizing and adams morgan because she would always come andthis family used to refer to me as her play daughter she was also big with alot of foster kids and she and i actually shared a foster child oncethat's very interesting story from a school board member as to how i ended upwith his foster child named kyle miss fanny call me up and miss harvey wholived on seating place called me up and said there's something going on downhere because we all got these letters and we went and looked at the lettersand the letter basically said you have

3bought the entire every rental property on the on the block and we were like appalled that was awhole was 27 families it was like what are you doing we had just gotten the home rule i meanof the just gotten the ring control bill in place and there was this littleobscure thing in there about the right of first refusal if you lived in asingle family house and i was like well you should apply we weren't sure how it would apply butthis should apply

i had also been appointed to the firstrip commission so we were in the process of writing regulations for it and hadcontinued i no longer work for em i was the executive director i was the firstexecutive director but i no longer work for them full time i had gone to workfor a common cause around the home rule campaign i had worked for npr for a while and soonce we started to look at this piece of paper and kept saying well we should beable to do something and so i went to johnny barnes johnny barnes was a youngattorney working at the georgetown legal clinic and i said johnny

don't you think there's something we cando about that and he was like well yeah i'm not sure what but he wrote a letterto the developer and said you violated local law because these families deservetheir first right of refusal there are many into an ounce of thestory of how this rolled out but most significantly we ended up in court andthe families were amazingly strong you're not putting us out of our houseswe started doing son raising frank smith had become i guess the chairperson ofthe adams morgan organization at the time i was sitting on the rinkcommission johnny barnes was headed the legal thing and finally

somewhere along the way johnny said idon't think i can represent 127 families and we got i want to say arnold importer but i have to check to make sure but wegot a major law firm to represent these families so at that point we would gointo court before the judge and there would be 27 families 27 cases thedeveloper and this slew of corporate attorneys and finally one day the judgelooked at the courtroom and said you know what you all need to go outside andfigure out how you're going to settle this because if you don't we're going toend up in the supreme court

so we never mitigated the issue of firstright of refusal we actually went out and ended up settling and the developeragreed to sell the houses to the family huge victory and then it was like noneof them had any money how are we going to pay for these houseswe've been doing fundraising and then of course the families started to get alittle panic eight because we only had so much time in which to meet this rightof first refusal and about that time there had been an effort to build up abranch of perpetual savings and loan at 18th in columbia road mo once again was very involved and at afederal level they have there had been

some legislation passed called the community reinvestment act and itjust been passed and so with research done and eddie i'm sure you'll be ableto fill in on the reason because it was a it was a community-based research andeducation group that special reserve the perpetual research prison is still going that's good to hear anyway they werevery involved in putting together the framework and we follow the challengebefore the federal home loan bank board because perpetual refuse to providemortgages for these 27 families to buy their houses and that's a verysimplistic over

overview of what happened available johnbrown that's right interest research he waswith the ralph nader research i had forgotten about john brown we alsohad another group of nader lawyers around the federal communicationscommission but that was a whole another project that am i was involved in thathad to do with ownership of media anyway that that was a very important work thatwe did at that point but we followed a challenge at the federal home loan bankboard and the federal home loan bank board members i actually have met since then a womanwho was a member of that board who

looked at me and said i remember thatbecause there were no records we didn't know what to do once again the pressure ended up withnegotiations with perpetual who agreed to provide the mortgages and agreed tobuild the building in a way that there would be a courtyard and a place for acommunity gathering which ended up being of course the farmers market right in the new bank building and athing columbia road which i think today is still there i'm just said it may not be there toomuch longer but so the families were

given the right to buy their houses theygot the mortgages and then it was like these houses have to be rehabbed andperpetual that was one of the big issues is that they didn't want to writemortgages for houses that were falling apart in many ways they were you knowvery small two-story houses so we started looking at where to get themoney and determine of course that the best source was federal rehab loans thatcame through the district of columbia but when you look at the map for whereyou could get a rehab loan all the map was that was colored that you could getloans there was not one block and adams morgan where you could get acommunity development loan and at that

point we took on the city council andthe department of housing and community development the hdd here and finally they designated by specialresolution one block if adams morgan which was the17 qualify for rehab loans the next big hurdle of trying to keepthese 27 families intact some of whom were very were older seniorcitizens and this battle went on for three or four years and trying to keepthem intact was very hard it was a very very critically important piece ofhousing history in an affordable housing

history in the district of columbia i remember going through the agony ofwhere the family is going to live while we have what's going on and they got relocated i think two of the families didn't makeit back to their houses after we have one passed away but that was the saga ofseating street which led to the second round of the rent control law which thenincorporated the extension of right of first refusal to multifamily buildingsthat ultimately spawned thousands of rental units being converted to tenanton co-ops that still exists today that

many of us live in and still go to thatyou talked before that importance and housing to women and the importance ofwomen is housing in ages oh yeah was always the women always thewomen who organized and kept the organization together i remember a tenant group i you know even even the latino latinofamilies the latino organizers i remember a group of families on a teenstreet all of the members of the tenant association where women that is what because women are the ones who keep thefamily together who worry about are my

kids going to have a place to live and ithink that that was a huge motivation i mean i can remember having some quotepolitical discussions about whether or not housing was a woman's issue havingwas definitely a woman's issue because it was mostly women who were doing theorganizing doing the tenant work not a hundred percent but probably 8percent werewomen iggy know and to this day the buildingthat i lived in plaza west on columbia road all of theofficers of that tenant co-op were women and to this day as far as i know one ofthe original officers who and mccain who was the secretary of that co-op is stilli mean she may have finally resign with

still the secretary of that colorboarding and the keeper of the history so i think that that was always the casethat women were able to see what was in their own best self interest in a waythat i think men were never forced to have to think about it a lot of it hadto do with children and families can you tell us that some people you work withyou in the neighborhood 3d john wow you talk to that johnny linejohnny barnes was an important attorney certainly the folks at any of law schoolwere really committed in the leadership at antioch was very committed edward jackson and jackson who lived onbeyond ontario road

you're right i was a key person healways headed up every few months a community cleanup where he would havepeople out shoveling and raking and cleaning up the neighborhood to keep itclean that was his that was his niche that was hiscommitment but he was a very important leader he was very involved in hischurch community his whole family was he was a homeownera long time homeowner ontario place charlotte i'm sorry i have to stop and think shelived she had been displaced from ontario place at one point which iswhere walter pearson his family live

charlotte and then she moved to a houseand was actually on columbia road she was a key person in every one ofthese single member districts that were key leaders carol davis on linear place which ofcourse had been home to a lot of the old sds organizers and anti-war arguments onorganizers before yeah but what are you all going to haveto help me on here he ended up being he ended up being a the legislature in california he livedin ontario place there was a collective of people who live there was reallydavis there i think really davis was

karl what on when your place what was he was he was involved withjames bond come on kylie no wasn't karl oh tom hayden of course all right who became a sweater later incalifornia ya tom hayden lived on linear place where right next to the firestation because carol davis slipped on the other the other side to wear thishad to have been 74 maybe 71 to 74 there were there was arotating number of people who lived in on that particular house there's anapartment building mid-block on linear place i have no ideawhat it's like now

but that's where dorothy mcgee lived anddorothy mcgee was a key part of everything that went on in the communitybecause she was the publisher of three different underground newspapers thedaily rag colonial times boy who can remember the color i thinkcolonial times was first in the daily rag and then newsworks there was another communitynewspaper bob bollman was involved as was called the rock creek monitor jude franco and there was another personand one is brian brian who works for brian who works for the it's not thefederal home loan bank board with the

federal housing finance agency i think you said i don't know maybe he'sretired on the station 39 years ago i was on the first wpfw board was a hugebattle over getting the license pacific guide applied for the license we finallygot the license and then there was another huge battle between the pacificnational board and the local folks over how black the station would be becausethe national you know movement left folks wanted to control the station butthe local folks wanted to control their own stations and there was all thistension there that led to jazz and justice radio andthat was it was a big deal when we as a

local board agreed that we would playonly jazz and that's what we started out as paying playing only jazz i then was elected to the nationalpacific aboard as a part of that effort man the course the station still thereit's gone through its struggles and continues but i can't believe it was 39years ago i figured that out yesterday i think it was 39 years the chris then wethe whole issue of homelessness surface for the first time we never had how muchpeople i can remember doing an interview with the new york times was writingabout the coalition for the homeless and mitch schneider and the community forcreative non-violence and i i read that

interview again recently and i was likei can't believe i said this but i actually said in adams morgan we didn'thave homeless people because people kind of took care of each other and if therewas somebody who i can remember walter pierce's mother used to let everybodyunder the sun you know if they needed a place to staythey would you know you knew where people could go and stay we didn't havethat level of homelessness but as the gentrification and displacement spreadand as the economy got more and more difficult well jimmy carter was elected in 74 74after work and grow

car that's true 76 ok so it's about 1976that some very significant things happen namely wage and price controls getlifted which had been imposed by the nixon administration nixon was like thelast president to ever fully fund the development of affordable housingbecause it was under nixon that section 8 program was created once that came to an end and wage andprice controls came to an end prices started to spiral out of controlboth in terms of rental housing and of course we had the age-old argument inthe district of columbia that well give rent control

you know no one's going to build anyrental housing as long as you're ever in control even though new rental housingwould have been exempt from rent control that was you know that was always theargument economically so we began to see i think that was kindof where because what happened is waiting price controls were listed undercarter and if you remember interest rates hit twenty-three percent andeverything spiraled out of control it was at that point that i went to iwas working for the barry administration at this the local housing department and westarted the tenant purchase assistance

program where we put in place a wholeseries of things to help tenants bother building that's when we did threethousand units in three years we had an innovative grant from hudpatricia robert harris had been secretary of hud we had other grantsthat we were able to put in place and the whole theory behind tenant purchasewas if we can get folks into ownership by the building and we had technicalassistance we funded muscle and metropolitan washington planning andhousing who would come in with the team of people to provide technicalassistance and organizing and getting people could you have to exercise yourright within a certain period of time

hundred eighty days i think it was ahundred and twenty and it all worked very well except that the premise wasget people into ownership once the coop own the building then itwould be pretty easy to get long-term mortgages the problem was that long-term mortgageshit that twenty-two twenty-three percent and nobody could afford that so it was areal kind of panicked to figure out how to do that and there was an insurancecompany that actually came to the table jim gibbons the gibbons know jim who wasthe president of this insurance company and he agreed to give mortgages to thetenant co-ops

i have to track down and think throughhis name which was pretty amazing in and of itself the a society google see uncle andconservation that's right of lenders it would finallymake the construction loans and i guess it was at that point that i decidedi should run for city council because i ran for city council twice once at largewhich i think was a much more exciting time and then of course oncefrom word one but it was the first time i started to work kind of professionallyas an affordable housing developer and then i was elected president of the newcoalition for the homeless and community

for creative non-violence and mitchschneider had i had an issue on the ballot givingpeople the right to shelter and the coalition for the homeless which was allof the various nonprofit neighborhood groups who would come together to try todo programs etc for homeless people dennis buffet was a was a leader in thatwhole group took a rather novel position of opposing the ballot question for theright for shelter it was it was very very divisive but aschair of the coalition for the homeless i had to speak for that position whichwas very very hard because i'm not sure i ever really agreed but the big concernwas that if you were going to have a

right to shelter what you were going toend up with was big warehouses which is exactly what happened because that wasthe only way you could you could provide that kind of basic right to shelter butthe ballot initiative want you know pass so the district of columbia's this hasbeen changed i don't think it has like new york you have a basic right toshelter which does define in some very clear ways the government'sresponsibility to support people who need housing in new york it's been onthe books for a very very long time but you city council races what lessons

well i think the i ran for city councilbecause i thought i could use that as a basis for organizing oh no on a wider basis and i think therewas a point in time when the government was still very new that that might havebeen possible but i think by the time i ran for the word one seat it haddeteriorated into electoral politics business as usual and it was a questionof-of you know who could do what you know with whatever people at the pollsand i think that my my-my race for city council on board one you know posed a real racial dilemma fora lot of people who thought well we

should vote black as opposed to lookingat issues and i think that the those that was a difficult time was a verydifficult time for me it was very difficult time for a lot of people whotold me murray i really would like to support you but icannot use why would you ask me this plus i have tostop and think what year it was maybe you should maybe you should put it on myarm jenny 78 79 8- yeah yeah with 17 i was functional yes and you know i don't know what to tellyou no no that was the second time on thatlist

the first time i ran at large oh forcity council with large place that thinks i found out the other day i thinki placed 3rd hr crawford one that seat ya know that was the second time in ward1 yeah that was right smith who wouldbecome chairperson and frank had never been involved historically but he wasalso involved with ips he was a fellow at ips and the christian there'sthe whole saga of my role with ips when i when nick barnett fired me because hesaid i was spending way too much time you know dealing with work that wasn'this and i said to him well i don't know whyyou can't use your own finger to dye

your own phone and i think it was thenext day that i was told you know marie you really should find something else todo and that's when i kind of started freelancing and working you know in theneighborhood stuffed full time but i subsequently was among the first groupof women nominated to be a fellow at ips arthur wast thou nominated me to be afellow and charlotte bunch was in that groups it was this group of womenbecause the big controversy and ips was there were no women there were no womenfellow so i was among that first group and asit was related to me later i wasn't there but it was related to me laterthat i was elected because the work i

guess the big debate was between markyou know markin dick barnett mark raskin dick barnett made the ultimate decision the other fellows were involved but theymade the ultimate decision but my work was not considered academic enough youknow scholarly i was not doing scholar wework community organizing was not considered scholarly enough even thoughwe were doing a lot of stuff that challenge basic economics and on and onanyone but that would have been nominated as a fair amount ofsignificantly changed my life is by probably would have never run for citycouncil

yeah so tell us what all this amazingexperience college inform your life since then well i guess it depends on who you mightask but from my perspective everything i get after that was about organizing iworked as a affordable housing professional and i went on to workinitially and i i left the district in 85 yep in 85 and went to philadelphia wherei was a neighborhood what they call the neighborhooddevelopment fellowship and i built a huge amount of housing in northphiladelphia much of which is still

the very first kind of sro we built converted to school did thevery very first tax credit low income housing tax credit deal that was everdone with fannie mae is an investor in north philly arm and from there other than the fact that that's where imet my husband and that's where our son was born i then went to new york because janewent off to new york so we lived in brooklyn for 20-plusyears and i did a variety of housingdevelopment work i worked in queens i

was executive director of habitat forhumanity in new york city which was probably one of them as satisfying jobsever had because at that point habitat took no government money so we raisedall our money and it was wonderful because then we could just decide how wewanted to spend it and we did some pretty important things at that time we finished off the thefamous jimmy carter buildings on the lower east side and started doing inphil housing we did one of the first projects in brooklyn and habitat ofcourse and we did the first project started the first project in harlem

so we did a lot of housing there iworked with in long island at the long island housing partnership doing kind ofconsortium financing with banks for senior citizen housing worked in queensdoing economic development with the queens borough president we did some housing but i was doing alot of entrepreneur development and very very diverse communities and then uhworked with housing works in new york city which was providing housing forpeople who are living with hiv nh and of course some of the very early folks thati knew in adams morgan live de menthe would place who died from eight

i mean the impact of that was prettypretty heavy duty you know people who had been involved inan amo organizing people who had supported i did a radio show and in dc at onepoint with john wilson before he ever became a member of the city council on wamu andwe talked about local issues and one of the people involved with that show diedof aids so eight took its toll not just in the gay community and thearts community but in the community

development you know community as well so i i builtand managed housing for people who are homeless but we're also active drugusers so i did that with housing works and then i guess in 2the district to workat hud right in the aftermath of when the recovery act waspassed by the obama administration and we did the neighborhood stabilizationprogram which was the national hugely successful even today effort to put notonly money on the street to help people buy foreclosed properties and make themaffordable but also a very very successful effort at building capacity

and local technical assistance effortsto build the capacity because people have forgotten how do you buildaffordable housing how do you do the kind of we never really got down to thekind of basic community organizing that people still i think don't quite knowhow to do every day how do you bring people together and howthe people figure out what's in there own best self-interest that's a very hard question becausepeople don't know how their own self-interest connects to the decisionsthat get made that change their lives and there's much of what you look backon now

and you think you know this is it's likeit's like your life passing in front of you what happened to all that workbecause i think we've done a lousy job of succession planning a proactiveanother way of describing it but we sometimes i think we haven't done a verygood job of bringing along the leadership that even has the notion thatit's possible to change things but then i look at the young people who are partof my sons you know the twenties and i'm like ohwell you guys are doing it one of the young african-american men who was one of the first people that myson connected with in college name is

james days james is organizing in ohio and one dayhe you know and we've talked often on he was winded chaffins best friends and hehe said to me you know somebody named cortland cocks and i was like a winocourt when cocks of course you know to cortland booth and courtland is a partof what they call the sncc elders who are now working with young people over you know all of these issues the blacklives matter and it's like hey maybe this is going to come around you know i mean i remember my earlyconfrontations with you know with with

sncc and being told get out you know just leave now you you don't need to be here which ledto a very very important moment for me in college because i was able to becausei was asked to live leave a snake organizing conferences iended up walking down the street dead and these are bed this church andmeeting martin luther king and doing a very long interview which wassubsequently published with coretta scott king so it's a very it was a very importantthing for me to have been told to leave

but that you know that i think thequestion becomes can we can you bring people i mean i was a jackson delegatewhen jesse jackson ran for president and we elected all these local delegates andpeople forget the amazing organizing that he in and the people around him did thequestion becomes can you can you cole s these folks back together in a way thatwill make a significant difference thank you thank you thank you when asked questions so what-what one thing about get somemore detail about call has he was coming

out of this karl has the head was barry goldwaterspeech writer and he came out of a of a heavy-duty libertarian really an economist kind of history andif you read any of his books and work now you you see what that history was i'm notquite sure how karl got to the district of columbia accept that obviously he worked for barry goldwaterso that's what brought him here and when i met karl the first time he was livingat on about at buzzards . it was after

he left the buzzards . boat i guess theyall got evicted or maybe he broke up a relationship i don't remember both thathe came to live with us a minute would place and karl had very very newthoughts about what libertarianism what being an amicus mint and it all had todo with the whole issues of local control which is the reason why he wassent to heavy-duty supporter of the neighborhood government work that wewere doing he never disagreed that you neededregulation that you needed regulatory framework but that it should becontrolled as locally as possible and if if decisions could be made major policydecisions could be debated and made in a

town hall atmosphere people acted moreresponsibly not just because they were with theirfriends and neighbors but because it allowed them to be educated about whatwas in fact in their own self-interest because i think what happens now aspeople become so isolated day they don't know they don't know that you knoweconomic decisions are not in their own best self-interest and i think karl wasan important it was an important thinker and heactually you know he actually wanted to do things it was more than just being asinker he actually wanted to do things and sore adams morgan as soon as thelaboratory we were a great laboratory

it was no question that just like manymany things you think of historically in the district of columbia i mean look at urban renewal we were thegreat laboratory and southwest dc of urban renewal you know eleanor frank eleanor rooseveltlooked at all these o people living there on the river withno indoor plumbing and we have to do something and what do they do that raised all ofsouth with dc and moved all of 27 thousand families moved from there tochar basically so we've always been a

great laboratory i think the distinctpart of what happened in adams morgan is that it was truly you know an effortfrom the bottom up it was not something that was likesomeone's great experiment and i think that was that was an important and ithink the other thing that was so important about what we did is that itwas promised on many different kinds of people both economically and raciallybeing able to work together the amo flag which my mother made thatsaid unity and diversity you know you know so it's a neighborhooddid struggle to achieve school in - yeah and you know when it what people maybedon't know or understand about when

marion barry was elected mayor he was avery very important progressive leader to the very end hewas an important progressive leader and those of us who were involved with hisfirst administration we really thought we were going to builda local government that was going to be different that would be very different would bevery progressive that would be very locally based with advisory neighborhoodcommissions and that's how decisions and policy got a the problem of course wasthat congress controlled everything i mean that's certainly was something thati think he'll the mason and you know

julius hobson and the people who startedthe dc stated party believed you know they were they were the premise for ya we can do this and we can do it in avery different kind of way it was a time of great optimism and wedid some pretty of you know there was some pretty amazing things that happen i mean adams morgan in the work thatmarion barry was doing he wasn't even on the school board at that point aroundthe pilot district project took on the issues of police brutality that you tookthe parallel right down the line what's going on now with black livesmatter i suspect folks in black lives

minor know nothing about the pilotdistrict project so the question bending maybe they dobecause courtland's connected them so we can help with somebody like court letteryou know jimmy garrett or somebody else would have connected them the inspiration i don't know solomon skior any you can provide for jim darrell of these names well certainly karen clients with wasimportant i mean she-she kind of came along as we were doing housing stuff andshe was very involved in community development and financing and sheactually gave me a job once when i

really needed one which was at people'sinvolvement corporation where we did we convinced howard university president togive us some of the vacant houses in the droid park and i convinced the districtof columbia government to give us some loans and we actually rehab houses inthe droid park which was pretty cool those were all historic so that was anexciting kind of time that was under the president who had been president forever so care and i think work particularly at the hud level with genobarone ii and was an important kind of person and i think karen now works inbaltimore doing community development if i'm correct but i may be incorrect but ithink she's in baltimore jim zarrella

jim jim was one of the tim was one ofthe thinker's you know who kind of took the concept of a community reinvestment and built on it i think i can't remember the name of thenonprofit in the coalition that he put together and i think that was what wasreally interesting around a lot of what was going on is that you had you hadthese connections between people who were doing to some extent theoretical orresearch or whatever but in adams morgan you know we were we were the doers wewere the ones who support yeah why not i mean human i mentioned something aboutthe federal communications commission

and what happened there there were a group of public interestwarriors and charles firestone being one who were very involved in the issuesbefore the fcc around local media and the fact that local media was becomingmore and more consolidated and they followed the challenge to the fcc thatled to you know splitting up some of the-the mediacontrol between tv and it led to the rule that said that somebody onecorporation could not own a major newspaper the radio and the televisionthat spawned h you are being given the howard university by wtop and had a lotto do with what happened with the

washington start but we day we werethere lap i mean we were the community of voicethat said yes we don't think there should be localmedia control if you work with you mark you know absolutely videos absolutely nick nickwas cutting this like i'm a he had also been a part of us student pressassociation and college press service and knit said we're starting this videoproject and he would teach kids how to use video how to use technology he did the that i pretty sure it wasnick who did the-the famous tape that

led to our dragging this movie aroundcongress to get them to run community park west on now walter pierce part so nick was nick was an important part i think he lived with us in 1829 for abrief time i can't remember how long it was like a couple of months somewhere inthere so the community video project i alwayssaw it as a kind of extension of much of what we were doing community control schools i mean thatwas that was a whole thing at hd cooking and that's how marie got built the moviethat has an interesting history but the

applicants trees disappointment so i understand i do remember when thepool first opened down there because i'm a i-i-i swim if it was so crazy becausethe pool and marie reed had so many different cultures swimming in the poolyou could never bring order yeah you know - who was swimming whatlane and more they all going this way or where they go on this way or that waskind of like the community garden story it was like oh my god it was thelifeguards just had no control over that pool at all it was always free swim always know you

of course you know it was on it was onmet with place that we had the first met would place block party that withinabout three years became adams morgan day and the people on meant would placehated of after that they were like god adams morgan day we're all these peoplecome from it cetera i can remember when they were doing whatthey would do they started doing evening stuff at what was then having youngfrere and some of the younger folks in the community decided we're going tostand around outside and scare them so maybe they will all go away from thesegroups of young men kind of grouping arrest the evening and having anaffair just hoping that these people

would go away and not come here to eatthis french fruit it and you know the whole thing about the bars everybody was like up in arms aboutevery everything you opened up with about the bar remember when columbia station open itwas like now original come , station this yeah adams morgan didn't want to be anothergeorgetown exactly exactly and in fact that it was the big dealabout the subway whether or not we're gonna have a metrostop in adams morgan and ended up at

woodley because people didn't want themetro stop because it would become like and that's exactly why georgetown has nometro stop they fought against it well that was very i don't know i don'tknow what year it was to be honest it would have been a natural and 76 andthat would come yeah but they were still building partsof it so - 72 73 yeah construction of a few years yeah disaster now well look at who designed it wasdesigned by the army corps of engineers

the army corps of engineers have neverdesigned anything for public wide public use you know that's not what they had everdone and then of course congress stop sending any maintenance also gets aroundjurisdiction especially virginia refused that i meanpressure yeah one two three so ok campaign ran for city council herea hundred waiver unsuccessful bid and he was riding on this myth you guysactually created when we see was like yeah and-and the my campaign beenordered one use the use the heart you

know and up until ready two years ago your bumper sticker was still on theback of a one-way sorry you know and you know what there wasanother one and i don't know if it's still there but somebody tell me the nottoo long ago that there was another one on the back of a stop sign somebody was really under the back ofsubstance a cap with university there was one right there issue as youcome up whatever it is that goes across i guessif you go all the way across columbia

road to catholic university and come upthat way yeah michigan app which is really funny then the he can he can he can postersthe yellow ones what is our meeting i mean you know youdaddy booking my father's my grandfather camein the second wave the second massacre in the union he was recruited off the boat literallymy grandfather because he could speak multiple languages he was 12 years oldhe can speak multiple languages but he was recruited to go to a military schoolcalled ben lippen huh

in western north carolina to playfootball and that's how i ended up in north carolina