Wednesday, April 5, 2017

rent apartment dallas


>>> good afternoon, everyone. my name is patrick. i work in the secretary's office here at hud. i'm joined today by my colleagues, greg burn to my far right, who works in the office of public housing, dia thompson, also in pih, and

margaret salazar in the office of multifamily programs. today we want to share with you the proposed implementation details of the rental assistance demonstration or rad. hopefully most of you are fa congress in last november hud

2012 appropriations bill and based on our proposals last year. most of up know the purpose of rad is to generate additional sources of financing to address a substantial needs in public housing and with the so-called multifamily

organs, the rad and mod rehab programs. the public housing backlog today stands at nearly $26 billion as documented by the recent study. without additional financing resources, we stand to lose about 10 to 15,000 hard units of just public housing each year.

rad will test on a limited basis the convergence assistance for both public housing and orphans for long-term project based section 8 rental assistance to better access private debt and equity investments to help address that backlog and to stem the loss of this very much

needed housing. in publishing the initial notice last week, and maybe you had a chance to look through it, we considerable detail how hud proposes to implement the authority congress granted us in the 2012 appropriations bill. i say proposes, because the

initial notice is designed to solicit your comments. over the last year -- hopefully opportunity to discuss your thoughts, your inputs with us and how to implement the demonstration. the challenge now is to translate the statutory

authority into a workable we fully realize that what we propose now nor complete despite being fairly lengthy and may not be sufficiently addressing the questions and the inputs that you offered you. a lot of this is by design.

we now are seeking your further detail the comments that we're seeking. once we have all of your comments, we will thoroughly review them and then issue a final notice implementation later this spring.

before going into the details of the initial notice, let me underscore a few givens in the rad authority. that is, what congress said we have to do, and no volume or eloquence of your comments will be able to change that. first a

environment, congress judged that rad could only be piloted on a no-cost basis. basically this means that when rental assistance is converted from one type of assistance, for example, section 9 operating and capital funding for public there can be no increase in the

amount of that assistance when it's converted. obviously this affects initial rent levels and how rents can be adjusted, and we'll address that more today. second, congress also decided, partly a that there should be a 60,000

unit cap on the number of public housing and mod rehab units that could be converted under the competitive or the first component of the bill. but congress also allowed in a second component of t mod rehab rent sup and rad properties to project based

assistance in certain circumstances on a noncompetitive noncap basis. the variations allowed under the first and the second components of the bill make rad a bit we'll walk through today some of those complexities, and in subsequently webcasts this he

can would, we'll go into considerably more detail for each of the sections of the initial notice. be able to submit your questions to us via e-mail. the e-mail address to submit those questions to us is up on our white board today.

please send them to rad at hud.gov. another said by way of background. let's get into the notice. so let me hand this off to greg burn, who will give us an overview of what we're proposing in the initial notice.

greg. >> what i want to do is go to the white board here and see i can demystify a little bit this sort of 130-odd page notice. so the notice is rad notice phi 2018, the official rad number, although it's jointly issued by

the office of the office of housing. and this conversion authority, which the 2012 appropriation bill gave us, there are three sets of property types, public housing, which we call section 1 of the notice, mod rehab, which is in section 2, and rent

rap on section 3. what we try to do is make each section sort of stand on its own so you don't have to keep referring back to different sections if you're in mod rehab and whatnot. so i'm going to start here with section 1, which is public

housing, and down here these boxes, pbra, pbv and tpv's to pbv's. so pbra, what we really mean there is the ability to convert to traditional multifamily housing, the office of housing, whereas pbv is the project based voucher

program, which is the component of a housing authority's voucher program where today they can convert 20% of their vouchers or take 20% of their vouchers and attach them to buildings. so for public housing authorities, what they have is

the ability to choose between pbra and pbv, but there are a few conditions here, and those conditions are first and foremost that the congress only gave us the authority to 60,000 units under this first component of the demonstration. congress also said it has to be

done through a competition, and we'll talk more about the nature of that competition as we go along. another sort of real defining element of this first component of the demonstration is that it has to be done at current funding.

okay. 60,000 units competition currently funding, sort of three things that characterize really demonstration for public housing. mod rehab also has the ability to convert under this first component of the demonstration,

which they convert to pbra or pbv, in which they also are cap, also subject to competition and based on current funding. i want to move now over to rent supp/rap for a moment. rather than being able to choose assistance or project based vouchers, it's a much more

limited demonstration, and it really just gives the authority for these owners for rent supp and rap projects at contract certainly nation or that a rent sup rap owner, rather than using the tenant protect vouchers or tbv's, which would normally be given to

tenants of the property, that the owner has the right to convert those tenant project vouchers to project based section 8 voucher program. under this, compared to the first component of the demonstration, there is no competition.

so there is no competition. there is no units that can convert either, and the congress gave us the authority really through 2013 in which to sort of do this second and there is both a authority, which is the properties they're converting

between now and the end of 2013, but they also gave us retroactive authority back through october of 2006, and when margaret speaks about the rent su p go into more details about that. that's the demonstration, three sort of classes of property,

public housing properties being able to convert to project based rental assistance or project based vouchers but subject to the 60,000 cap competition, no more than current funding. rent sup rap, just purely being able to take the tenant protection vouchers and convert

them to project based vouchers, no cap, no competition, mod sides. it can either sort of be subject to the competition and go the same way as public housing, or it also has the develop to convert to tpv's and project based vouchers.

one last thing, pat, before i sort in terms of -- we mentioned that the notice is organized section 1, section 2, and section 3, that for public housing and mod rehab, the notice is proposed. expires april 9th, 2012, and that these are all proposed,

everything for public housing and mod rehab, whether mod rehab is moving in this direction or this direction, but rent sup rap, it's effective immediately. we call it sort of inter authority. that one we really wanted to do because these properties have no

sort of really new renewal option, for those expiring now, we wanted the ability to be able to convert, if that's what they want to do, their tpv's to comments, and after we review the comments, we may make changes. >> graying overview, greg.

thanks a lot. now i'd like to ask margaret salazar to help walk us through in a bit more detail rent supp and rap program will actually work. one of the main goals of rad, margaret, as we all know, is to generate financing for rent sup

and rap projects. why doesn't that work now? what's the problem and w rad to differently to help us raise additional capital? >> thanks. happy to talk about that. as we mentioned recently, rent sup and rap properties are

unique. the contracts are expiring, and unlike section 8 contracts, hud does not have the authorit renew them. so when the contract expires, that's it. there is no ability to renew it. so hud originally sought

authored under rad to convert those rent sup and rap contracts to section 8. rad doesn't quite allow us to do another tool. under rad, owners can convert the properties to project based voucher contracts with 15-year terms.

the assistance will be tied to the project, which means the owner will be able to leverage that project based voucher cont equity financing into the property to make repairs and maintain the project of the affordable housing.

>> great. margaret, another goal of rad is to give residents more choice in where they live. how will that work as we convert rent sup under rad. >> the project will be covered by a project based voucher

project as we said. the project based vouch every rules will be in place. what that means is that a resident in a project based voucher unit will have the ability to move after one year and will be next available tenant voucher

from the pha. >> greg. >> so let's talk a minute about how the rent sup or the rap owner can pursue a conversion to pdv's project based voucher under there is both as prospective and retroactive eligibility for

doing this; is that correct? >> that's right. i'll talk a little by about prospective first. if the contract has not yet expired or terminated, rad considered that to be a prospective conversion. contract is essentially provided

in lieu of the tenant protection vouchers that would otherwise be provided to the residents of the rent supp and rap units of the property, when the contract expires or terminates. how this works is that submits the request directly to the multifamily field office.

the request must be submitted at least 60 days prior to the expiration or termination date of the rent supp or rap contract to provide time to review it. section 3 of the rad notice provides detail on what the owner actually submits with that request.

i won't go into that today, but what i do want to talk about is the process. so the owner develops the application following -- excuse me, the request following the guidance in the rad notice. as part of that, the provide tenant notification and

a 30 day tenant comment period. tenants are provided a briefing by the owner with the multifamily and the public housing field office staff owner present. when that is complete, the owner submits the application to the office 60 days prior to contract

expiration or termination. the multifamily hub satisfy reviews the owner's request. if it meets the requirement of the notice, office informs the public housing field office director that it, in fact, meets the terms of the notice.

then the public housing field office selects a pha to administer the contract. now, per the rad statute, the pha has the opportunity to consent to actually e into that pbv contract with the owner. and if the pha does not consent,

office will actually seek an alternative pha to administer the contract. so at that point, then the pha actually e and enters into the contract with the owner. >> so that's the prospective component.

>> right. >> as you also mentioned, there is a retroactive component. can you explain how that works, how it's different? >> sure. there are a couple of main differences here. rad does provide the authority

sup or rap projects where the contracts have already expired or terminated, ask that's only for fiscal year 2 006 and later. here again, the tenant protection vouchers have already been issued to residents in those properties. we're calling this a

conversion. the vouchers that have already been issued and are being utilized by families in the property will convert. two main differences i wanted to might today for folks. the first main difference here is that the owner applies

directly to the administering the vouchers of the property. they actually don't make an application to hud at that point. the second main difference between retroactive and prospective is that for

retroactive tenant consent is required. so i mentioned for prospective conversions there is a tenant notification, period and a tenant briefing, but retroactive conversions, in those cases only the households that con isn't in writing to

convert their tenant vouchers to project based vouchers will have that assistance converted to the >> okay. thanks for that margaret. let's shift gears now for a minute and ask diane thompson to talk with us a bit about mod rehab, which has multiple

options under the bill. so diane, could you help us understand those options? >> sure, sure. well, pat, fir just a few differences between mod rehab and rent supp and rap that margaret just described under the second component of

the bill. there are really just three. first off, the section dealing with the mod rehab under the second component is proposed, so the public will have an opportunity to comment, unlike rent sup and rap which is effective immediately.

owners of mod rep has been projects, they had the opportunity to renew their contracts annually for one year. the second major difference is that mod rehab owners will be required to submit a financing plan. mod rehab projects underwent a

moderate level of rehabilitation some 15 to 30 years ago, so we recognize that these projects may be so we are requiring that the owner submit the financing plan to demonstrate that the project will be sustained both physically and financially for

the term of the contract. and basically just to insure that it's viable for long-term and the third important difference is that the mod rehab owner is going to submit the request to the currently administering pha, and they'll submit that request 120 days

prior to the expiration of the contract for both retroactive and prospective the pha has to consent, and once the pha does, the owner would submit that ab indication to hud headquarters. can you talk a little bit more how the mod rehab program, the

conversions will work under the first particular, how is it different from the way that public housing will be converted? we're going to talk about that in a minute. actually the process is going to be very similar as greg described.

there will be a competition. owners are are going to be able to choose or pbv's and rents, they will be based on the current funding left, as greg described, and also there are certain provisions for public housing that are unique just to the

public housing category. for example, use agreements, grievance procedures. those things would not apply to mod rehab owners. great. still under the first component demonstration where mod rehab converts at current funding.

what will be the contract term? >> great question. for project based rental assistance contracts, the current -- i'm sorry, the contract term will be for 20 years initially. for project based voucher contracts, the initial term will

be for 15 years with the option five-year initial term, so the total term could possibly be for project based voucher conversions, 20 years upon the consent of the pha. >> so you've talked a little bit about rent setting. how do rent increases or

adjustment contract terms? >> well, under the first component, as i indicated, it's going to be at current funding, the rent setting. however, the increases will be performed through an operating cost adjustment factor for both

project based rental assistance contracts as well as fo based voucher contracts, and the demonstration, the requirement for rent increases will be consistent with the project based voucher program and rules. so basically the owner would

request a rent increase from the pha on its anniversary dat the rent may be increased by the pha up to 110% of the fmr limited by resources, of course. >> overview, let's leave mod rehab for now, and greg, i'd like to turn it back o you.

if you could walk us back through how the first section of the bill on public housing, how those public housing conversions would actually work. >> sure, pat. so under the first component of the demonstration, again, subject to 60,000 cap, actually

the 60,000 units we're reserve about 58,750 for public housing conversions and about 1250 for mod rehappen conversions, and those are sort of representative of those sizes of those two portfolios. a pha will apply. we

go into probably at the next webinar, not this one, and pha's will submit an application and the application will require them to sort of walk through the basics of pro forma, what are they g current rents and what are their operating costs and how might

they -- if they need to raise debt, can they raise adequate debt. after we review applications, those that get awarded based on the selection factors will issue to chap, commitment to enter into a housing assistant payment

project. and from there, they will have about 6 months to come back to us with a firm financing plan. once wes review the financing plan for feasibility and hap, and it will be converted. >> where would a public housing authority go to get innocencing,

be -- financing, be it debt or equity. >> we'll go to all the sources that anybody with af housing production these days goes. if they're seeking financing, very likely they will look to fha insurance.

if it's a lightly rehab'd job, it's probably the fha 223 f program. if it's more heavy construction, they might do 221 d but some pha's may not see a need to do fha financing. they may found -- find something local or have a relationship

with a bank in town they've been dealing with over the years. they may also find other grant sources, othe they may also choose to sort of go after the low income housing tax credit program. they can either going to the competitive credit for 9% or the

noncompetitive with taxes and financing for 4%. then in addition to all of those sources, any of which is permissible. we don't prescribe any particular one. but we do prescribe that it has to be fixed rate -pbs --

financing for one. the term of the mortgage cannot be longer than 40 years, because we want something sort of con we can't be any balloon payments that plight be due during the term of the contract. we just don't want to put any

sort of undue risk on the property. and i guess maybe the last comment to make is that pha's, when they're sort of their project and looking at how much the project can support in first mortgage financing, if the project itself add current

funding -- let's say the property needs 25,000 per unit in rehab, but the first board can only support 20,000 in rehab. the pha could look to reserves or funding program and bring over any of those sources necessary.

>> so it would be very common to other affordable housing projects where basically there is likely the gap is going to have to be solved through the creative financing. really every project will be different.

some the current funding might be just right in the zone, and other cases they'll need to sort of get a little haircut, and other places, leap. >> financing sources, renters and investors are always interested in who owns and who

manages the project. now, how is that going to work under the public housing portion of the bill? >> so under public house, at conversion, the proper stay in either public or nonprofit hands, so the pha can either own it outright as its

own, so as the pha, it might decide to create a nonprofit if that's what it wanted to do, and it cannot -- initial conversion cannot be transferred to any sort of with one exception, and that is if the pha needs to come out and get low income housing tax

credits, that's a requirement of the program. if order to raise credits, you need a for-profit ownership bed bo. that's that conversion. are provisions if there where -- for which we don't expect many instances for it to occur, but

if there is a foreclosure or default or bankruptcy, any of those sort of did he veer, unusual first options are to try to find another public body and then, if not, a nonprofit, and then it can go into normal for-profit body.

so let's talk a minute now about so diane talked about pbv, providence of public housing, and the pha's will continue to play their role in the vouchers. what happens and they convert to who oversees that at hud. >> when it converts to pbra, and i'm a pha or a mod rehas been

owner, i as a pha, my property leaves the public housi it will no longer be are the pa of the public housing program, and it will be administered by hud's office of housing. another 1 to 1.5 million students through long-term assistance contracts.

the office of housing is that the day to day hap administration is performed by performance based contract administrators pbca's. they will do all of those duties, bulb if a pha decides to convert to pbv's, then that project still

remains in the voucher program, and it's still, we would say, within the one last provision that i know that everyone has had a lot of interest in, a lot of questions, how the choice mobility component that we're offering remember debts will work under

the first component of the bill relating to public housing and also to mod rehab. can you walk us th choice mobility can work for residents? i think i'm going to go to that diagram or the white board to help us out.

here we have choice mobility and the rules are different whether you convert under the first component of the bill excuse me, whether you convert from either part of the bill from pbv or pbra. if i convert my property, whether i'm pha or mod property

owner, and i couldn't verdict to pli, which means after one year, the residents, if they want to move with a voucher, then they get really the first -- they get the opportunity for the first available v agency's voucher turnover list. so go to pbv.

under the demonstration, no different than the standard rules for the pbv program. residents get to move after one year subject to the availability of vouchers in that program. there are a few more bells whistles without going into much greater detail.

under pbra, if i'm a housing authority and i convert my public house, remember, the only two under demonstration that can convert to pbra housing and mod rehappen, because rent sup rap only goes to bpv. to bpra, what's difference is,

rather than one year, proposal says the residents would get two years or the latter of two years or if it takes the initial repairs, the construction after conversion, so it's two years for there. there's also a 20% project cap. so the ph

wants to limit the amount of turnover from the choice mobility, it can say no more than 20% annually of that project would be subject to choice mobility. >> i'll stop you on that. all of the residents are eligible, but you're just

talking about turnover in any there could be other reasons for people leaving the property, but just those leaving to take advantage of choice mobility, the housing authority could put a 20% cap. the thousandsing authority could also decide

authority could also decide that -- they could establish a one third sort of inventory cap of its whole voucher program. it could decide that not more than a third of the voucher turnover would be used for rad pbra conversions. and so those are some of the

three major things, but then also there is an exemption, and the department reserves the awards under the demonstration to those that would be exempt from the choice mobility pha would ask for that in its application, or mod rehab would ask for that in the application.

in order to either is an agency without any vouchers, or it would be an agency that already uses a third of its vouchers for the homeless or vets it certified it would be providing. those exemptions would be awarded through the competition

ess with ranking factors overall, that those with the highest ranking factors would receive the exemption. >> let's end the formal presentation for now and get ready to take that's a gentle reminder to

everybody tuning in today that if you haven't got your questions, please submit them by e-mail to rad at hud dot gov. while we're waiting for the questions to come in and logging them in, let me just take a minute to webcast that we'll be doing

really the rest of this week. as we said, we want to go into more detail on public housing and mod rehab, section 1 for public housing, section 2 for mod rehab, rent supp and rap. the first section, 1, public housing webcast, is scheduled

for march 15th at 3 p.m. eastern time. the second section webcast for day, march 16th at 2 p.m. eastern time, and then the third section on rent sup and rap, and you'll be seeing more margaret for that, diane for mod rehab, greg for public housing.

the webcast will be also on march 16th; and we'll that right after the mod rehappen. you can find the updated schedule of all of these webcasts on our website, www dot hud dot gov, slash, forward slash rad. further, you can send queries

but not official comments that the specifics on how to do that are detailed in the notice, but if you have just general questions about anything, please feel free to submit them by e-mail, also to rad at hut of hud dot gov now let's take some questions

that we've gotten from those who have joined in today's webcast. let's see. here we have one, greg, that probably looks best for you. can you confirm that under rad could be used for capital upgrades in conjunction with traditional financing and how

that would work? it was a great question. >> so again, every pha will apply project by project, and if it runs its feasibility review and finds out that the first mortgage is not going to be enough to meet the needs, then it can use existing

public housing program funds, and that's public housing capital funds, whether it's the traditional capital fund program or repl funds, but it also could use any operating reserves that it has. and the p ha -- so those are all permitted uses.

normally you wouldn't be allowed to use public housing funds for something that is essentia subject will program. section 8 program. what they would do is put that in their financing plan. we mentioned earlier they apply, they're selected, they sign a

contract that says over a back with a financing plan, and it's when they present their financing plan back to us and it says, here are my sources of funds and my uses of funds and one of those sources, you'd identifying early on that i need to go into reserves to help

support the conversion of t so yeah, we definitely want to facilitate the ability of these projects to convert. >> let's stay on financing theme for a minute, because this is the sort of major purpose, is to secure this kind of financing to be able to address the capital

backlog. we talked about the different places you could go. one of the things we mentioned was fha. margaret, that's sort of your division, maybe you can help out with this question. what fha products do we

investigation might work for rad? thinking about? do we need a new product or do we think some existing products are going to work well enough? >> it's a great question, one we've been thinking about quite a bit here at hud, fha financing

and how folks might be able to utilize it for these conversions. greg mentioned a couple of programs that i wanted to highlight and just under score again. so section 223 f program is kind of our bread and butter program

here at hud for refinancing. you can either use it for acquisition, refinance or a and that's something that our field offices know very well. borrowers would work with an fha approved lender, and you would approach your local hu to discuss your into in pursuing

a loan. the other program is the section 221 d-4 program, which is a program that's used for either new construction or substantial rehab, and so obviously the substantial rehab co would probably be a good fit for rad, as well.

it's the same kind of a process where a pha or owner would find a map approved lender and would work with their local hud office to make application for a loan. >> so one of the things we may also a webinar on just fha products for rad, and we can sort of spend more time on that.

but maybe if you could just explain the benefit of, say, the 223 f, sort of why that's a in terms of sort of one loan as opposed to two loans. >> the 223 f program is sort of our bread and butter program. about 75% of the loans that we do through fha

it's not construction and permanent debt. it's just a fully funding loan, and so you can do what we call a direct to firm application, where you just submit one application for a firm commitment, and then the processing is done, like i said,

at the local and there is a moderate level of repair work that's allowed, whereas a 221 d 4 is little bit lengthier process because we drop require preapplication, and then an application. the 221 d 4, i don't want to say it's a disadvantage, because

when you compare it to the other financing sources out there, what's great about the 221 d 4 is that we sort of call it one-stop shopping. it's your construction and your permanent dead all in one, and it's up to a 40 year term, so product for folks.

>> there is a follow on question about this. when we think about fha projects, we think about housing finance agencies. they do a risk share program. will the risk share program be something that can work for a conversion?

maybe you can talk about tax exempt bonds and how that works for a minute. >> we have the risk share program under section 542 c. that might not be familiar with folks, but it is a very popular ub in of -- number of hfa's. they should meet with their

local hfa's and discuss it, find a little more out underwriting process works. they delegate most of the review to the partners. >> greg, it looks like we have a follow on the first question about the use of public housing capital funds.

interesting question. public housing capital funds are really restricted to public about converting public housing to actually section 8 housing. so six 9 -- section 9 to section 8. how can it be that we can use public housing capital funds in

a ra >> normally it would be a big no-no. you wouldn't be allowed to use the public housing funds but anything for the public housing here, the 2012 appropriation act gave us enormous broad waver

authority for allow for these conversions, and that's one of the authorities we're going to use, which is to say, to facilitate the movement of this project from hubble housing over to the long-term section 8. that's the pha can take --

unobligated, funds monies, if that decides where it wants to spend it and use it towards the conversion, one thing we'll do is just ask you to put that in your financing plan. here disclose, this is what i'm doing it.

once you convert, then you won't be able to go back to the well. so the financing plan so we can review it and see it, and then it is approved. very helpful. let's stay on the public housing side of this for a minute.

a up canel questions have come in. one has to do with, this is voluntary, so on the part of completely voluntary. there will be an application process, and hud will have a role, but doesn't the public housing authority itself have a

role in sort of assessing what's the best project to submit and how will that work? because we asked, you know, first, 2012, we asked for 200 million for the conversion under rad and the asked for sort of other authorities, and that -- we realize that with no

current -- with no not every project is going to make it. not every project is an ideal candidate for rad. and so what we would expect most housing authorities to do as they've been doing over the past five or ten years is looking

across their assessing, what is it i get for funding? what is my capital fund formula grant specific to this project and what are my tenant rents to this project? thinks about that, of as, okay by the way, soon we'll post on

the rad website for pha's so that those calculations, that what we know to be, their current capital fund allocation for that project, their operating fund and tenant ren to come up with what that funding will be. we fully expect the pha's will

look to the portfolio and say these are properties more easy to convert, these are take more effort. the last group, i really can only do these if i bring in some outside funding, either grant funding or for larger tax credits.

there are a couple more questions that have come in related to public housing. let's take a few more there, and then there are some that are starting to come in on mod rehab and rent sup. let's sta again, we'll have an opportunity

this coming thursday to dig in more into section 1 of the public housing section of the bill, so we would urge folks that want to participate in that to think about their questions ahead of time and begin to submit them. >> we will spend more time at

application procedure and the selection process and the milestones and sort of all of that. we'll definitely get more chances to drill down later in the week. >> here is a very common question that comes in related

to public housing all the time, and it's >> so there's no additional funding associated with public housing conversions or rad really in general? so what's the advantage for a public housing authority thinking about this, if there is

no additional funding. why would a housing authority, developme about converting its acc into a section 8 contract, be it be pbv or pbr funding? >> the main advantage is to for them to go out and access under the public housing

program, it's so difficult to approach a lender and say, hey, i have this property. i'm looking for a 30-year loan because i have 20,000 unit and rehab to do, and the lender asks, well, what's collateral? what's your pledge of how you're

going to pay this back. while we have some ability of pha's to do some of the mixed finance public housing, it's very difficult relative to it's a much more it let's lenders know the section 8 program very well. we don't have the equivalent in

public housing of long-term contract. we have a contract that is really subject to not just annual appropriations but a lender can't be sure what the terms a so section 8, it's a more readily understood platform, and

the fact that they'll be signing a 20 year contract with sort of built in operating costs adjustment factors makes it far more attractive to someone to the lending product or feasibility than the public housing program. >> just to follow on that, and

this goes to a question about rents that we talked a little bit about that. so at current funding, convert from acc to a section 8 contract, and we know that section 8 program is really oriented to market based rents in that platform and i think as

much as we can in, say, the mixed financial program, is to get rents for affordable housing relative to market. so currently funding. how do we know that this program will be able to to, frankly, the comparable market rents that housing

authorities and owners are facing out there? just because of the way that the legislation is constructed by not providing additional funding for it, that you are -- you' market rents, if your market is higher. have you to look at your current

have you to decide whether, when i talk up my tenant results, operating eligibility for this project and capital allocation, what can i do with that in for a moment -- for a moment, assume the tenant rents and operating is going to pay for the operating costs.

those two of the three pieces of the pie covering operating. what's my capital fund grant for this project, and to what extent am i buying sort of defendant service by sort of converting around the country, on the order the capital fund grant $1,450 per unit per month,

again, this is back of the nfl, as you say. i've got my operating subsidies operating my operating costs. how much will i be able with my capital fund grant to go out and rather than getting a grant that's payi repairs in a year, i'm going to

use that to leverage for a long-term mortgage, and every $150 in debt service raises about 25,000 in today's market. >> and there should be, if it operating, funding and capital funding, and there is a tenant rent contribution that factors into this, there should be some

margin in there to be able to direct replacement reserves over time s that with -- is that we review the financing plan. we want to make sure that not only are you taking care of your existing capital needs if there is a 100 unit property, may have 3 or 4 million of existing

needs, but what are the needs over the next five, ten, 15, 20 years, and so the pha 20 years and size a replacement reserve to sort of fit those needs. ultimately the pha has to look at its current funding, operating capital, tenant rents,

what ever other sources it need project is both meeting the -- going out and meeting existing needs but also the long-term needs through the buildup of replacements in the account. >> one last question on public house, which actually sort of transitions to the question

about multipae it's an important question. i'm a resident of public housing now. my housing authority, and presumably i've had some role in saying this might make sense to convert, et cetera. let's assume that happens.

when i live in th it's converted, i have a set of rights and procedures and responsibility as a resident of public housing. how will that work when we convert really from the section 9 platform, if you will, to section 8, project based

assistance. margaret, you familiar. diane, you know both sides of this, so maybe either of the two of you could help with that question. >> so under the conversion of public housing to pbra

contrac rights that are currently in place for public housing will carry over into the new contracts, which is something that's unique for those public housing residents. that was something that was in the rad language and we think

it's an that's carried over in the >> and in addition to those procedural rights, we also have sort of important tenant consultation, requirements fo converting through the demonstration so that we've got input from the residents through

>> margaret, here is a specific i think it's for you that's come in, and that is, my rap contract expired last year, and my residents were issued most of them have chosen to stay in the project. is my project eligible under rad even though i don't have a wrap

contract on the project right now? saturdays like the retrospective -- i'm sorry. as we mentioned, for this section 3 of rad, which is rent sup and rap, as well as from mod rehab, there are provisions for

retroactive what's nice about that, it also means the owner doesn't have to kind of race against the clock to try to get an application or request in for the cop version before -- conversion before the contract expires. this takes time, all of this

that we've discussed. you can pursue in retroactive. so only have tenant protection vouchers that were provided when the contract expired or terminated, it's only those households that are eligible to have their system converted, and the

households have to still be in place at the property. so residents receive vouchers, but only five of those families are still residing in the property, it's only those five families that would have their assistance potentially converted.

and again, it's only families that provide written consent to the conversion. that was a question specifically about rap. but that also applies to mod is that create, as well, the whole restroe active and the prospective?

we went -- retroactive and prospective. we went through this. in the second bill, as we call it, we have this retroactive and prospective that provide to both rents and mod rehab. >> yes.

the owner will have the ability to request the conversion for contracts that expire, either the initial contract or renewly contract that expired in 2006 up until the time of this and they will be able to convert those vouchers it he property to assistance, again as margaret

said, provided that the families consent to the conversion. >> and th question i think applies again to you diane, and greg mentioned this. let's go back over this again, and that is, i thought the requires that not more than 25%

of the units in a building be assisted. is that going to prevent my mod rehas been or i guess also under rents up? >> that's a great question. actually we will go into a lot more detail on subsequent webinars this week, however,

just to answer the question, we have certain waiver authority component of rad, and one of those things is to allow for a different income mixing standard or to weight it completely, and hud has decided that it was important to preserve certain provisions of the pbb program

but also to insure that rad is go reserving these projects. one thing we've done is we've allowed for the income mixing requirement to be set at 50% rather than 25%. so 50% of the units will be able to be project based, and the

regular exceptions under the project based vouche will apply, which may allow in order to go to up to 100% of assisted units under the pwropblg -- project based voucher program. that's helpful. it looks like we have just a few

more minutes. looks like time for maybe two more questions. here is one about choice mobility. let's go back to this for a minute. question is this, when a resident exercises his or her

choice mobility or right to move option, does the subsidy remain on the property or leave with the resident and his or her family? how does that work? who wants to take >> the subsidy will remain on the project.

it is a project based subsidy, so as this family exercises its right to move, the housing authority would issue that family denent based assistance to do so, and the project based voucher assistance would continue. the unit would remain under the

actually that is the last question that we've had posted from our participants today. so what we'd like to do is just wrap it up. i'd like to thank greg and diane and margaret for helping and i want to remind those of you that are participating in

the webcast today that this webcast will be archived and posted on www.hud.gov/rad. so without any further questions, we'll wrap up webcast and encourage you to tune in to the next webcast or actual multiple webcasts that we have on public housing on mod

rehab and on rent supp and rap. thank you very much. captioning provided by

Tuesday, April 4, 2017

rent apartment ct


i knew something was fishy. listen, mister. you jumped in front of my car, right? you sure you're not a blackmailer? how dare you? no! ujin, a doctor shouldn't resort to violence. fine. go ahead. go ahead. i thought doctors healed people,

but i guess they beat people up too. - go ahead. / - you'd better be quiet. don't, ujin. don't do it. ow, my back. are you okay, dad? my back. dr. lee, get mr. jeong manjae prepped for a ct. yes, doctor.

ms. kim, prepare for a urine test, blood test, and x-ray, please. i'm fine. i don't need anything done. yes, you do. the police will handle the legalities, so please leave. if the medical report is not legit, i won't let you off easily. what a pain.

hey, you! - hey! / - you need to lie still. how do you expect me to just lie here? why are you here? this isn't the university hospital. i left that place. you quit? why? just because.

what are you talking about? we spent a fortune sending you to med school, and you just quit? it's my life, dad. i make my own decisions. you good-for-nothing... how can you say that? what about the fellowship? i threw in the towel.

what? but... did you do something wrong? did you mess up another surgery? is that why you got sacked? i chose to quit. what kind of craziness is this? we were all waiting for you to become a fellow. how could you give up without telling us?

this is a hospital, dad. that's enough. fine. okay. we'll talk at home. i'm going. - ow, my back. / - you can't go home today. you need to get a cat scan for a diagnosis. your grandfather... i couldn't afford to take him to the hospital.

i can't just sit around for a cat scan. don't make me feel any worse. give me a break. i feel much worse than you right now. your insurance will cover all the bills. this won't cost you anything, so stop being stubborn. understood? what do we tell your mother?

i'll talk to her. we're ready, dr. jeong. i don't want any scans or tests. stop acting like a child. you're a patient, and i'm a doctor. - please take him. / - yes, doctor. there's no need for this. there's no need for this, ujin. hey!

i don't need this. this is unnecessary. ujin. what a surprise, ujin. don't be alarmed, mom. dad's hurt. what happened? he got hit by a car, but it's not serious.

just come to the hospital. oh, my goodness. it must be serious if he was taken to your university hospital, no? not the university hospital. come to seorim. seorim hospital? the hospital on the main road near our house? yes.

okay. i'll be right there. what in the world... oh, my goodness, dear. dear! manjae. manjae. what happened to you? you were perfectly fine when you left home this morning. hi. it was just a minor car accident.

who was the driver that did this to you? who's the bastard? don't make a scene. where's ujin? he called to let me know you were here. did he go back to his workplace? oh, um... he went that way... are you family?

is he okay? we just finished the tests, so you'll find out soon. okay. what you brought in smells fishy. oh, this? it's pollack. what did you just call me? why do you have to bring that up again?

i said, pollack. you can't bring something like this into the er. what am i supposed to do though? this is our dinner. you can't keep it in here. it needs to be removed, ma'am. where am i supposed to put this? ma'am. i'm going to leave this with someone.

hurry up and go. good grief. what am i going to do with this? i can't throw it out. - mom. / - hi, ujin. dad's in the er. you should go in and see him. i was just there. why are you in a doctor's gown in here? i work here.

you work here? you work at the university hospital. i work here now. here. it's nice and cold. did you get fired from the university hospital? i quit. tell me the truth. did you do something wrong there? did you mess up a surgery?

no, it's nothing like that. then why did you quit? i've waited on you to become a fellow. how can you do this to me? fellows aren't the only doctors around. children only cause grief. not even one of my children is successful. good heavens.

stay with dad. i'll come by after my rounds. i don't believe this. how could he...? is someone gravely ill? don't be so dejected, ma'am. that doctor may seem a bit rude, but he's very talented. who are you?

i'm a cook at the cafeteria here. about that doctor... does he have a bad reputation here? people do say he's bit of a jerk, but... a jerk? but don't worry. he's a very good doctor. and yet... i know it's tough, but i'm sure it'll be okay.

this is a good hospital. a good hospital? yes. you can take my word for it. who cares if it's a good hospital? my son's meant to be a professor. so your son was on track to become a professor. i really hope he gets better. and i'm sure he'll become a professor. have you had lunch?

why do you ask? you need to eat well to take care of him. come have lunch at the cafeteria. everyone likes our food. i don't have an appetite. in any case, thank you for your concern. huh? this... isn't this yours, ma'am?

i'm so out of it. they said i couldn't bring it into the er. could you hold on to it for me? sure. i'll keep it in the fridge. you can come pick it up later. okay. thank you. you should come and eat, too. good grief.

but i'm fine. your doctor has to authorize your discharge. i don't need anyone's permission to leave. what's wrong? go and get my discharge processed. you need to get treated, or we won't get any insurance coverage. is insurance coverage that important to you? you lie down here then,

if money's so important. i'm not the one who's hurt. i can't even afford medical care for my father, so how can i just lie here? i'm leaving. manjae. manjae. manjae. manjae. dad! let go.

i'm going home. you can't. you have to stay here for the day. let him go. i don't want to stay here any longer either. mom. look at me... i went through so much for him, but he couldn't even get a fellowship.

he says the new hospital pays well. money isn't the issue. ujin's meant to be a professor. you always say money comes first. don't make this worse for me. don't tell my parents. i don't want them worrying over nothing. how is this nothing? he lost his chance at becoming a professor.

i'm talking about my accident. what a devoted son you are. and yet you didn't want to pay for your father's hospital bills, so you made me take the blame. mother thinks i was behind the whole thing. geez. stop nagging me. i'm not well.

nor am i. my heart's broken to pieces. keep it down, will you? - good heavens. / - i'm sorry. oh? she's not here. did they take his son up? what are you doing here? the lady who came to the er earlier asked me to hold on to her groceries for her, but she hasn't come to pick them up.

ow. groceries? you were talking with her in the waiting area. has her son been hospitalized? she said he was on track to become a professor. i know her, so give me that. how can i trust you? she asked me to hold on to it for her. then just throw it out.

what's wrong with you? who are you to tell me what to do? i'm a doctor at this hospital. i belong here more than you do. if you see her again, please let her know i have her groceries. good day, doctor. it's been ages since she left to get groceries. aren't we having dinner?

not yet. suja's not back yet with the dinner groceries. i need to take my medication at set times. when will i get to eat and take my medication? so what if dinner's a bit late? you have more than enough time on your hands. ever since i started going out to sea, breakfast has been at 7:00 a.m.,

lunch at noon, and dinner at 6:00 p.m.. don't you know that? yes, yes. good job not skipping a single meal. i was so busy raising our kids, that i often forgot to eat. are you sure that's why you were so busy? i heard something about the twist and the crab. that's...

oh, my goodness, suja. what took you so long? did you two meet up outside? yes. something came up. i see. but why are you empty-handed? you said you were getting pollack. did someone say sack? oh, no. my groceries.

look at you. your father-in-law said he wanted pollack, and you come home empty-handed. pollack is the least of my worries right now. stop talking about pollack! why are you yelling at her? ow, ow. i need to go lie down. is something wrong? - i'm fine. / - manjae.

were they out of pollack at the market? i'll just make soybean paste soup. asking you to do anything for us is like pulling teeth. why should i feel bad when it's my son who's working hard to put food on the table? when did i make you feel bad? you make it seem like it's such an ordeal when all we wanted was pollack for dinner.

i'm upset too, mother. i might lose it if you keep nagging me. are you threatening your mother-in-law? i could really use someone to vent myself. aeran, you're the only one i can rely on. my goodness. aeran... when father was still a sea captain, you were bored and lonely, so you turned to this.

there was something to it. something is suspect... what are you scheming now? do you know about mother's dark past? my mom's dark past? did mother go out dancing with other men? are you out to tarnish our family's reputation? let me finish. that's not it.

when i was at your parents' today, suja said mother got lonely during father's absence, and resorted to this. that's what suja said. mother suddenly went pale, and started stuttering. suja should be more careful about what she says.

my mom devoted herself to raising us. she's not like you. that's right. i don't have the children to devote myself to. is that what you wanted to point out? hey... women... instead of speaking ill about your in-laws, find out if something's up with manjae.

what about manjae? he came by my office this afternoon, and something wasn't right. what do you mean? maybe something happened at work. at work? did he get fired? why would manjae get fired? but with voluntary retirement and all...

i was just wondering. okay. i'll find out. be tactful. we don't want to hurt anyone's feelings. i'm not an idiot. - yunchan. / - oh, my goodness. you startled me. where are you coming from? the store.

subin said she wanted a popsicle. is mom still up? she went to bed before i left for the store. - really? / - yes. why didn't you call me then? i'm so thirsty. give me one of those. how much did you siphon off anyway? just chump change.

must be a big lump of chump change. go easy on that thing. you'll wake mom up. - she's asleep. / - dad? yes, it's me. come sit down. here's your popsicle, subin. you'll pay for this, taejin. come and sit down. mom,

i must've lost focus again. cut me some slack. you were okay for a while. why don't you and subin go upstairs? so you feel ashamed in front of your niece? put the remaining popsicles in the freezer. yes, dad. how much did you take this time? don't leave out a single penny.

the rent there is paltry. won't i be inheriting that building anyway? it'll be mine eventually, so consider it inheritance tax. what did you just say? how is that entire building yours? you're right, yunjeong. you're a lawful heir, too. mom, you need to make this clear.

otherwise, who knows what yunchan will do? what's the matter with you, yunjeong? i want the passbooks for all our rent accounts. if you leave out even a single one, you'll be removed from the family register. dad, how are you feeling? i'm fine. we got the ct result.

your backbone is fine. there's just a little muscle damage. see? i told you it wasn't a big deal. you should still take a few sick days. i brought the medical report. and here's your medication. can't you return to the university hospital? that's all said and done. making you a professor is what i've lived for.

how can you crush my dream? is that so important to you? yes, it is. it's all i care about. why can't i be proud and happy? why can't i have a husband who is an executive and a son who's a professor? fine. i'll become a professor. you mean that, right?

you can return to the university hospital? i'll do it. i'll go back there, so please take time off work and get treated. oh, right. i do think i should take a few days off, but... you should've stayed at the hospital then. it's tough enough having to take care of father. that's right. i don't even deserve to be ill.

please don't talk like that. you need to rest if you're unwell. why make things worse than need be? that wasn't my intention... you're sure you can go back, right? yes. what did i tell you? no one can be a better professor than you. you must be tired. go and unwind. don't go to work tomorrow, dad.

good night. it's not easy returning once you leave. same goes for regular companies. he says he's going back. don't jinx it. i do think i should at least take tomorrow off. i feel much better now. should i go to work or not? there's water.

take the meds ujin got you and go to sleep. ow, my legs. i walked around so much i got blisters. did you just get in? ujin, i saw dozens of studios today, but the rent is crazy. do you really need a studio in gangnam?

enough with your rooftop apartment talk unless you're going to help me financially. you're coming to our vip party next week, right? i put your name on the list. ow, my toe. let's eat, kids. semi, let's eat. i'm so hungry.

oh semi, can't you tie your hair up for school? leave me alone. having curls gives me confidence. a student should look like a student. you don't know anything. you sound like an old woman again. i'll let it slide because this tastes good. everything tastes so good at our house.

right? nothing beats home cooking, right? nothing. but why don't people know that? it's so upsetting. why do you say that? is something wrong? yeah. some big company might start supplying the hospital with food. really? which company?

does that sound good to you? of course it does. a big company probably makes tasty food. i should eat at your cafeteria more often. me too. me too. a big company isn't always the best. why not? i don't like big companies. my dad's dry cleaning business

lost customers to a large franchise that set up shop next door. is that why your family went bankrupt? if you don't want to be late for school, you have to finish breakfast in 5 minutes. move it! wait for me. wait. please wait. please. please.

why are people so heartless? sir. good morning. are you not feeling well? i'm fine, sir. you don't look good. you should take time off if you're unwell. you should take a sick leave. thank you for your concern,

but this is a company i am devoted to. over my 35 years, i was never late nor have i ever taken a sick day. this is my floor. excuse me, sir. - have a nice day. / - you too. i really think you should take time off. i'm fine. good day, sir. he's planning to stay on until he croaks.

i'm kim at management. good morning. yes. not today... yes. yes. no, no. okay. got it. yes. good morning, mr. jeong. mr. ha, you're here early. are you unwell?

you look pale. actually, i was in an accident yesterday. - an accident? / - yes. i got hit by a car. i was flung into the air. you've never been in an ambulance, right? it was my first time in one. so i was taken to the er, and they said i needed to be hospitalized for a week.

but i have a job, so that wasn't feasible. despite their insistence, i told them i had to work and left. when do you plan to revise this? by this evening, sir. get this revised quickly and report it to me. yes, mr. kim. - call them, mr. ha. / - yes, mr. kim. this is kim.

i'm sorry. there was a small mistake. we'll send you the revised version shortly. what brings you here, mom? i ran into mr. jo at the office. you're signing a deal with seorim hospital? why bother? catering is what our company does. seorim isn't a conglomerate.

it's not even a university hospital. it's a hospital that our company sponsors. there's no reason not to work with them. you must work with bigger clients for the company to recognize you. my engagement saved the company. what more do i have to do? so when should we have the wedding? mrs. ha wants to have it before the summer.

we'll talk once our company is back on track. ciao. buongiorno, signora. ciao, bello. i'm here to see ms. ko. is she in? yes. she's in her office. nice jacket. grazie. why is she being so nasty?

oh, my goodness. hello, mrs. ko. you're from ga-in... yes. i'm jeong huijin. every time i see you, i'm awed by your elegance. you flatter me. are the wedding preparations going well? let us know if we can help in any way. we will.

are you here to eat? i'm here to see ms. ko. it's just to touch base with a valued customer. go on up then. i will. have a nice day, mrs. ko. i hope to see you again. so classy. - please sit down. / - thank you. your mother seems to get younger by the day.

my mom loves to hear that. like all women. what brings you here? i came by to ask you for a favor. go ahead. my company is having a vip party next week, and i was wondering if we could have it here. who will be coming? this one's a get-together for doctors.

my brother will be attending, too. your brother's a member? it's only been a few days. i was waiting for him to become a fellow first, but our parents want him to get married soon. so have you found a good match for him? i'll be honest with you. we matchmake our members based on compatibilities between the partners.

but i have to admit, i'm guilty of being biased. there is a woman i have my eyes set on. i wonder what she's like. we'd be happy to provide the venue. you can discuss the details with our manager. thank you, ms. ko. i have an appointment outside. would you excuse me?

of course. right here. and please sign here. you too. yes. thank you, sir. no. thank you. now that we're getting 7-star rated food, i should eat at the cafeteria every day. we'll try to live up to your expectations.

wonderful. this isn't fair. they're signing with won's foods. really? oh, no. i was so worried that i asked the management department. they're signing the service agreement today. are we all getting fired?

this isn't right. i'm going to talk to the director. is anyone coming with me? oh, come on. ms. lee... are you serious? haesu, won't you come with me? me? come on.

let's go. hurry up. there they are. could you all come out? this way. please hurry. won's foods will take charge of the cafeteria. i was on my way to see the director. what business do you have with the director?

you can't change the system here without discussing the matter with us. but that decision is for the hospital to make. we may be employed by the hospital, but we're all certified cooks. but of course. without a cooking certification, you can't cook won's foods. look here.

there is a huge difference between the food mass-produced by a factory and cooked by us. it's just different. of course there is. that's why you need to receive training. training? the continuation of your employment will be determined by your performance. so we could get fired if we have low scores?

i wish you the best of luck. what... what kind of nonsense is this? it's absurd enough that we have to get training, but we could get fired if we don't do well? every company has regulations. regu... what do we get to eat today? yewon.

hello, doctor. this is absurd. how can they do this? what do we do? all for one, one for all. we're going on strike, so put up a sign. we can't let people go without food. don't play games with people's livelihood. not all of them can stay on anyway.

you always do whatever you want to, right? voluntary retirement? how dare you accuse him of such a thing? i was just asking. get out of here! a list of voluntary retirement applicants is up. i won't accept this. i'm not leaving. voluntary in name only,

out with voluntary retirement! out with voluntary retirement! haesu, what do you plan to do with the kids? they're my family. how are they your family? they're not related to you. then what is family to you, dad?

Monday, April 3, 2017

rent apartment cork


hello everyone. welcome to friday morning’sgoogle hangout. this is a live conversation discussing short-term rental regulations.and if you are joining us… the website is vacationrentalmag.com/strgooglehangout andi probably should have that in a form that i could put up on the screen. if you are joiningus either through facebook or through youtube you are welcome to keep watching there. ifyou want to join the conversation, we have a live chat roll on that website, vacationrentalmag.com/strhangoutand join us over there if you want to participate. looks like we already have some questionscoming up. michelle, we see your question. so, we are gonna go through just a very briefagenda. i’ll introduce my esteem panelists and we do have a q&a and we want to make sureto answer everybody’s questions and we’ll

get to that very shortly. let me jump in tothis and introduce my two guests. i’ve worked with these guys quite a bit, just great respect.these are fun folks but also they are probably the two best resources in the industry rightnow when it comes to understanding short term rental regulations. so, our first guest ismatt curtis. matt say hello. you’re on camera now. matt: hi everybody, good to see you. joel: matt is the director of government relationsfor homeaway and he was also recently elected to the board of the vacation rental managersassociation and he is just fresh from a flight back from nashville. so, matt, welcome. thanksfor joining us. our other guest is tim doyle

who is a spokesperson for str advocacy center.that’s stradvocacy.org. and str advocacy… he is gonna give us a more complete…well,tim, i’m gonna give you the floor. give us the fifty-thousand level view and in thethird segment we can go into more depth into about what great resource str advocacy is. tim: sure. good morning. good afternoon. stradvocacy.orgprovides resources to any stakeholder looking for information about short term rental regulations.specifically, we work with a lot of policymakers and people operating short term rentals tohelp them better understand what the laws are locally and how they can advocate forfair and reasonable regulations. it is a platform for folks that are trying to learn more, tryingto organize locally and trying to learn how

they can advocate for fairer and reasonablerules. joel: outstanding. alright. so, a brief lookin the agenda. we gonna break these essentially into three segments and then we have a q&a.first segment, matt is gonna talk about the current state of regulations. so, we gonnalook at what’s happening not only here in the us but around the world. there are conversationsthat are happening in a number of different places -- in new york, in madrid, all overand there are some great examples of communities that are doing the right thing but i thinkthe evidence really bares this out. there’s a way to look at short term rentals and whatregulations that are beneficial to all the parties involved and some really bad thingsthat just end up hurting everyone involved.

so, matt’s gonna talk about that for aboutten minutes. i’m gonna give a case study of what it actually looks like on the groundif you’re a manager or an owner. i think most people just want to do their businessand not be concerned with all these regulations stuff. i think the number one thing that bothmatt and i heard and probably tim as well when we talked to people about regulations,when they end up facing them, they always thought it could never happen to them, youknow, not here -- we’re not gonna face unfair regulations. so, we gonna talk about whatit really looks like on the ground when those things start to happen and we’ll give somepretty good examples of what we did in austin that was done well and some things that wedefinitely could have done a lot better. and

then the third segment -- and man do i wishthat there had been resources like str advocacy when we were having our battle here. the thirdsegment, tim is gonna talk about what new resources are out there particularly thisonline clearing house but also some… just some great case studies for how you can buildyour constituency locally, how you can find some common natural allies, and how you canjust walk yourself through this process. so, we are looking at somewhere around 30 minutesfor the program part and then we’ll open up for the questions, and then… we’realready seeing a bunch of questions pop up on the chat roll. so, we will try to answerevery single one of those. our hangout today is sponsored by vacation rental magazine.hopefully, if you signed up through the registration

you got your coupon for a free three-monthsubscription. we’re pushing the boundaries here technologically so we have a couple ofclips here from our sponsor. we don’t have any audio because we’re not able to workany audio working today but today’s hangout is sponsored by vacation rental magazine.it’s a gorgeous magazine. i hope you pick up a subscription. every issue takes you aroundthe world. we highlight beautiful, interesting, unusual vacation rentals around the worldand there are also travelers stories. any of these properties that are highlighted youcan actually click right through and find a listing on homeaway, vrbo or flipkey. andthere are also stories for owners about how to better manage your properties, everythingthat is happening in the industry is covered

in the magazine. so, that’s the bit fromthe sponsor. but let’s jump right here into this. matt, i’m gonna hand you the floorand you kinda give us the rundown of what’s going on with regulations around the us andaround the world. matt: you know it’s fascinating and thanksso much for having me on joel. this is just really fantastic. it is just fascinating situationbecause when you look at it there is clear best practice and there’s clear sweet spotfor a regulatory framework that can work for most communities and every community justcan augment it just a little bit to work well for them but what is very clear is that theregulatory framework that would best work for all stakeholders involved would have tobe something that is fair and reasonable,

easy to follow and allows the vacation rentalowner or manager to easily understand the rules and easily follow. and to achieve thati think there have been some discussions that have worked very well and some well-thoughtout regulations have come together but at the same time i think there have been somediscussions where the regulatory atmosphere got a little bit maybe down the wrong pathand the regulations that came together just don’t really work. so, want we want to dois talk about regulations that worked well. at homeaway and with short term rental advocacycenter, within the industry all around the world it seems that every time we have thisconversation, the best way to look at having a regulatory discussion is for it to startwith the managers or with the owners, you

know, with the stakeholders involved in thatcommunity. in one case, we actually had a situation wherein a former owner, a womanwho didn’t even own a home currently, she just got so involved in this conversationthat she actually put together the local alliance of stakeholders to go down to her local towncouncil and have this conversation. so, what make cities that are small, medium and large?there are some regulatory discussions that have happened in small, medium or large communitiesthat have happened outside of working with the stakeholders; so, not working with themanagers, not working with the owners, not working maybe with the travelers or otherpeople who are invested in short term rentals. then there are some communities that havedone great job of bringing all those stakeholders

to the table. and i think austin is a reallygood example of that. and to come and brought all those stakeholders from sort of outerring back into the inner ring, it actually included not just travelers and owners andmanagers, i guess to start with the outer ring. it really started with the economicdevelopment professionals in austin and the creative community -- the music, film andgaming community who used short term rentals -- the people who put together fast rolesand other events that use short term rentals. they got involved; the travelers were involved;and all of these were organized by a local alliance of owners and managers. that broughtall the stakeholders to the table to have the best possible conversation that we couldhave in austin. and we see that in some other

communities as well and sometimes it has workedout in advance enough so that the regulation that was able to come together was the bestregulation that could be. in some circumstances like the cuchara valley. so, these are townslike palm spring, palm desert, rancho mirage, indio and cathedral city, they had some prettysignificant regulations that were… which directly were short term rentals from thelate 1990’s to early 2000. so, they did not allow for rental or rent properties forless than 30-day stays. in the cuchara valley cities locked to this over a period of time.this is just to generalize lots of those communities. some of them even double down on that heavyheavy restriction and created even more owner restriction or even stronger fines to opposerentals of less than 30 days. in about 2009

or 2010, i think it was palm desert was thefirst one… i’m sorry, it was palm spring was the first city that come along and say,“hey, wait a second. we are trying to eliminate the ability for people to rent out their rentalproperty for less than 30-day stays to be able to do rent out vacation rental opportunitiesfor people for less than 30-day stays but at the same time what we’re missing outon is the opportunity for this industry to be transparent and above the radar and forthe industry to be able to pay their necessary hotel or transient occupancy taxes.” so,they came along, they created a regulation and you can find them on the short term rentaladvocacy website where people are allowed to register and pay their taxes. and whatdid you know? they started to make more money

than they were in fines and they were notspending as much in compliance aspect trying to regulate an activity that is… or restrictan activity that is very difficult to restrict. so, one by one, rancho mirage, palm desert,palm spring and the other cities have created good regulations that allowed folks to rentout properties for less than 30-day stays and each of those communities are benefitinggreatly from the transparent activity and from the taxes that are generated from theactivity such as transient hotel occupancy tax. that’s a small city example. mid-sizecity example if you want to look at maybe an example where this conversation got a littlebit more challenging is galveston, texas. in galveston, these conversations are goingon right now and early on when i talked to

some of the different stakeholders in galveston-- people from the city or people from the community down there or owners and managers.everybody seemed to think that clearly this is a common sense opportunity and they willfind a common sense solution and they develop a regulation that will work well but unfortunatelythe conversation got a little bit out of hand and later an owner and manager alliance, anowner alliance and manager alliance were part of galveston did form and has had some strongpositive response from the county to local town council and helping them to see what’sthe best practices are from around there and the rest of the country. there is an existingvacation rental manager association chapter in galveston and they have done a good jobin their area of galveston prior to this conversation.

and in big cities a little bit weird. in urbancities you can look at some examples and probably one of the most glaring ones is new york city.in 2010, new york banned short term rentals and was a state law. since 2010 there seemsto be multiple short term rentals that are in operation. you can find then in craigslistand different sites but those folks now are operating under the radar and not paying theirtaxes. in paris, the conversation has been very difficult. there is currently heavy restrictionagainst short term rentals and there are some conversations to restrict that activity evenfurther. however, we would see the same effect happen that activity would go under the radar,people would not be paying their local taxes and of course not being in compliance meansgreater other issues that could become even

more apparent like maybe not providing goodservice because they don’t have to worry about reviews because they are operating belowthe radar. so, looking backwards we’ll break about cities that have been regulatory discussionsrecently are berlin, munich, hamburg, frankfurt -- all if which are talking about some restrictionsright now. we are hoping that the owners and the managers’ groups that are coming togetherthere can help us convince those folks to find a best practice that could work for thosecommunities where the activity can start operating. in spain there is a potential for a nationallaw but madrid, the canary islands and the balearic islands were looking at restrictionson short term rentals. in catalona, however, there is a very good example of a regulationthat works. they put together a regulation

that allows folks to register and pay theirtaxes. they allow them to operate above the radar and we use that example often throughouteurope. in the united states… i’m sorry, i skipped over france. in france there isa discussion about a national law that would probably primarily affect paris. however,several different groups of owners and managers and stakeholders have been working on thatto try to positively affect that regulation as well. it seems that if you can get in frontof the decision makers early and discuss with them the positive effects of having a transparentindustry vastly outweighs the negative effects of having an industry that would probablystill operate under the radar. joel, i wonder if i could just go through a real quick withthe us. in the us there are several cities

that are discussing regulations. many of themare discussing regulations that would work and would be good for the community. manyof them are very restrictive. and i think a good place to look at the short term rentaladvocacy center website is to look at the us conference affairs policy that they unanimouslypassed in 2011, i believe. basically, what that said was key cities there is economicbenefit that comes from short term rental activity; there is a level of tourism andbusiness travel that comes through the short term rental activity that won’t come throughour hotels the same way. these are people who are staying for longer periods of timewith a larger group and it goes on talking about the value of having a transparent andabove the radar industry in the community

that you can work with rather than tryingto pretend it doesn’t exist, allowing it to go under the radar. so, in the united stateswe have some communities that are a little surprising that they have tried to restrictshort term rentals like sandusky, ohio or atlantic city, new jersey or saint joseph,michigan or even page, arizona. but for several communities they have had these discussionsand are finding positive results and i think some of them can be found in some discussions…i think working positive in action in oregon. in monterey, california there’s a conversationthat has been going on for a while i think some people quite described as have been challengingbut at the same time everyone has been open to the idea that there are best practicesand there is a common solution out there,

a common sense solution. so, i hope that answersat least some of the regulatory discussions that are happening around the country yetmy biggest challenge that i see, as joel alluded to, the number of owners or managers or travelerswho have said that “this will never happen in my town.” i usually hear that just afew months or a few weeks before they call me back and say, “hey, guess what?” thenumber of people who said, “we knew it’s gonna happen. we just thought we had moretime,” is also a big challenge for us. the best thing we see is to organize your localowners and managers alliance early, become an active part of your community and definethe message rather than let the message define you. alright joel, i turn over to you.

joel: yeah. well, it’s tough. well, i meanas an owner myself and i help manage a couple of properties and now have friends in austin,a pretty large group of people that have vacation rental properties, i think everyone wouldprefer just to manage your business day to day, bringing your guests in, giving greatservice and the idea that you are gonna spend a bunch of time running around city hall,you know…the natural tendency is just to hope that it just goes away. in my segmenti’ll talk pretty specifically what it kinda feels like on the ground as you should bepaying attention to those signals. but before we let you go matt, i want to get a perspectivefrom you because i know what those conversations look like, specifically in austin, you weretalking about when the conversation can start

to go the wrong direction, starts to go alittle bit or maybe very negative. what are some of the commonalities throughout the placesthat you are seeing that are having a challenge or talking about owners’ regulations. whatare the objections or what are the complaints that start this process rolling that peopleare looking to, you know, crackdown? there are problems. i think there are some commonalityto the perceived challenge of this type of rental property. matt: you know, i think that you are absolutelyright. i think that there is. well, i feel these conversations, whether it is in thecanary islands or in page, arizona this conversation starts with typically start with what peoplerefer to as nimbys -- not in my backyard folks.

and they tend to be people who -- i just sawsome last night in austin city hall -- people who do hang around in city hall usually arevery active in these discussions. and so when they hear about this going on in their communityor they see a regulatory discussion happening in another community they start that conversationin your community. the three probably common places where people seem to be settling arediscussions of how this is a commercial or spot zoning in a residential area that isa commercial activity in a residential area. another place might be how it affects affordablehousing and that could be two different ways. one is how it affects the overall cost ofyour neighborhood, the value of your neighborhood, and then two, in some communities, how ittakes away from affordable or from housing

stock thus driving the cost of housing loanand then the other one, is oftentimes, you’ll hear folks “we’re okay with primary homeowners renting versus people who own a secondary property, vacation property and renting outtheir home or vice versa.” that seems to be the three places where this gets startedand where often it goes bad is when the conversation goes for far too long. there are best practicesout there. there are places where both government decision makers can go to find information.and i think our short term rental advocacy center is one of those and then, of course,the stakeholders involved in this discussion can go and find that information. and i thinkthe more quickly people can educate on “hey, here’s what best practices look like. here’swhat works, here’s what doesn’t. here’s

the economic value,” and maybe do a littleeducation on what the industry is. i think the decision makers can more quickly findtheir answer but it’s one way operating in a vacuum that don’t have anyone givingthem education, they don’t know anything about the industry at all that maybe theymight turn to say, “hey, let’s form a working group or a task force or put thisinto a committee of the sub-committee of the city council for the next six months.” andthat allows for the conversation to be far more negative and a lot of misinformationto fester. i was gonna say very quickly the easy places to go against some of these argumentsare these are still residential use and that many people who are renting out their homesfor short term rents aren’t always running

out for short term periods of time. i knowin a lot of cities when we talk to owners and managers they will point out that theirproperties that they are renting, they are renting for sometimes 60 days, sometimes 45,which is typically a long-term rent but also sometimes less than 30 days. so, this is aresidential use that is not even a short term activity. there’s no study that says anythingother than almost for that fail the short term rental investments that people make intheir properties actually helped the property value. and of course, in communities wherefolks think that it’s taking away from the housing stock, especially that argument mightbe laid at the feet of secondary homes. remember these are secondary homes. these are homesthat people use for vacation not some investment

property. it’s not going back to the housingpool or else they are empty otherwise and not be contributing to the local community.and then finally, the primary versus secondary arguments, you know, we see the professionallyrun secondary homes operating very well. they see people renting out their primary homesworks well too. there is no example wherein if you try to have them restrict one or theother that they are still going to operate which is underground and then they are notcontributing to the community and paying their taxes. joel: perfect segway. thank you matt. so,i’m gonna talk just briefly and kinda share with the audience what happened on the groundon austin and i’ll just give it… i’ll

give the ending away by telling you rightnow the number one mistake we made, if i had to do it all over again, is that we didn’tget organized quickly enough and take these threats seriously enough and we also did nothave a resource like str advocacy. and i’m just so thankful that it’s out there nowfor the people that are facing conversations about regulations. but those are the two bigones. we had no model to look to but we also just did not take it seriously as i’ve said,you know. everyone at the... members of our ad hoc group at that point were having conversationswith one another. thankfully, we had a group of people online. thanks to a woman namedcindy hill here in austin. she had formed i think it was a yahoo group and so vacationrental owners and managers had discovered

each other online and we were sharing bestpractices -- how do write your contracts? who do you use for cleaning? does anybodyknow a good plumber? -- those sorts of things were the focus of that ad hoc group but westarted to… most of the neighborhoods in austin had some sort of a neighborhood listservand we started to see through people finding these conversations on their neighborhoodlistservs.. there were a couple of little neighborhoods that were having an issue withparty houses and so just as a heads up that's typically one of the ways that this will appear.there is a property that you know an owner may not be acting responsibly we certainlyhave to allow for that possibility. there are people who run furnished rentals, shortterm rentals who are bad neighbors, they’re

bad actors. they're typically a very ,verysmall number. i think the whole controversy in austin really stemmed from about five propertiesout of you know who knows how many hundreds of really good operators. but there were acouple of bad eggs and so we started to see these pretty angry posts thrown upon our neighborhoodlists, parties until three in the morning and this is a residential neighborhood. there'strash in the yard. there are people you know and some of them were pretty outrageous. guysdrunk late at night peeing on somebody's car. not something that anybody wants to experienceand our group response was to... i think we did a fairly good job of finding the ownersof these properties finding the neighbors who were affected, trying to mitigate thesituation, trying to help the owner be a better

neighbor. but those neighbors who were upsetconnected with one another and we just didn't pay close enough attention to realize thatthis was a dialogue that was starting to gain momentum until we started to hear from ourcity council that they were going put together a working group because there were peoplewho were asking to the council to do something about these problem properties. and what theywere asking was for the city council simply ban the process or ban the practice of rentingshort term. hey, matt looks like i’m gonna mute you for just a second... so that waswhat was happening on the ground. it sort of burst in neighborhood online lists butthen it made its way to city council and suddenly we had to deal with what was now politicalproblem. and i think i have told matt before

i think the low point for me was meeting oneof our council members and we had laid out a very clear argument about what these propertiescontributed to the local economy, how short term rental is almost invariably the nicesthouse on the block. how the use is without exception residential use. it’s not a commercialuse. it’s no different than a long term rental. and he looked at me and he said , “yes,absolutely i understand your arguments. these are all great points and your problem joelis now you have a political issue. it has gained momentum and you need to solve it politically.so what we ultimately had to do was form a real organization, you know an official non-profit.we formed the austin rental alliance. we brought in owners. we brought in managers and thenwe had to mount what ended up being a year

and a half long campaign of going to all ofthese stakeholder meetings but also going in meeting individually with each one of thecity council members. meeting with the planning and zoning commission and laying out a veryclear argument for all of these different folks about again how much short term rentalcontribute to the economy, how the uses is not commercial no matter how many times ouropponents tried to characterize it that way. know what people were doing in the house wedemonstrated was sleeping and eating and watching tv and that it’s a residential use. we hadto go make those arguments in front of the council in front of all these different constituenciesand it was really a long process. and so again what i’ve been telling people consistentlyif you are if you are starting to hear these

things take it very seriously and get organized.find the other owners in your area if you don’t have an organization form one. ifyou do, make sure that you’re communicating and that all of your members are paying attentionto your local listservs. because it really just takes one or two problem properties fora group of people to get together and decide that this is their next cause l'assureur.mat talked about people who are here in austin who frequently go down to our city hall. thosesame people are down there protesting something new now. we just happened to be their causeat that particular point in time but they’re dedicated. i mean they are, they were downthere at every meeting they had people lined up. they had talking points, they had scheduling,they were absolutely very, very involved locally.

and i think probably every city around theworld has people who are to their credit they are very concerned about their community buti think they fundamentally misunderstand what short term rentals are because the argumentsthat they kept bringing to city council were you know these are cover for drug runners,these are you know really just a cover for brothels. they’re nothing but party houses.and we had to, you know the other piece that i think we did really well and i’ll seeif i can i might be able to bring out some of these videos. see if i might even be ableto bring out some of these videos . the other piece that we did very well was bringing insome of the people who use short term rentals. and it was grandmothers visiting their kidsin the neighborhood who didn’t have enough

room. it was, you know, professionals whowere coming to either do business in austin or they’re looking to relocate here. itwas ut alumni coming back for a long game weekend. it was really everything except thekind of bad actors and party crew that we kept on being characterized as. so to sumagain, to sum again have your feelers out there, be paying attention, paying very closeattention on what’s happening on your neighborhood listservs . organize all of your owners. getsome sort of a group together; if you don't have one, the short term rental advocacy,i going to turn the table over to tim in just a moment, but str advocacy is a phenomenalplace to find other owners and to start a local chapter if one doesn’t exist . andthen there are a number of different case

studies up there that will walk you throughin much more specificity than i can go into in a you know 15 or 30 minute hangout aboutthe tools that are available to you and the steps that you can take. the last piece thati am going to share here and again we're pushing the edge technologically i am going to seeif i can make this happen. do you guys see a video here on your screen, matt and tim? matt: no. joel: no you do not. allright. i going tohit play and we’ll see if this works or not. matt: hey joel, while you do that i am goingto shout out that we formed a local alliance

where we get other people rally together.it just means less work on you. all of a sudden you've got, you've got you know dependingon the size of the town you've got four, five , ten other friends who are working with youto help you know find out what's going on at city hall. hear about things, to rallysupport. it's just more help for you so it’s a great thing to do. joel: absolutely. i'm going to give this ashot here and see if i can play this video back. just a couple of examples and one ofthe things that i think really had an impact on our council members was bringing in examplesof who's actually using these property, who would be affected by the regulations thatwere being proposed and so those were four

to five videos that we shared that had youknow highlights from the neighbors, highlights from business travellers who were coming into town. and then there were even some videos that we did with the local art community.just showing the support for the art community and also highlighting with those natural allies.the hotel occupancy tax that we’re collecting as vacation owners goes to directly supportthat community so that's just a quick overview. i think tim has a bunch of more in-depth andgreat examples on the str advocacy site so i am going to hand the floor over to tim. tim: sure. well can you see my screen joeland matt? joel: yeah. absolutely.

tim: so the short term rental advocacy centeris again really meant to be sort of a resource center for policy makers and specificallyshort term rental operators and we have three sort of big pillars in terms of trying towork with people, trying to educate them and trying to help them organize and win fairlyreasonable regulations in their community. so the first pillar hear would be learn. soyou just click on the learn tab. this is at stradvocacy.org. so here we have at the topour fact sheet, very useful to show people our best practices, these are some of thebest. it has some specifics about you know presenting this to policy makers, gives themsome specifics about you know what are in terms of the creation of legislation and ordinances.what thing sort of work the best and then

we have a series of case studies here thatall connect to a presentation that walks through some places and some approaches that havebeen incredibly effective and this is palm desert, california being one of them thatmatt talked about earlier. we also have some videos here. this is the video here that joelwas just referencing of some very short clips from folks in austin, texas talking aboutthe use or their use of short term rentals or this guy specifically appears as a neighborwho of the house next door he was very much in favor of being a short term rental andthen we also have some previous webinars and here a great example of the blue ridge lodgingassociation in blue ridge, georgia that sort of has done a tremendous job in terms of organizingthe short term rental operators in that community.

we also have some stories from policymakersand folks on the ground about you know bringing about really effective legislation and ordinances.the next pillar would be connect that is and this goes back to what joel talked about youknow the number one thing you can do, you know. whether you are concerned about shortterm rental regulation in your community or you’re facing an imminent threat is to forma local group of folks this is typically not a very large group but somewhere between anywherefrom 6 people to 2 or 3 dozens and what happens there is... and that is really how you wouldgo about through the organizing and approaching your city about through the value of shortterm rentals. so here we have maps you can punch in your zip code and look up if thereis a group near you. we only have about 22

on our site right now but are looking to addmore and more every day. and then here we have if you click on this and you will seea guide about how to start a group. typically these groups are formed typically as googleor yahoo groups which give people a very easy ability to email everyone in their group strikeup conversations and then once people create groups they can submit them here. we put themon our map and then we work with homeaway and other companies that are in our groupto make sure everyone locally knows about it. and, lastly we have just a feature herewhere people can submit their email address we send out a monthly newsletter that sortsof highlight things going on, how to implement these steps better so on and so forth andjust give you some good tips and tricks. lastly

we have act. once your group is formed whatdo you do? how do you approach your city? what are the most important things? we havea 6 step advocacy guide here. so this about how you learn about short term rentals youknow for instance step 1 and step 2 how do you learn about the laws near you and howdo you calculate the impact of short term rentals. so this, you click on this righthere give you more detail. the one example we cite here is a small community in floridacalled lake worth. they calculated that just 50 short term rentals created $3.5 m in spendingevery year. once they formed get that number together and try to advocate to the localgovernment. they're incredibly effective in terms of having those numbers having themsome materials together. so again here we

go through how do you craft your argument,what materials do you need to get together once you approach h your city? here are the5 things we suggest but by no means you can follow them. and then we have some more informationabout how you talk to local officials, how do you deal with the media, how can you leverageup ads and interactions with the local newspapers or broadcasters and then six it's just sortof sum everything up in terms of the need to really be persistent and as joel alludedto, how to cultivate champions for your cause, try to find third party voices that can speakabout the importance of short term rentals and what they bring to our local community.so that is sort of a quick guide if you ever have any questions about you know forminga group or some of thespecific steps we are

always here to sort of work with folks onthe ground. we work with people all the time. the easiest way to get in touch with us isjust to email us at info@stradvocacy.org and we'll get back to you as soon as we can. joel: outstanding. and there are definitelyquestions right now. so i think we should you know perhaps go ahead and jump in intothe q and a and i’ll just try to open this up and you guys both jump on them or takeone that seems to appeal to you. one of the first questions is, what is the first stepto fighting owner's regulations that are already in place? so for cities that already havepassed either an outright ban or maybe they just made it very, very restrictive, they’vemade it difficult to get registered to comply.

what are, what are the first steps? tim: i would say you know obviously forminga group again is always sort of the first step. when there are laws in the books thatare owners restrictive or an outright ban i think that some of the steps we have inour guides still sort of apply. it is important for you to get your materials together, tryto figure out what the impact is on your community and the importance of it. obviously it isa more difficult situation than if you’re, if it’s something your town's consideringor something that’s you know far down the road. but you know matt spoke about this earlieryou know presenting and talking about some of the case studies of places that had restrictiverules and then went out and created something

that is a little more fair and reasonablesuch as palm desert, palm springs, california are great examples of, you know, these arecities that have laws that didn’t work. they made some changes and they started toreap some humongous economic benefits and frankly that was a solution that worked alot better in terms of, you know, wrapping their arms around the issue what they perceivedas an issue with short term rentals. matt: you know, i just want to chime in fora quick second because i think that's very important. i'll make out an example. it willbe a far-fetched example but what to say have scranton, pennsylvania. i have no idea ifthey have restriction or not. i can imagine they do but to tim's point organizing is thebest first step in finding even this one or

two other people like yourself. the shortterm rental advocacy center, homeaway, and other companies like ours will email peoplewho list in that area as a way of notifying them that that group like yours has formedand we have seen in some communities groups grow from just a couple of members one ortwo to groups having dozens of members a week later after receiving that email and findinga place online where they can organize with you may be on facebook or if you create awebsite. so that would be the first step is to organize and just quickly go into whatthe immediate next step would be is you have all these information out there for you. nowthat i am a new member of the vacation rental managers association, there is a lot of informationon that website if you are a main website.

of course the short term rental advocacy center,homeaway itself and you can look at joel’s website of how they kind of got organizedfrom the austin rental alliance and many other places and i think finding the us conferenceof mayors resolution. here's the largest group of elected officials that get together andvote on policy that are facing urban areas around the country and they agreed unanimouslythat this is the best way to handle short term rental. this is hundreds of mayors whovoted on this. so i think the idea of organizing and gathering your information should quicklymove into how do you use it. that’s one thing we did not mention. but i suggest everyoneput every decision you make through a very simple filter of are we being transparent?are we being positive? are we being solutions

oriented? and are we being data driven? andthe reason for that is as joel discussed your opponents are almost without fail going tobe negative, they are going to obfuscate for their real purposes, they’re not going comewith the solution. their solution is going be just ban the activity which is not a realisticsolution. and they are going to operate from a point of emotion and not from data. andone quick last thing is if we can have fun with this. we’re frankly getting organizedearly really helps is if you do want to use data add a little of anecdotal informationto sell your point and you are from scranton, pennsylvania, you are organized , you’vebeen somewhat active with you know maybe chamber of commerce issues that relate to housingor anything you may care about. maybe somewhat

active with the local real estate councilon any issues that they are discussing. well then you may know that the end of the budgetseason what to say that the scranton city council got to the end of their budget andthey were starting to really cut into the bone on the budget there and they are sayingwe cannot fund this $150,000 improvement to this park or you know this $ 290,000 improvementto our local civic arena.what’s great about that is when you use your data and use someof the information that tim has talked about or joel has talked about and you develop yourown economic analysis. now you are able to come back and say, “you know what we doas vacation short term rental owners and operators who bring people into this community as faras paying taxes and the direct and indirect

economic impact of our activity? it’s millionsof dollars. so when you were discussing the $ 290,000 budget item or the $150,000 budgetitem proper regulation of our industry and proper partnership with our industry can benefitthis community to the tune of millions of dollars.” and it always does. tim: and to that point i do not want to taketoo long but it's sort of an amazing transformation too when a local city official hears thatin the context of keeping their job or not keeping their job because that's often whatpeople, it's on the table given how constrained local and state government policy is. joel: yeah. and there’s just aren’t manyindustries where the constituents come in

and ask to be regulated but i think that hashappened enough times now. there's clearly a trend of that because there is such a benefitto good regulations. there are so many clear examples of that. one of the other questionsis: can you provide an example of good ordinances? that's a question for both of you. tim doesstr advocacy have sample regulations? tim: yeah. i would encourage folks toi wasgoing to pull it off for a quick start. if you see on our main page i talked about thelessons learned presentation we have. so this is a presentation that walks through, hassome general information about the short term rental industry but has very specific examples.here's one about palm desert, about how they passed owners’ rules and then sort of switchedand cared for something that was much more

strict before. we have a quote here from theprincipal planner about why that was such a good change. yes, we do have examples ofgood regulations here. we also talk about just get to know a little bit about the rulingin atlantic city that basically found that the city was wrong to try to go after "absentee"owners. some great resources here and there’s also an example here, this is not really aboutthe regulation but about a group of owners in blue ridge, georgia that organized createda very formidable organization and also includes the professional association of innkeepersinternational about a favorable decision they made about short term rentals and finallythe us conference of mayors resolution that matt talked about earlier.

joel: wow. those are great examples. okayone question that stands out. briefly it says can we show a youtube of this hangout we arehaving right now to our constituents right now? absolutely so... there will also be anemail about a replay but this will also live on youtube. so, i will make sure that allof the participants probably post upon this page if you are watching on vacation rentalmagazine page. i was going directly to that. i suppose tim you may also do something. puta link up. tim: yeah. yeah. it will definitely be postedwithin the next few days or week at stradvocacy.org/learn. joel: great. okay. one of our next questionsis about hoas. how can we have influence over hoa boards that rewrite the by-laws in orderto restrict short term rentals?

tim: hoas are definitely a different and abit more difficult of a situation but i would say some of the principles in terms of howyou know approach these board members. approach them and talk about the value of short termrentals is very similar to the way you should do that with local policymakers. unfortunatelytypically those in many scenarios hoas have boards that sort of rule a bit more firmlyi would say and not sort of in line with the principles of our democracy but i think thatyou know gathering a group in your hoa that is in favor of short term rentals you knowproviding some good examples of what they’re doing to the community. you know, a lot oftimes getting some testimonials from the neighbors saying they never had a problem with noiseor anything along those lines i think all

of those things would help tremendously tofinding and getting to some rules that everyone can live with. joel: yeah, i know they’re tricky. mattwe are talking about hoas and the question is for hoas that are trying to rewrite theirby laws or maybe they already have their by laws that are very restrictive to rentingfor less than 30 days any insight there into how somebody can deal with that. i know whenwe had the panel in las vegas at rezfest cindy goslin had so much interesting things to sayabout hoas from your perspective any thoughts? matt: you know one of the things, i don’tknow if we’ve been given adequate background of cindy goslin but she was a former citystaff for palm springs who helped rewrite

their ordinance and helped all the... valleyrewrite their ordinances to become far more effective. one of the things that she saidi think was like with hoas just like with cities , over-restriction of this is justgoing to drive the industry underground. people will to participate in the activity. so, youknow, i don’t know what the right answer is but you know some hoas have such prettyinteresting thinking on this. they made a lot of policies some policies internally thatdraw a lot of people to essentially register with the hoa. just to file the little thingand say, “hey, i am gonna be renting my property for short term rent and if you needto get hold of me for any reason here’s a contact number.” and the hoas also cametogether and said, “look, if you gonna to

rent your property for short term rent thenyou must realize that we may have an issue with increased need to monitor and be concernedabout the maintenance of the facility and potentially the security we’ll ask for a$ 50, $ 200 a year fee for registering your property within that building. we heard greatsuccess from that particular property. the people said, “hey, that’s great we hada little fee we had to pay to participate because of there were some members of thecommunity that were concerned. those concerned didn’t have any real data to support thembut they were willing to pay a small fee to placate those concerns and then of courseyou know being able to continue to register their home and provide a 24-hour or have sometype of contact number or have a manager who

had a contact number. a lot of homeownersfeel comfortable in fact with that activity was going to occur. they wind up working forthat particular hoa. i think what’s cindy’s point is, what my thought is that it stillhappens anyway. it’s been incredibly difficult and very unbelievably expensive to try toenforce this activity so the easy thing is to create a program that is very easy forpeople to participate. joel: that makes perfect sense. one of myfavorite programs now is boardwalk empire because its partly because steve buscemi isvery amazing but we brought out the volstead act with city council and i think a few ofthem laughed. but there’s a lot of validity to that. when there’s an activity whetheryou like it or not if there is an activity

that the seller is going to benefit from financiallyand that the buyer is very interested in and that is certainly the case with short termrentals, vacation rentals then it’s going to happen whether cities want to be involvedor not it’s going to happen and just like prohibition people didn’t stop drinkingit just gave power to criminal elements it basically made a bunch of law abiding citizensinto criminals. and i think from the examples that i have seen and talking to vacation rentalowners around the us and around the world, the cities that have tried to enforce a banfail miserably but they also completely lose the money. so i think the money is not onlya piece when you are talking to cities that already have owner’s regulations in placeit’s certainly something that you can bring

in as your supporting evidence for why goodregulations make sense. again into matt’s point in the situation of an hoa i have severalowners that i have worked with that have been facing issues with their hoas, hoas have eventhreatened to sue her they have actually initiated a lawsuit and they lost. i am not providinglegal advice but i have certainly seen a number of situations wherein an hoa is trying tolimit the rights that someone has in terms of how they can rent their property almostinvariably those lawsuits end up being very expensive lawsuits and the hoa ends up losing.so had cindy talked about it for a little bit we might have another hangout and haveher involved. one let’s see a couple of other questions that have come up here. sorryi didn’t see the name, michael: “as a

management agency we’ve seen a lot of undergroundrentals in our community that are not [i am going to paraphrase a little bit around here]they are not following local regulations, they are not paying their taxes. they listwith vrbo and flipkey and other websites how can we work with these listing sites to ensurethat everyone that rents through them, how do we help them ensure that their customersare following regulations”. matt: you know i’ve had a lot of thoughton that one and a lot of success with it too and my suggestion to michael again is to goback to our suggested first place to start which would be to organize a local alliance.i think what joel will tell you is they have had a whole lot of luck with compliance inaustin and self-regulation among the industry

by forming an alliance and then people tendto say, “hey i know joe down the street who is doing this or i know my cousin hasa best friend who is engaged in this activity. we can get him involved and then of coursewe can make sure they are following all the local regulations. so step 1 would be to formthat alliance and the other step is to go out there and gather the information and resourcesthat are available to you and that would mean homeaway, vrbo, tripadvisor, flipkey and othercompanies that are willing to email their listings in that area and let them know ifthere are regulations in place here’s maybe a link to those regulations and there’slocal owners and managers alliance that has formed and here’s how you can find out moreabout it. that usually has the great benefit

of driving a lot of people who probably arejustunaware to being aware. and then from there that’s a good place to start. youknow we want people to abide by local regulations, that’s very important to us but the unfortunateaspect of a lot of regulations are that they don’t always make sense. they’re hardto read, they’re hard to understand. there’s not a lot of uniformity in this industry atthe local level around the world to the language that’s used for that sort of things so ithink a good place to start is organize that local alliance and then you can start withthe information gathering, the resources and the self -regulation. tim: yeah i want to also i want to just quicklyadd i think places that have enjoyed the best

compliance are also… this is more sort ofabout the local regulatory environment. the places that have sort of the simplest againand easiest to understand rules, and then governments that are proactive in reachingout to folks about paying taxes, the need to register are the ones that sort of usuallyhave the highest compliance. one quick example there would be okaloosa county florida thatis the area in northwest florida known for its very nice beaches. the town destin isthere which is something people are familiar with and they’ve been doing this since 2005.they have one employee who just works on this issue and spends one day every week goingout in the field to go into people’s houses telling them about the laws, telling themabout the need to register. this has to happen,

this has to happen. it’s not hostile. it’snot you owe for the last five years but they get everyone to start paying and i think inthat time span i am ball parking these figures here they went from a million or two dollarsof revenue in 2005 to over 13 million dollars revenue from transient occupancy taxes i believein 2012 we have that information up on our site if you want to check it. it is in thepresentation i have just talked about. but i think it’s a great example of being proactive,being easy to understand local government and that kind of outreach in general is whatleads to best results. matt: you know joel, i don’t want to expandon this too much but tim had a really good point about okaloosa.it reminded me of somethingyou know the woman who is in charge of the

okaloosa situation recognizes that a heavyhand and strong enforcement will not raise what she calls the lawn money in the hoteloccupancy tax and the compliance that you get from people being engaged in her program.when i talked to her about other communities around the world that feel like heavy fines,hiring more enforcement officers to try to enforce heavy restrictions they wind up sayingreally strong negative, negative in the overall cost of the owner of the program because ofthe salaries that are included for those enforcement officials and the cost of running that programin a very heavy handed manner. she has found a whole lot of luck as tim laid out aboutby being far more positive promoting the industry, promoting the activity but at the same timebringing people in their regulatory environment

in a very positive manner. joel: and as alluded to that i think we certainlysaw that here in austin as we were going through our challenge. once we were organized as anofficial non-profit one of the things that we had to do was phone tree simply puttingdown lists of people we knew out there who are renting and then we would sit down andeach of us would make 4 or 5 phone calls. it was very positive supportive and just lettingpeople know that they needed to be involved and that they needed to be also you know forus at that point the number one thing we had going for us was that the prerequisite formembership in the austin rental alliance was being compliant with your hotel occupancytax and just making people aware. and there

was a pretty astounding level of i don’twant to call it ignorance you know misunderstanding about hotel occupancy even within our cityofficials but also to people who were operating as hotel rental owners. so that educationaleffort was probably the best things that we did to bring people into the fold and alsogrow the ranks of the austin rental alliance. so, hopefully that was an answer that youcan take... actually that was an answer. we’re coming up on top of the hour here. i thinkwe just have one or two more questions and i think we have kind of addressed this onethem was what is being done internationally regarding regulations? i think matt you havegiven a pretty good rundown of you know the challenges that you are keeping track of andtim talked about some groups that are forming

around the country. anything else you wantto discuss about what is happening internationally? matt: well, internationally there are actuallya couple of interesting things happening. these are strong enforcement right now inpanama of the not less than 45-day rental regulation. again what we gonna do is tryto help people organize local owners and managers alliances there and why that is because weknow people who are on the ground locally who are voters, property taxpayers involvedin their community are gonna have much better luck with their local elected officials thanpeople who come from another town. we’ve seen some regulatory discussion in columbia,in the philippines and of course i had the discussion about europe. europe is probablythe most dense area with the most activity.

that’s why we have seen the most owner manageralliances in each of these major cities formed and then of course even a pan european associationhas formed called the ehha. don’t ask me what that stands for but they have been helpfulwonderful people. it’s the european holiday homes association if i remember correctly.and the vrma frankly is also very engaged in that discussion at the pan-european level.again the regulations on the local level but we are trying to organize and discuss in thepan-european level because then we can identify best practices. joel: tim, anything else? tim: no, i have nothing to add to that, mattis the expert on international.

joel: very good. we just have one last questionthat popped up and i don’t know that we can offer a lot of help here. jason says,“i have a legitimate short term rental. it’s licensed. i am paying my taxes butit’s currently anything less than twelve months is not allowed by my hoa. jason ifyou just joined us we had talked a fair amount on how you can talk to hoas. it really isprobably something that you‘ll have to engage an educational process with that hoa becauseit’s you know there are by-laws for every hoas some of them it just depends on you knowhow i guess how enthusiastic they are about enforcing. but you can certainly use the toolsthat are available on stradvocacy.org. an earlier part of this hangout there was a prettylong discussion about how to deal with hoas

so we encourage you to grab the replay andtake a look at that. all right we’re exactly on the hour here and i think we’ve answeredall of our questions. this hangout will be available as i said we’ll put the link upon this page there’ll also be a link that tim going to put out on stradvocacy.org. iwill just quickly acknowledge my two guests here and we’ll wrap this up. tim, thankyou so much for joining us and any final words? tim: thank you. this has been great. againi encourage people to check out our site and again if you have any questions about what’sgoing on locally and your campaign feel free to email us at info@stradvocacy.org. joel: and man i wish that resource had beenaround when we were going through our challenge

here in austin. mr. matt curtis you are aboard member str guru extraordinaire any final words? matt: yeah. organize, organize, organize.use the free resources that are out there starting with stradvocacy.org and the us conferenceof mayors policy is written as if it was written from somebody within the industry. and whenyou look at each individual line feel free to quote from each individual line and usethat to present to your local decision makers about how these regulations can be formedin such a way that it is good for everyone. joel: and i will steal this directly fromyou matt, positive, data-driven, solutions oriented and transparent. that’s it forour hangout. we are hosted today my vacation

rental magazine if you did not get the linkplease just send me a not to joel@vacationrentalmag.com and we’ll make sure that you have a complimentarysubscription. we thank you for joining us. all right. have a great friday. matt: thank you everyone.